3 ms·
>Had this been a religious idea, I'm afraid the new evidence would have been buried and we'd still have the old, wrong idea. Historically, religions have been
by pretoriusB 14y ago
>Had this been a religious idea, I'm afraid the new evidence would have been buried and we'd still have the old, wrong idea.
Historically, religions have been found to be very adapting, incorporating new and existing ideas, and even elements from other religions. Christianity, for one, has incorporated many foreign elements and have changed over the years adapting to every era.
Sure, people have also been burned as a consequence of religion. Then again, people have been killed as a consequence of science too. 240.000 men, women, children and elderly died in Hiroshima and Nagashaki from the direct results of several years of work by the top physicists of the time. Or the people had followed psychiatric treatments such as lobotomy we now consider BS. Or the tens of thousands sterilised (in Western Europe) by eugenics programs that run until the '70s. Those are consequences of science too -- one cannot separate it from politics arbitrarily, else we can say the same about religion "oh, but a TRUE believer would never harm anyone", etc. Well, many very true scientists are working on biological weapons and other scary things, and a lot of true scientists amongst them hate other people or nations with a passion.
- illuminate 14y ago"Historically, religions have been found to be very adapting" You're talking about syncretism. As new religions are generated, they draw from previous ritual and myth. This is not the sort of adaptation to eliminate falsehoods referenced here. The bible includes elements cribbed from other religions, it is not rewritten to be factual.
- pretoriusB 14y ago>This is not the sort of adaptation to eliminate falsehoods referenced here. The bible includes elements cribbed from other religions, it is not rewritten to be factual. Both things happen. Religions also take things out of their "canon" as the society evolves, precisely to take out old mistakes. The way the Catholic church does not endorse slavery or the "Spanish Inquisition" as it once did, for example.