7 ms·
This would be an issue if they were the only game in town, last time I checked they have some pretty stiff competition in package delivery, UPS being the one th
by Shivetya 14y ago
This would be an issue if they were the only game in town, last time I checked they have some pretty stiff competition in package delivery, UPS being the one that comes to mind.
Look at it this way, if they are overcharging for delivery but are still getting business then they are charging appropriately for their market.
- wting 14y agoThe presence of competition does not imply a fairly priced market, e.g. US telecom companies.
- paulgb 14y agoFedEx were sued for breach of contract. Presumably the plaintiffs shopped around and compared rates before entering a contract with FedEx.
- spoiledtechie 14y agoIf all companies that deal with governments should be sued for going over budget or charging too much after a contract was set in place, then federal contractors would all be in court.
- paulgb 14y agoThere's a difference between going over budget and systematically overcharging. A major government contract should have provisions for the former, but if someone systematically overcharges they should be in court.
- aptwebapps 14y agoNot all government contracts are the same. Many of them have provisions for going over budget.
- fleitz 14y agoIt's an issue of charging for a service that was not provided, doing something like this is called fraud when done intentionally. An officer of the company knowing about the issue and not doing anything about it would generally be the nail in the coffin.
- cygwin98 14y agoIt's called Oligopoly, which is much better than Monopoly, but still far from a competitive market.
- Shivetya 14y agoHow is the market not competitive? UPS, FedEx, and USPS, are the three big carriers that come to mind. The logistics for nationwide delivery pretty much insure your not going to have a large number companies. You might get some that specialize in particular types of delivery, but generic deliveries is self limiting.
- DanBC 14y agoA hypothetical example is if each carrier makes their pricing hard to compare with the others. Combining weight, maximum size, distance, overseas or not, time, reliability and customer service gives carriers plenty of room to confuse customers.
- chimeracoder 14y ago> UPS, FedEx, and USPS, are the three big carriers that come to mind. Ironically, the two private carriers depend on the sole public carrier (USPS) for deliveries to rural/remote locations (which USPS is required to serve), so this market isn't quite as "competitive" as it looks.
- nickpinkston 14y agoWell, assuming there's no price collusion, which there's a good chance of the implicit type. "Charging appropriately" isn't the best measure pro-socially, AIDS medication was still selling well in the West as millions died. FedEx could be prohibiting whole business models that are waiting to be profitable with cheaper shipping. Yes, I know it's speculation, but what we often forget here is that capitalism is a deal of state-based enforcement of your property rights so that you create value for society. If your company, like Comcast, is systematically overcharging / under-delivering, you're not holding up your end of the deal - so the state might just step in to ::realign your interests::
- Gormo 14y ago> we often forget here is that capitalism is a deal of state-based enforcement of your property rights so that you create value for society. Are you saying that the protection of one's property rights is contingent upon the delivery of some arbitrary metric of "value" to "society"? That doesn't sound quite right.
- meepmorp 14y ago> Are you saying that the protection of one's property rights is contingent upon the delivery of some arbitrary metric of "value" to "society"? That doesn't sound quite right. Are you saying that property rights are not contingent on a metric of value to society? If it weren't better for society as a whole to provide protections for property rights, do you think they'd exist?
- sageikosa 14y ago>capitalism is a deal of state-based enforcement of your property rights so that you create value for society No it isn't. Capitalism is a "system" of capital investment (usually with the expected gains of personal profitability), contingent upon the property rights of the ownership of capital and transferable (partial) ownership of an enterprise that consumes that capital. Capitalism is contingent on property rights being recognized and defended against arbitrary taking, but property rights are not contingent upon the owner of property contributing to society in some arbitrarily (im?)measurable way. This is not to state that the protection of property rights is not a net social boon, just that property rights do not evaporate (in whole or in part) in specific instances once someone calculates the "social value" for an owned enterprise has dropped below some immeasurable threshold. Governments operating under a system of justice attempt to regulate the systems and boundaries of social exchange (to minimize and resolve apparent conflicts), but do not require any party to engage in such exchange to the benefit of anyone, or the mutual benefit of society.
- rscale 14y agoThe only appropriate charge is the one that was agreed upon for the services rendered.
- Permit 14y agoYou mustn't have read the article. It's not "FedEx's prices were too high". It's "FedEx told me it costs $x.xx to mail a package and I was charged $x.xx + $y.yy".
- bdcravens 14y agoFedEx and UPS have been known to collude, and there's currently a lawsuit pending related to FedEx and UPS colluding to shut down third-party negotiators.