4 ms·
Ad hominem attacks are actually underrated. Like, why listen to bad people wanting you no good. It is a good shortcut. The failure is when it is used in bad fa
by rightbyte 4mo ago
Ad hominem attacks are actually underrated. Like, why listen to bad people wanting you no good. It is a good shortcut.
The failure is when it is used in bad faith. But that would apply to all techniques. LLMs are masters of bad faith discussions hiding misconceptions in optimal regression maths.
- chungusamongus 4mo ago[flagged]
- rightbyte 4mo agoAd hominem attacks attacks is often missused as a way to slander stating conflict of interests.
- chungusamongus 4mo agoThen just state the conflict of interest instead of resorting to insults. The problem with your way of thinking is, sometimes your opponent is detestable, but that doesn't make them wrong. Kneejerk dismissal of an argument on the basis of character can be self defeating. You do not want to reflexively dismiss a point that is potentially salient just because the person making it is potentially "bad."
- rightbyte 4mo agoSure from a philosophical standpoint I agree with you. But in practice you need to weight in trust. Bad faith retorics is just too expensive to engage. The main problem with ad hominem is when ot is used as "Mr Y agree with you. Mr Y is bad. You are wrong". Like, 2nd order ad hominem attacks?
- cindyllm 4mo ago[dead]
- chungusamongus 4mo agoYou have done nothing to demonstrate how that's even relevant here. The person who posted this is not "bad" simply because they have used an LLM.