3 ms·
It's not speculating about Steve's health that made me dislike the article, but the way it was done. I think it really was about "look here, I have a friend who
by Tichy 18y ago
It's not speculating about Steve's health that made me dislike the article, but the way it was done. I think it really was about "look here, I have a friend who chats with Steve", and not about caring for the AAPL investors. Those were just lame excuses for gossiping (my impression anyway).
- davidw 18y agoI agree that it's kind of an ugly article. However, all articles about Steve's health, bar a hypothetical one saying he's completely fine and over whatever he has, are going to be a bit distasteful. So the question was - how should Apple, Steve, and various and sundry journalists approach the issue? It's not an easy question.
- Tichy 18y agoI guess official statements at timed intervals would do. As for gossip snippets like that, I don't know. Suppose you would be the first to get hold of such information, would you feel a duty to society to publish it? Or is publishing it more of a vulture thing to do?
- davidw 18y agoWould shorting the stock and making a lot of money be a vulture thing to do if you knew he was getting worse? If you knew he was making a full recovery before anyone else did, would buying the stock be a vulture thing to do?
- Tichy 18y agoAt least if you buy or sell stock, you put yourself on the line. But it is a difficult question. As I said, I guess I didn't really dislike the reporting about Steve Jobs health indicators, as the spirit of it. I don't know enough about philosophy to discern whether that makes for a meaningful distinction.