9 ms·
Samba 4.0 released
- RyanZAG 14y agoOne more stake in Microsoft's coffin? With their Win8 tablet/mobile strategy not doing too great and rapidly improving office alternatives... Is the MS legendary lock-in cracking apart?
- shmerl 14y agoYou can the deterioration of DirectX domination in the gaming market.
- shmerl 14y agoI mean "you can add".
- flyinRyan 14y agoWhat has overtaken it? Open GL? Got any citations on that because that wasn't my impression at all.
- shmerl 14y agoThe rise of mobile gaming and more interest in MacOSX and Linux brought more attention to OpenGL, SDL and etc. It definitely threatened the dominance of DirectX. Practical example: http://en.thewitcher.com/forum/index.php?/topic/33183-red-engine-and-opengl-support/page__p__897129 http://en.thewitcher.com/forum/index.php?/topic/33183-red-en...
- dsr_ 14y agoThere are few people running Windows AD who are going to view this as their next step, largely because they've already become used to running those Windows boxes. For groups who aren't fully invested in AD, or need compatibility with those who are, this is a major win.
- josemariaruiz 14y agoMicrosoft AD is the ONLY reason many companies (Apple shops included) have Microsoft servers. People cannot imagine how disruptive is a fully operational Samba 4.0 AD for Microsoft. (like a fully operational space station with a planet destroying laser :p)
- fleitz 14y agoIf you can offer AD as a service you could setup a tidy business, otherwise not very many people are going to look at this. Small companies don't have the expertise, large companies can't afford the risk.
- vy8vWJlco 14y agoNever underestimate the power of "free, as in cheap." :)
- jmspring 14y ago"free, as in cheap" does not apply in the case of an existing infrastructure with staff already trained on using the deployed (AD) system.
- josemariaruiz 14y agoCan you imagine offering a fully scalable AD online? Having access to the code you can start doing things that Microsoft never allowed you to do ;) (Google Docs is, as far as I know, OpenOffice for example)
- jiggy2011 14y agoI'm not much a Windows guy, but is this really a full drop in replacement for all AD features?
- josemariaruiz 14y agoDuke Nukem forever... Samba 4.0... what's the next? A GNU/Hurd competitor to Ubuntu? Space travels to Pluto? Time machines?
- jf 14y ago> A GNU/Hurd competitor to Ubuntu? Well, there is this: http://www.debian.org/ports/hurd/ http://www.debian.org/ports/hurd/
- josemariaruiz 14y ago"Get Xorg + gnome/kde/xfce (xfce should work, kde is missing working dbus (due to local socket auth and bugs in select() cornercases)) + some webbrowser working (iceweasel 9 works, though not https)." From GNU/Hurd TODO list :)
- pyre 14y agobugs in select() cornercases is the thing that stands out to me. Seems like I would want select() to be pretty solid to consider this a viable alternative.
- duskwuff 14y agoHURD can largely be regarded as a cruel joke. It's been under development for over twenty years (since 1990!) without yet producing a usable product. Pretty much every operating system kernel that's in use today (Linux, the BSD family, Windows NT, and XNU) is younger than HURD, and yet far more mature.
- papsosouid 14y agoIf you are measuring the current hurd kernel's age as starting from 1990, then the BSD kernels are far older, not younger. The initial release was in 1977, and obviously development started before that. That said, hurd is essentially abandoned at this point. Even RMS has accepted that it will never be completed, and has said that it really doesn't matter since there's already a free kernel available (linux).
- molf 14y agoThis is fantastic. Microsoft Active Directory is truly awesome, but a replacement that is both free and runs on Linux? Yes please.
- Osmium 14y agoAny news on if Samba 4.0 is still single-threaded? (the page isn't loading for me) I recently wanted to use Samba, but was limited by performance on a low-end dual core processor: it'd max out one core, and be unable to use the other. I'm sure they have (or have had) good reasons for not doing this, but with so many low-power multicore processors out there now it seems a shame...
- cryptomilk 14y agoSamba has a flexible process model so you can choose what you want: forking, preforking, threading (bad) or a single (for debuging) process model.
