4 ms·
Any data to back it up? I.e. any comparison, ceteris paribus, of Stanford MBA graduate income vs. other MBA graduate income and non-MBA graduate income that pro
by smsm42 14y ago
Any data to back it up? I.e. any comparison, ceteris paribus, of Stanford MBA graduate income vs. other MBA graduate income and non-MBA graduate income that proves, say, if we define "no time" as 5 years, that 5-year income of Stanford MBA graduate is at least 185K higher (after taxes, of course, so before taxes, given federal & California taxes, it'd be around 400K or 80K per year) than the income of other people mentioned above?
I imagine you should already have a substantial income to qualify even for 185K loan (in most places, it's a mortgage-size loan, with over 2K per month payments), let alone paying 185K in cash, so the improvement should be from the level of people that are already capable of spending 185K - i.e. either having current income substantially higher than, say, level of experienced software developer, or somehow having amassed 185K in cash that they can invest in their education.
- rayiner 14y agoGradPLUS loans = guaranteed to be approved unless you have major credit problems.
- smsm42 14y agoSo you're saying you can get 185K unsecured loan with no proof of income to back it up? I heard in some country they recently got into big problems with giving large loans to people that couldn't pay for it under the premise that the property they buy with these loans is going to raise in value so much that it will cover the loans anyway. But this time I'm sure it would work out just fine.
- rayiner 14y agoYes, and it's a bubble waiting to pop. It's alleviated somewhat by the high interest rates (8%) and non-dischargeability in bankruptcy, but yeah...
- kyllo 14y agoIt works in America because student loans are non-dischargeable. It doesn't matter if you are penniless and have filed for legal bankruptcy, the lender can still keep coming after you and even garnish your wages for the rest of your life. It is extremely difficult to escape an American student loan obligation, basically you will pay it off, with interest, unless you die first. This system is what enables American universities to put such high price tags on education, and also what allows the students to actually get approved for such large loans. Almost all of the risk is assumed by the borrower. Even if the graduate cannot find sufficiently gainful employment to repay the loan, the lender still eventually gets a return on their investment. If they were forced to take a loss, that would cause lenders to make their approval processes more stringent, and would limit most students' ability to attend these universities. So it becomes a political issue because no politician wants to be perceived as being responsible for limiting students' access to higher education. The fact is that the risks and costs must be absorbed by someone--under the current system it is the students' future selves. (My personal opinion is that this is a form of modern indentured servitude and should be outlawed.)
- smsm42 14y agoDischargeability does not matter if the person has no income to pay it. You can't take 2K per month form a person that earns 2.5K per month before taxes. In fact, unless you have six-figure salary, 2K per month will bankrupt you very quickly, since you also need to pay for shelter, food, utilities, etc. and with income that allows to pay 2K per month you will get no welfare. So repayment of the loan is linked to the person having substantial income. Actually, as far as I know most of education loans are now government loans, so there is zero incentive of changing the requirements, and zero incentive to reduce the costs. If these loans are losing money, we can just tax the rich and have more money, can't we?
- kyllo 14y agoThe non-dischargeability of student loans matters because it significantly reduces the lender's risk of taking a loss. Even if the student doesn't have the income to service the loan debt within 5-10 years after graduating, the lender will still recoup their investment, with interest, if the person ever makes enough income to pay it down in their entire lifetime. And the lender is near the front of the line for collections (just behind things like the IRS and child support). So the only case in which the lender takes a loss on their investment is if the borrower dies before they can pay it off. In the aggregate this is a very small risk. Student loans are not all government loans, maybe 70% are Federal Student Aid loans. Both FSA loans and subsidized private loans are subsidized by the government, which only means that the government pays the portion of the interest that would be due while the student is still in school. But it does not matter whether the lender is the government or a bank--the loans still carry an interest rate and are still non-dischargeable. The government cannot "just tax the rich" to pay off students' loan balances, the government does not work that way.
- sjg007 14y agoThe gov't ends up buying the deliquent loan in full and then they chase you down. Extreme hardship is the only way to get it dismissed and that is very unlikely. They do have a 20 year minimum payment plan and then will forgive the remainder. Not sure if that becomes taxable after the fact. They also have principal forgiveness plans for government or teaching service.
- rgovind 14y agoyep...Its an unsecured loan. Student loan is the next crisis waiting to happen. Also, in case of Booth School MBAs, I hear (from friends), that students are charged something like 4% extra...since statistics show 4% of people typically default on MBA loans.
- prakashk 14y ago... that 5-year income of Stanford MBA graduate is at least 185K higher (after taxes, of course, so before taxes, given federal & California taxes, it'd be around 400K or 80K per year) than the income of other people ... The Stanford MBA's income need not be higher by 185K, for the comparison to be fair. It needs to be higher only by the difference between the cost of Stanford MBA and the other MBA.