10 ms·
So I'm very curious if anyone can help see a "intuitive fair line" better than I can (because I can't find one). On the one hand, it makes perfect sense Apple
by crazygringo 14y ago
So I'm very curious if anyone can help see a "intuitive fair line" better than I can (because I can't find one).
On the one hand, it makes perfect sense Apple wants 30% on apps. They run the store.
On the other hand, it seems like Amazon should be able to sell books, Dropbox should be able to sell space, etc., without paying 30% -- otherwise it's financially impossible.
But if you allow apps to sell content within without paying 30%, then all of a sudden all apps become free, selling "upgrading functionality" within, and the app store is no longer viable for Apple.
You can't even make a rule like "reselling 3rd party content is exempt from the fee", because apps will claim additional functionality as 3rd-party. You can't make a rule that "content accessible on other devices is exempt from the fee", because gamemakers will just make their in-game purchases accessible on the Android version too, or something.
Can anyone think of a clear, unambiguous rule that would allow things like Dropbox, Skydrive, Amazon, etc. to get around the 30% fee, but without allowing loopholes that would allow everyone to skirt it? I swear my brain thinks there's a distinction, but I can't figure out what it is.
- JuDue 14y agoThis is a good point. Also wondering what's stopping MS from doing down the DropBox path and not allowing purchases on iOS.
- hdra 14y agoMicrosoft offered to remove all paid subscription option, but the compromise was rejected.
- JuDue 14y agoWell who really knows how two IT giants communicate. There is little to stop MS from expecting the DropBox model to be accepted - it depends what else they are asking. We simply don't know the details of all this, beyond the MS focused blog item. MS want Skydrive and their own mobile/tablet App prowess recognised.. .. and here they are David compromising with Goliath!
- jemeshsu 14y agoI just checked Dropbox and Google Drive apps, both offer in-app upgrade of disk storage, giving Apple 30% cut. Appears that you can not simply just remove the upgrade option from the app. So I don't see how MS could be any different.
- jan_g 14y agoYou can't, because apple rejects your app, if it is in any way connected with a website that offers payment. In other words, apple doesn't allow you to circumvent this "30% tax" by accepting only website payments. If you accept payments, you have to accept them also on iOS. At least that was the case with our relatively new app.
- rplnt 14y agoWas this for content that can live outside of the app? As can the storage or perhaps the books mentioned elsewhere in the discussion. If it was something tied with app I can see why apple doesn't want you to sell it anywhere else.
- jan_g 14y ago>Was this for content that can live outside of the app? I don't fully understand your question. We have a voip app that among other things allows users to call landline or mobile numbers. These calls are not free, so a user must pay. We started with web site+flash and added paypal and stripe payment options. Then we've created iOS app and as anyone else found out about 30% tax. Long story short, nothing worked until we added in app purchases. Before that, the app was continuously rejected on the grounds that if it's possible to pay on website and then use that credit on iOS app, then we must provide also in app purchases. > I can see why apple doesn't want you to sell it anywhere else. It's not that apple don't want you to sell it anywhere else, but that if you do sell it anywhere else, you have to sell it also on iOS.
- Terretta 14y agoI think the question was content vs service. Your app, like Dropbox and Skydrive, is providing a consumable service.
- Danieru 14y agoYou cannot have your cake and eat it too. All pricing introduces inefficiency without perfect price discrimination. If you charge a fixed rate for a product or service you exclude the users where the wealth created is less than the rate charged, aka the marginal consumer. You can improve this by charge lower prices for the marginal buyers. You can then do a similar thing for very high value consumers. This is why Microsoft sells so many versions of Windows. In the real world price discrimination is very crude. Consider that Microsoft only has ~6 versions of windows, that is only 6 discrete steps to covers the several magnitudes of value created for users. The reality is there is no algorithmic way to determine the marginal apps. Thus if Apple wants to charge 30% for all apps except those for which this is excessive they are best off doing things on a case-by-case basis.
- pserwylo 14y agoI agree. Perhaps a nice way to solve it is to tell Google and Apple: "Let people do in-app purchasing however they want, if they use yours, you can take a cut." By all means, you make it as easy as possible to integrate with your solution by providing tools and support, and then you take a cut if they choose to make it. Of course, this will never happen, but if it did (either because they thought it was morally right, or because of regulation), then it seems like a way to solve this issue.
