5 ms·
Why would anyone here support a fundamentally racist, oppressive de-facto apartheid occupying state which is about to commit genocide? Especially considering t
by josteink 14y ago
Why would anyone here support a fundamentally racist, oppressive de-facto apartheid occupying state which is about to commit genocide?
Especially considering the above average intelligence i presume people here to have.
Israel needs to be boycotted, globally. Not supported. Not in any way. Not in the slightest.
- Petrushka 14y agoFrom the guidelines: Please avoid introducing classic flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say about them.
- josteink 14y agoI'm questioning the ethics of having this on HN at all. I think that is absolutely within reason.
- alwaysright 14y agoSame question I have, but on your comment, not on the topic.
- CleanStar 14y agoSorry, this is not yet Gaza where you can just drop a bomb on someone you dislike. If Israel is a start-up nation, I guess from the Zionist point of view, the newly UN recognized nation of Palestine is a nation to "shut down". Like with Netanyahu's recent shutting off of east Palestine. For daring to show that only nine countries oppose the existence of the Palestinian state - the USA, Israel, and Canada - as well as some US territories in the Pacific with UN votes (Marshall Islands, Palau). Considering how this posted topic has immediately turned into a flamewar, it is obvious that the "introduction of classic flamewar topics" was done by the original submitter. You start the fire, then point a whiny finger at those who come around - how typical of a Zionist.
- alwaysright 14y agoHow typical of an antisemitic to immediately make it personal and blame a user that simply quoted the site's policy (which to remind you, is not yours to decide about) and violate the same policy by calling some poor user who has nothing to do with the topic "a Zionist." Yes, everyone is a Zionist, the jews control the world, they kill Palestinians and use their blood to make Mazzas for Passover, we are sick of hearing it, besides being racist and antisemitic, it's boring, we hear this for thousands of years. please provide something new. that's was the purpose of that comment. You know what? I wish you love success and prosperity and hope to God one day you'll take the time and read the facts and see how you are brainwashed with antisemitic propaganda.
- accountswu 14y agoWhen the Israeli terrorists stop murdering women and children and ordinary civilians we can stop flame wars against them. Until then if you stay silent at the injustice, you are siding with the oppressor. That's from Desmond Tutu who fought South African apartheid. Guess what he's got to say about Israeli regime? He said it's worse than what they faced; there were no white-only roads in South Africa and they weren't bombing blacks with F-16s and Gunship helicopters like Israelis are.
- mulya 14y agoI don't take you seriously, sorry, you also claim that: > "many of the stories trumpeted by Western and Saudi-backed media highlighting Syrian regime's brutality have turned out to be fake (or worse, some massacres blamed on regime were actually carried out by CIA-sponsored armed Syrian "rebels"). " see http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4318514 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4318514
- eranation 14y agoNo politics in HN, please.
- klearvue 14y agoI think the title of the article is unnecessarily provocative considering recent political and military events. It might not be intentional but a little more thought into the title could have resulted in something with less political overtones, say, "Supporting Israel's Start-Up Community".
- recuter 14y agoThe title is in reference to the book "Startup Nation", nothing provocative about it.
- supervacuo 14y ago"No politics" is like absolute zero: a state unreachable because of the nature of the universe. In fact, "no politics" is in itself a very political statement; you're calling for a libertarian foreign policy attitude by saying that it's possible to separate technology from the conditions under which it is produced and used. If it were Apple or Google enacting a murderous military occupation I don't think you'd get very far trying to prevent people from discussing that on HN. Nations are like what we used to have before corporations... remember?
- alwaysright 14y agoIt's the site's policy, read it, and perhaps you won't have karma of 1 forever. http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic. Calling Israel "apartheid" or "murderous military occupation" or "racist" is so old and boring (regardless of being racist, antisemitic and not really supported by facts nor accepted by most western world) and really doesn't fall into "evidence of some interesting new phenomenon" Funnily, this flame comment is what took this topic off the front page, which means no one hardly reads this post anyway. So congratulations, instead of voicing your opinion in a civil way and making your point, you managed to get this topic flagged, and no one reads what you have to write. So if you want to help the Palestinians, stop trying, you just make it worse.
- wslh 14y agoDo you think the major part of Israel support oppressing people? think again. This is about startups and people.
- eranation 14y agoThis is supporting Israeli startups, not the Israeli government. more and more Israeli startups outsource work to Palestinian high tech companies, which is probably a good thing for both sides. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/29/technology/29compute.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/29/technology/29compute.html?... http://www.haaretz.com/news/national/israeli-high-tech-companies-outsourcing-to-palestinians-1.331256 http://www.haaretz.com/news/national/israeli-high-tech-compa...
