3 ms·
I've been doing something similar. I'm on my fourth iPhone, so I'm well invested in that ecosystem. I recently added a Galaxy S3 with a new line for testing pur
by bdcravens 14y ago
I've been doing something similar. I'm on my fourth iPhone, so I'm well invested in that ecosystem. I recently added a Galaxy S3 with a new line for testing purposes. I'm comparing both devices: if I prefer the S3, I'll transfer my personal line to it, and use the iPhone as the backup/test device.
I have no problem buying apps. I have a few apps I depend on, and many I like. My thoughts so far:
* The S3 is a superior piece of hardware, hands down.
* Most of the OS features are superior on the S3 as well, and the built in apps are as good or better than what's on iOS.
* The app situation is what kills the S3.
1) Many apps I depend on that are awesome on iOS don't exist on Android, and the "substitutes" are really poor in my opinion (for example, OmniFocus vs. the generic to-do apps)
2) Some of the same apps don't have ad-free Pro versions on Android as they do on iOS. Perhaps there needs to be a separate app store filled with more curated, paid apps? (Say Google Play and Google Pro)
3) Some of the same apps are absolutely horrible on Android. I suspect they are quick ghetto ports of successful iOS apps, not properly developed Android software. (Example: The Chive is pretty decent on iOS, and a bug-filled mess on Android)
Again, I was really cheering for the S3, but honestly, ecosystem trumps innovation.
- Simucal 14y agoWhich iPhone were you comparing to the S3? The iPhone 5?
- bdcravens 14y agoIn my hardware comparison, yes, the iPhone 5. (I've also owned the 4S, 4, and 3G)
- gbog 14y agoYou look like those Frenchmen going to China and complaining that the bread is not as good. Try android native apps.
- mikeash 14y agoWhere do you get the idea that he is not?
- anotherbadlogin 14y agoHow about basic functionality that the iPhone inexplicably lacks? This, for example: http://goldmanosi.blogspot.com/2012/06/will-apple-ever-fix-iphones-biggest.html http://goldmanosi.blogspot.com/2012/06/will-apple-ever-fix-i...