- elithrar 14y ago> By all means, you make it as easy as possible to integrate with your solution by providing tools and support, and then you take a cut if they choose to make it. The problem here is two-fold: 1) 30% is a lot, and many large scale developers will choose the homebrew/third party library solution 2) It begets a bad user experience when users have to be cautious about IAP, remember another set (or sets) of credentials, chase yet another company for refunds - and Apple are likely to cop the blame even if it's not their IAP solution the dev is using.
- rhizome 14y agoTo be sure, they can split the functionality. 30% for payments for the app itself, some other % for in-app purchases using their e-commerce API.
- nucleardog 14y agoAnd that's all ignoring the negative security implications of having every developer reimplementing secure credit card payments.
- pserwylo 14y agoPerhaps a similar situation would be online payment gateways for dealing with credit card transactions. There are strict guidelines about what you need to do in order to be considered secure [0]. As a result, we don't end up with every man and his dog doing it, but there is sufficient competition compared with the single-player in-store app purchase situation. [0] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PCI_DSS http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PCI_DSS
- hayksaakian 14y agoIt would make more sense if apple did anything to help attach content delivered via the store to specific individuals. Recently there was a story about a game that was 'killed' by piracy because apple didn't provide a way of connecting players to iTunes accounts, in order to ban pirates. There's very little intrinsic value with the app store. How about if you use the app store to deliver your content, you are given a unique id to tie to specific devices? Or maybe if you could host content tied to in app purchases on iTunes? To me it seems fair to say 'if you use their resources to conduct a transaction and deliver content, you should pay them'
- radley 14y agoDo Apple-based in-app subscriptions until you hit critical mass. Cancel all Apple subscriptions but maintain 30-60 free trial / continuous open use to existing customers. Introduce new direct subscription with 30% discount (below previous rate i.e. minus Apple's cut) if signed up within 30-60 days.
- jthol 14y ago10%-15% cut if you use your own payment processing? You lose the one click convenience customers have to add all this extra data etc.
- notatoad 14y agoI think the unfair part is the rule that you can't link to your website if users can buy things on your website. If apple wants to maintain a monopoly on in-app purchases that's their prerogative, but not allowing you to link out to an external purchase is just a huge dick move that seems unnecessarily desperate.
- spullara 14y agoIf you allow people to get around the in-app purchase they will and the whole platform will suffer.
- chj 14y agoHow so?
- gurkendoktor 14y agoAlmost all top-grossing apps nowadays are IAP games. I'd say these are the natural successors of subscription scams on J2ME dumbphones. If you'd allow these companies to bill you through their website, you could probably forget about ever cancelling that subscription again.
- chj 14y agoNot necessarily so. Other payment systems like Paypal can come in and be the gatekeeper.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoPayPal, there's the company we should hand the keys to the kingdom to.
- ra 14y agoI think the problem is, flat 30% on in-app purchase is just too much when you're working on a margin. One solution would be for Apple to introduce plans. eg: classic - flat 30% - no monthly fee pro - flat 15% - $500 monthly fee irock - flat 7.5% - $2,000 monthly fee That's just an example, but I think the main issue is that a flat 30% just doesn't work for some types of business. [edit: fixed confusing typos]
- spullara 14y agoThose businesses are mostly middle-men businesses that are already offered by Apple (disk space, books, music, movies, apps, etc).
- bergie 14y agoSure, but do you really want a world where Apple is the only possible provider of storage, books, etc. on their devices?
- sthatipamala 14y agoNo, but Apple might.
- ddlatham 14y agoAllow apps to charge users the extra 43% if they are buying from the app compared to the price they would pay direct, without the markup.
- goronbjorn 14y agoWhy is it "financially impossible"?
- btilly 14y agoYou have missed the core issue. The problem is this. There is online content. The app is one way of accessing that content. Apple wants a 30% cut of everything you make on that online content EVEN THOUGH the user may be primarily accessing that content on another device. My suggested compromise is this. Any purchase made through the app, Apple should take its 30% cut on. If you've gone through the effort of accessing that content and purchasing it another way, Apple should not be taking a 30% cut.
- comex 14y agoI believe your suggestion is already the case.
