4 ms·
Potential consumer confusion has nothing to do with the size of Apple's cut or how it is structured. Clearly, a 30% cut is fair for the average $1.5 purchase b
by fauigerzigerk 14y ago
Potential consumer confusion has nothing to do with the size of Apple's cut or how it is structured.
Clearly, a 30% cut is fair for the average $1.5 purchase because it includes fees for payment processing and fixed cost per app.
But Apple will have to decide whether or not they want people to sell more expensive stuff on their platform. Taking a 30% cut on a $100 purchase is not economically viable and it is unnecessary if the goal is to avoid consumer confusion.
They could just charge 50 cents + 5%
- jobenjo 14y agoThat's a great solution, actually. Think of it more like a credit card processing fee.
- easytiger 14y agoHow have you been brainwashed into that being acceptable?
- marcusf 14y agoI don't understand... elaborate?
- easytiger 14y agoThat taking a percentage of a transaction and giving it to a credit card company is OK.
- drakeandrews 14y agoThey are providing the service of making your money available for payment without you having to think about the logistics of moving the money (plus credit facilities, chargebacks, fraud protection (If I have a wallet full of money and someone spends it I'm down that cash. If I have a wallet full of cards and someone spends with them, I'm covered.)). It only seems fair that they get paid for their work. Whether the amount they charge is worth the services they provide is another question entirely.
- easytiger 14y agoYou are completely missing the point.... I at no point suggested that they shouldn't charge. That it is a percentage of the transaction amount is what I have a problem with. If their business was truly about "credit" they shouldn't need extra charges as they claim back more value from bigger loans/transactions. Debit cards provide the same service without a percentage charge but without the payment protection. Its a rigged game.
- diegobc 14y agoI thought the percentage charge is used to cover the cost of fraudulent transactions?
- smackfu 14y agoThat's 10 times the normal fees.
- megablast 14y agoThey have decided.
- chj 14y agoThis makes sense.
- drewcrawford 14y ago> Taking a 30% cut on a $100 purchase is not economically viable The market for a $100 app isn't very large, and that price point is also a target for fraud / scams / accidental purchase complaints. This risk is offset by additional review scrutiny, but the cost for that additional scrutiny is amortized over a small number of potential customers. The result of all this is that $100 purchases are expensive for Apple to run, and Apple as a rational actor should discourage them. I wouldn't be surprised to learn that the whole $50+ market runs at a loss that is covered by the cheaper apps.
- chj 14y agoEven for a $20 item 30% cut is not acceptable either, considering what Apple actually did is simply app hosting + payment processing. App Store did a really bad job on app discovery and promotion, so I don't think they deserve anything on marketing. However, they can charge developers for being featured on the front page.
- Terretta 14y ago> App Store did a really bad job on app discovery and promotion You think most app buyers found their apps outside the app store? Unlike folks reading HN or tech sites and trying new apps thanks to app launch news, the normals I know find their apps only within the app store (other than the occasional app roundup in a mainstream printed magazine). If you look at the CC processing industry, ranging from 5% fees for the most basic service (transaction + cc + merchant + bank) to 15% fees for an end to end service that cuts you a check, the 30% to also manage the user authentication and customer service is a reasonable deal, completely aside from marketing. Finally, as a user, I don't want featured apps to be the ones paying to be featured. Not cool.
- chj 14y agoFrom my own experience and friends I know, users rarely go the app store and search for a term. What they do there is check out the high ranked apps. The most effective way of discovering an app is still recommendation by mouth or websites. There are a lot of app review blogs out there for a good reason. We are talking about different business. apps/ebooks generally don't have a high margin.
- josephlord 14y agoRemember that you can put money onto your iTunes account using gift cards bought at retailers. Those retailers will get a cut (someone here probably knows but lets guess 10-15%). That doesn't reduce it to a zero profit operation but at least on that portion of the revenue it looks like a lot than 30%.
- josephlord 14y agoToo late to edit but the end should read: "it looks like a lot less than 30%."
- jthol 14y agoIt would be interesting to see what percentage of gift card dollars never get redeemed and how long they take to get redeemed.