3 ms·
There are two different activities that can both be described as consuming intellectual property without paying the creator: sharing and piracy. In the past the
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
There are two different activities that can both be described as consuming intellectual property without paying the creator: sharing and piracy. In the past the limitations of having intellectual property tied to individual physical copies made it much easier to separate these activities which made it easy to promote one and punish the other. Also, long traditions of dealing with these different behaviors showed us the relative risks and benefits of them and allowed us to be comfortable with the idea of libraries, for example.
Today, technology has erased those limitations and now the difference between sharing and piracy is much harder to determine, and the mechanisms for ensuring that sharing does not devolve into piracy are either much more technologically different or unproven.
We know from history that there are many, many benefits to sharing and other means of IP consumption without direct monetary compensation. We have a high reverence for libraries, for example, and museums, and art galleries. Logically, there has been a great value to the world in having an enormously expanded volume of music, film, books, etc. available to the world through online file sharing. The question is whether or not this has made it more difficult for IP creators to make a living and if so what the appropriate solution to the problem is.
Those who are extraordinarily naive and extraordinarily shallow minded imagine that there is no benefit to the world due to "piracy" and imagine that if we could just put a stop to it everything would go back to the way it was and we could stop worrying about it. That's not going to work though because we cannot go back. Things are going to change and the equation of how you make money on IP goods is going to be different in the future, that can't be avoided.