3 ms·
Treating patents as a property right allowed them to take the invention and "exit" by selling it to someone else. And what is the someone else going to do with
by pdonis 14y ago
Treating patents as a property right allowed them to take the invention and "exit" by selling it to someone else.
And what is the someone else going to do with that right that makes it worth $700 million? That's the key question.
If what makes that right worth $700 million is that the someone else is going to manufacture the drug in large quantities and sell it at a profit, great! That's what the patent system is for.
If what makes that right worth $700 million is that the someone else is going to sue anyone who tries to manufacture the drug without a license and collect damages, that's not great. Either the drug won't be manufactured at all, which removes the justification for allowing it to be patented in the first place, or it will be manufactured at an extra cost, the licensing fee and/or damages, which means less of it will be manufactured or it will sell at a higher price.
In other words, a "non-practicing entity" who buys a patent like this one without intending to use it, is basically extracting an extra fee from everyone who needs the drug, without providing any compensating value. The economic term for that is "deadweight loss", and it's not a good idea. That's why patents should be held by those who are going to actually use them.
- rayiner 14y agoThe NPE is a middle man--it allows the inventor to cash out now, and recoups it's investment by doing all of the things the inventor himself could have done anyway. There is a value to allowing the inventor to cash out immediately with an NPE instead of taking the time to find a suitable buyer who will actually use the patent.
- pdonis 14y agoThere is a value to allowing the inventor to cash out immediately with an NPE instead of taking the time to find a suitable buyer who will actually use the patent. If the NPE actually does do work to find a buyer, so that he buys the patent for, say, $700 million but then sells it a year later, say, for $1.5 billion to a manufacturer, then I agree; the NPE in that case is adding value by doing "brokering" work that the original inventor didn't want to do, and was willing to take a quicker exit at a lower valuation to avoid. But it seems to me that patent troll companies are buying patents with the explicit intention of doing nothing with them other than extracting fees and/or settlements, i.e., that they are adding no value.