- bad_user 14y agoIt isn't, because apparently you cannot advertise payment options in any way ... so a link to a web page where you can buy storage or where you can purchase features and so on is not allowed. Even though the app itself is just a gateway to an online service that exists outside the iTunes Store. And even though you make it impossible for the user to purchase anything by using said device, telling them something like "go to a desktop to make purchases". I have Google Drive installed on my iPad. In my profile it does say how much storage I have left, but provides absolutely no link or hint on if I can or how I could increase that storage.
- ghshephard 14y agoRight - the line between "Advertising" and "Purchasing" is pretty gray, particularly with in situ web browsing - what would happen if I clicked on a link and it brought me to an in-app web-kit interface? Apple just makes it clear that if you want to purchase, advertise purchasing, or in any way try and extra hard $$$ from users through a native-client, then Apple gets 30%. This is the only way their store will continue to work - any other approach will result in people gaming the system, and, instead of selling a $50 copy of Omnifocus, Omni will sell it for $5, but then have a "link" to Omnifocus's sync service for $45 for a three-year membership. I agree with the OP up top - I can think of no way Apple can continue to run a store without toeing a hard-line on this.
- drewcrawford 14y agoI think the problem is in how the question is framed. The App Store has always been revenue neutral [1]. It's not a profit center for Apple. It's not about "getting their cut". It's about having one billing statement to look at. It's about eliminating shady billing tactics a la gym memberships. It's about keeping your address out of some developer's mailing list. You'd be surprised about the extent of this problem. I get e-mails all the time from people who are worried that they have a monthly payment for my app, for example. There are just an awful lot of people who don't "get" software at all and derive real value from simplified one-party billing. So if you start from the premise that billing for iOS apps has to be brain-dead simple, we arrive at the present rule: any payment that looks like it happens on an iPhone must [2] run through IAP at whatever rate Apple can break even. If your payment collection process consists of people using their fingers on the screen of an iPhone, then it is potentially confusable with IAP by Grandpa and he might get mad at Apple; this is unacceptable. But monetizing your pizza ordering app by handing money to a pizza delivery guy who shows up at your house is not confusable, so it's A-OK. Now, it's perfectly debatable whether or not consumer confusion is really that big of a problem, or a problem big enough to justify the negative externalities of solving it. But if it is, then the result follows: the solution is to run all the billing through a break-even single party. If you accept the premise, then the rule that is fairest and best and also solves the problem is the rule that we already have. It's unfortunate that we live in a world where the economics of Dropbox, Skydrive, Amazon et al seemingly don't allow enough profit margin to pay Apple's overhead to process payments. But I'm not really sure who is to blame for that: the consumers, for being confused about billing; Apple, for trying to fix it for them; Skydrive etc. for not creating a two-tiered pricing structure to charge IAP customers at 30% more; or consumers again for being unwilling to pay an extra 30% for single-party billing. [1] http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/article/apple_app_store_runs_just_above_break_even http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/article/apple_app_store_runs_... [2] there are some exceptions, I'm speaking broadly to make a point
- ddlatham 14y agoIf it's merely a break-even proposition for Apple, then perhaps a flat fee per purchase (or at least a maximum) would make more sense and allow services like Dropbox, Skydrive, and Amazon to participate.
- chappi42 14y ago>Can anyone think of a clear, unambiguous rule that would allow things like Dropbox, Skydrive, Amazon, etc. to get around the 30% fee, but without allowing loopholes that would allow everyone to skirt it? Simple: alternative stores should be enforced by law. Apple alone deciding what goes onto iDevices is wrong. (Ditto Microsoft with WP). Let the market decide.
- chj 14y agoExactly. But some may say this is a free market, Apple can do whatever it wants in its own garden.
- greedo 14y agoAnd hasn't the market decided? Users are buying both Android and iPhone devices, and to a far lesser extent WinFones. Since Android has far higher market share than Apple, it seems like this should be perfect. Yet for people who are actually buying apps online, Apple seems to be doing quite well. Perhaps you're idea of letting the market decide isn't really focused on the market so much as developers...
- politician 14y ago> [These guys] should be able to sell space, etc., without paying 30% -- otherwise it's financially impossible. The difficulty in finding that "fair line" might be that using government's implicit threat of violence to force Apple to capitulate to these guys demands to be in their store without playing by their rules is inconsistent with a belief in property rights.