- sk5t 14y agoAs probably one of the more AD-focused participants on HN, I have to approach this with a good dose of skepticism w.r.t. large companies adopting Samba for complex AD environments. AD + DFSN + (DFSR|NTFRS) + LDAP + SSL + RPC + NTP + GPO + CIFS + NTFS + SDDL + WMI + ADWS + etc., is an extremely complex set of stuff to implement, and the cost of supporting a third-party version could, IMHO, easily dwarf the cost of a few Windows licenses to run the domain controllers. So many examples come to mind that it is hard to pick just one or two... consider an organization that configures access to Windows event logs (audit trails) and SMB signing requirements via GPO; will Samba 4 Domain Controllers honor that? What does it even mean to have access to modify the security auditing policy on a Samba DC without totally reimplementing the eventing system (syslog is not even close)? In other words, AD sits on top of a ton of mature but sophisticated Windows services, the failure of any of which could be a critical problem, and make for a tough sell unless one has a pathological hatred of Microsoft yet still wishes to use AD anyway.
- tptacek 14y ago... and if you have enough control over your environment to replace Windows Server as a domain controller, why would you be using the AD stack to begin with?
- sk5t 14y agoAye, if one has that much motivation to chuck Windows for AD, then it's only logical that Windows on the desktop, Exchange, etc., are not on the scene. I've done a lot of work with other directory servers too, and AD does the best job of any when it comes to multimaster replication and a few other things. However, using it purely for LDAP for an environment full of Linux and OS X machines is a tough call...
- rufugee 14y agoWhy? I have such motivation, yet I have no intent on eliminating Windows from our desktops. That would be very disruptive to our 2.5K users, and Windows does a pretty decent job there. However, AD is very pricey due to CALs, and what it gives me is IMO not worth the price if I can replace it with Samba 4. That said, we're only beginning to explore this option, so it may not be viable or wise.
- polarix 14y agoLast time I tried to use Samba 4, earlier this year, most of the config directives I was trying to use weren't supported. Has that changed?
- mrb 14y agoYes. Except the one you had on line 42. Seriously, how do you expect someone to give you a useful reply?
- obituary_latte 14y agoWell, if the current version is any indication... Fortuitously for this article, I've spent the entire day today trying to get samba sharing with AD. Oh, NT_USER_NOT_PERMITTED? Bbbut, the user is there; I even have it working on another server! I'm sure it's my fault, but still, as of this moment, I hate samba more than almost everything. At any rate, congrats.
- japaget 14y agoLink is down; here is an alternative: http://www.samba.org/samba/history/samba-4.0.0.html http://www.samba.org/samba/history/samba-4.0.0.html
- thyrsus 14y agoThanks for that. The error I get when attempting to go to the original URL ( https://www.samba.org/samba/news/releases/4.0.0.html https://www.samba.org/samba/news/releases/4.0.0.html ) is Cannot communicate securely with peer: no common encryption algorithm(s). (Error code: ssl_error_no_cypher_overlap) I went to about:config and turned on all the default-disabled ssl ciphers (per https://support.mozilla.org/es/questions/818578 https://support.mozilla.org/es/questions/818578 ) but it didn't resolve the trouble. UPDATE: I tried restarting my browser, and then it worked BUT after trying to do a binary search on which cipher setting was the "fix", I got to where everything was back to default, and the site still works. Probably there was a site problem that was fixed in the interim.
- madao 14y agoWhen people start mentioning price for these sorts of things I get a little confused, volume licensing for a bunch of hyper-v servers running 20-30 windows guests is actually quite cheap (you only have to pay for each licensed host server) I also have seen mention of a per user cost for ad? not sure where you got that from... I think exchange goes for about 6 bucks a user or so.. the next office setup ill be looking at will be three beefy hyper-v servers and running most applications on windows core... windows is now getting to the point where the only time I need to do any work is for weekly windows updates.
- jeremiep 14y agoSome companies have more than 20-30 employees. All these "quite cheap" expenses quickly add up. This is money better spent towards getting a better product on the shelves. Now when you consider that managing unix machines requires much less work to begin with, you can't look at "quite cheap" the same way anymore - it's actually "quite expensive". Not to mention I often see improved performance of server applications just by switching them to a linux host. Samba 4 is indeed very good news.
- theatrus2 14y agoA 5-user CAL pack for Exchange is ~$400, about $75 per user. http://www.amazon.com/Exchange-Standard-2010-English-User/dp/B002NWWR5Y http://www.amazon.com/Exchange-Standard-2010-English-User/dp... A Windows server CAL is about $20 per device. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16832416558 http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16832416... Windows licensing is somewhat a mess, between user CALs, device CALs, processor CALs, or combinations thereof. You can see why Google's $50/user/year price is attractive - no hardware to buy, no CALs to buy, no client software to buy.