- mikle 14y agoThat's a good point. A lot of companies in Israel outsource QA, development and other things to Arab and Palestinian firms. Both Neocleus (my first job) and Intel (my second) had real partnerships with Arab and Palestinian firms.
- bobinator30 14y agoWhen gaza lays downs its arms (rockets) and picks up its laptops, Israel will be the first one in there with shekels, know-how, and support.
- reuven 14y agoPreface: I'm an Israeli Jew, born in the United States. I've lived in Israel since 1995, and now have a family (with three children). I could respond to this comment by saying, "Why be so negative toward Israel, when there are so many countries that treat people so much worse?" But even though I believe that there are indeed countries with far worse human-rights records than Israel, and which treat citizens and non-citizens worse than we do -- it doesn't comfort me to hear, or to know, that we do a lot of things wrong. I could say that if you feel this way about Israel, that you should be equally adamant about boycotting China, Syria, Saudia Arabia, or Iran, let alone Russia or other "illiberal democracies." But that's a cheap excuse; after all, I didn't move to Israel, and I don't believe in the re-establishment of Jewish sovereignty, by creating and fostering a country with a dismal human-rights record. The sad fact is that Israel doesn't treat the Palestinians well. As a religious Israeli Jew, I find much of that treatment to be an embarrassment, giving me pause regarding the type of country that we've established here, and the future of Judaism in a sovereign state. That said, I'm pretty liberal in Israeli political terms, and the bloodthirsty words I hear coming from the Hamas leadership, along with the more muted tones I hear from the Fatah-led West Bank, make even me wonder if we can trust the Palestinians. I have to hope that the answer is "yes," because if we can't ever trust each other, then we'll never reach a peace treaty, or ever reach a reasonable compromise. In the end, I get comfort from knowing that Israel is a democracy, with a very strong tradition of free speech and free press, in which all sorts of opinions are allowed, if not welcomed. I have to hope and assume that while the process might be messy, and might take far longer than I like, Israeli governments will eventually manage to reach a peace deal with the Palestinians. Oh, and to claim that Israel is interested in genocide is pure nonsense, and makes an already complex situation into a set of bumper stickers and meaningless statements. To bring this back to the HN focus on startups: One of the reasons for Israelis to compromise, and to reach an agreement with the Palestinians, is to see that we have a lot to lose by not compromising. The rapid growth of high tech in Israel has changed the face of the country, making it stronger and wealthier than ever before. I believe, and maybe I'm wrong here, that the strength, wealth, and integration into the global economy gives Israel an opportunity to negotiate from a position of strength. In other words, Google's entry into Israel's startup scene has the potential to chip away at the problems you have with Israel. It will take time, because things always do in democratic countries, and especially when failure in your foreign and defense policy means the potential death of yourself and your loved ones. So instead of calling Israel names, and saying that the world should simply disengage from what we're doing here, I encourage you to take a more nuanced view, to talk to actual Israelis about what we're doing (and not doing), and to see how we can improve the world through startups and high-tech inventiveness. Google is having a more direct, positive affect on the peace process than your comment did, and for that I commend them.
- mulya 14y agoWhat are you talking about when saying "about to commit genocide"? can you back it with facts? is there a secret message you intercepted? if so please let us all know so we can stop it form happening Or do you mean a real genocide of Norway's Jewish community that Norwegians stood by and did nothing while most of them were murdered during the Holocaust? Aren't you risking that someone from FMC Technologies is either Jewish or Israeli? Don't you think making such baseless racist claims is likely to hurt your own career? Perhaps it's normal and popular to be anti Israeli in Norway, but if you don't provide proof to your claim that Israel is "about to commit genocide", someone might just end up filing a libel suit against you. But I can't blame you. Reading this from Wikipedia explains things a little: >"In 2010, the Norwegian Broadcasting Corporation reported that anti-Semitic attitudes were prevalent at some Norwegian schools. Teachers at schools with large shares of Muslims revealed that Muslim students often "praise or admire Adolf Hitler for his killing of Jews", that "Jew-hate is legitimate within vast groups of Muslim students" and that "Muslims laugh or demand [teachers] to stop when trying to educate about the Holocaust". Additionally that "while some students might protest when some express support for terrorism, none object when students express hate of Jews" and that it says in "the Quran that you shall kill Jews, all true Muslims hate Jews". Most of these students were said to be born and raised in Norway. One Jewish father also told that his child after school had been taken by a Muslim mob (though managed to escape), reportedly "to be taken out to the forest and hanged because he was a Jew".[53][54]" from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_Norway#2010_Norwegian_Broadcasting_Corporation_report http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_Norway#2010_Nor... And since 7.5% of Oslo is Muslim (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_Norway#By_county http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_Norway#By_county), it's not surprising that you have these opinions.
- k0nsl 14y agoI fully agree with you. Well said!