4 ms·
People don't seem to like something about this article, and I can see that - it's not fun to speculate about someone's health when there's a potentially serious
by davidw 18y ago
People don't seem to like something about this article, and I can see that - it's not fun to speculate about someone's health when there's a potentially serious illness involved.
But let's turn this around: how would you cover it?
There are billions of dollars riding on Jobs' health, and any news about it.
- davidw 18y agoIt's a serious question. His health affects a lot of people, from Apple employees to stockholders, so, like Cringely argues, it is important to more than just him. On the other hand, it's no fun to talk about someone's health. How do you think journalists ought to balance those conflicts? No coverage at all means rumors are all people have to go on, and when that much money is at stake, act on them they will. Or, as froo mentions above, it's easy to start them - even more so when there is no official news. And with that much money at stake... you get the point. Also... markets are a fantastic way of organizing things - by letting thousands of people collaborate to create and distribute stuff, they are undoubtedly the best way of organizing an economy. However, that impersonal nature (everyone acting in their own self interest, and in many cases, not even knowing one another), occasionally shows itself, as in this case. As kind humans, our instincts would be to leave the guy alone and wish him well. However, many people have a rational self-interest in knowing about Jobs' health, or, in the case of journalists who are information producers/gatherers, to obtain information that their competition does not have.
- Tichy 18y agoIt's not speculating about Steve's health that made me dislike the article, but the way it was done. I think it really was about "look here, I have a friend who chats with Steve", and not about caring for the AAPL investors. Those were just lame excuses for gossiping (my impression anyway).
- davidw 18y agoI agree that it's kind of an ugly article. However, all articles about Steve's health, bar a hypothetical one saying he's completely fine and over whatever he has, are going to be a bit distasteful. So the question was - how should Apple, Steve, and various and sundry journalists approach the issue? It's not an easy question.
- Tichy 18y agoI guess official statements at timed intervals would do. As for gossip snippets like that, I don't know. Suppose you would be the first to get hold of such information, would you feel a duty to society to publish it? Or is publishing it more of a vulture thing to do?
- davidw 18y agoWould shorting the stock and making a lot of money be a vulture thing to do if you knew he was getting worse? If you knew he was making a full recovery before anyone else did, would buying the stock be a vulture thing to do?
- Tichy 18y agoAt least if you buy or sell stock, you put yourself on the line. But it is a difficult question. As I said, I guess I didn't really dislike the reporting about Steve Jobs health indicators, as the spirit of it. I don't know enough about philosophy to discern whether that makes for a meaningful distinction.