4 ms·
Congrats on building a successful business. But the hyperbole is slightly laughable. This company is nowhere near competing with the likes of SAP. I recognize t
by mbesto 14y ago
Congrats on building a successful business. But the hyperbole is slightly laughable. This company is nowhere near competing with the likes of SAP. I recognize the ambition is there and it's great to have vision, but some of the statements are way off.
The business model is interesting though. The days of the 90% profit margins SAP/Oracle get on their maintenance combined with their outdated software licensing model, lends itself to be highly disrupted. My money is currently on Workday to be the market leader.
- kokey 14y agoI tend to have a little look every few years to what open source ERP alternatives to SAP are brewing out there. I come away from the exercise disappointed each time. I know it will happen one day and the time should be soon, not necessarily an open source product but at least some kind of disruption on price/model e.g. a popular SaaS system. I'll give Workday a look.
- mbesto 14y agoWorkday is basically PeopleSoft in the cloud. I really like Aneel Bhusri's attitude towards business in todays landscape: http://www.workday.com/company/leadership_team/aneel_bhusri.php http://www.workday.com/company/leadership_team/aneel_bhusri.... Highly recommend watching this video: (especially if you're a techie interested in this area) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dWawiKa50Xo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dWawiKa50Xo
- zurn 14y agoWhat would it take to "compete with the likes of SAP" in your view? I know almost nothing about ERP but a close friend is a SAP consultant and provides daily tales of super-Lovecraftian horrors so fantastic that it's hard to imagine why people use it. In fact most stories make me think "it would be orders of magnitude cheaper and more fun to implement that from scratch with Python and some open source tools".
- delive 14y agoThe issue with competing against SAP/Oracle is the kind of traction they have in the market already. Their contracts are long, and companies spend so much implementing the software that they're not excited to switch. Also, as mentioned somewhere else in this thread, ERP software (Payroll, HR, Financials, etc) are all about the details. Payroll and Financials are very complicated, which results in companies only trusting the big players (SAP/Oracle) Disclaimer: I work for Workday
- iandanforth 14y agoDo companies like this ever get involved in lobbying? The complexity of the problem seems to be the core of their value proposition, so I wouldn't be terribly surprised if they subtly or overtly opposed simplifying reforms.
- mbesto 14y agoAFAIK, the answer is no. I honestly don't think they need to. The complexities are mostly a result of globalization (different governments policies, taxes, etc) and changing business models/products (material management, pricing schemes, etc)... all of this at scale.
- arethuza 14y ago"it would be orders of magnitude cheaper and more fun to implement that from scratch with Python and some open source tools" I can honestly see why you might think that (I've had exactly the same thoughts before) - then you find out what a Tier-1 ERP does and can be quite a staggering collection of functionality a lot of which is absolutely required and not optional.
- supercanuck 14y agoI am an SAP Consultant, and my .02 is that companies are so in love with their back office processes such as creating purchase orders and sales orders, that they want these things so highly customizable that it requires big package software. Most SAP horror stories are from customers who don't realize their ability to process their Accounts Payable isn't a business core competency and is not bringing them competitive advantage. If customers come around on this, THEN the days of SAP will be numbered.