3 ms·
Nowhere do I claim that. What I said was that there is research that suggests that the educational level of political leaders is a significant positive predict
by mas_namerif 14y ago
Nowhere do I claim that. What I said was that there is research that suggests that the educational level of political leaders is a significant positive predictor of economic growth, based on a sample of 2000 or so leaders over a period of 129 years.
That is quite different than showing "correlation between education and worldly success" as you paraphrased it into.
The final two points and link are appreciated. I'll read your article with my morning coffee tomorrow.
- lutusp 14y ago> Nowhere do I claim that. No, you just provide graphs comparing educational achievement and worldly achievement that strongly imply that they're meaningfully correlated, i.e. show a cause-effect relationship. > What I said was that there is research that suggests that the educational level of political leaders is a significant positive predictor of economic growth Your use of the term "research" implies a scientific basis for the result. But there is no scientific basis for the claim --- it's a raw correlation with no real meaning, and beyond this, it pretends that there is a correlation between education and schooling. In other words, it relies on two meaningless correlations in series. Like this: Worldly achievement <|> Years in school <|> Education My advice is not to support such unscientific speculations by dressing them up in Web pages that try to confer unearned status to guesses. Do you know what distinguishes what you're doing from science? In science, an explanation is offered, one that can be tested and potentially falsified. Your page only describes, although it pretends to explain. But it cannot do that, for lack of evidence.
- mas_namerif 14y agoI really lack the motivation to go on with this, as appreciative as I am of your passion for science and, apparently, experimental rigor. If you're arguing against the agnosticism of a statistical regression model, then there's nothing I can say to that. This isn't scientific investigation, nor is it masquerading as one. I'm not basing a dissertation on this nor am I using it to develop formal models for Curiosity. It's visualization, it's design, an aesthetic transformation - driven by data, which as I've already pointed out, the analysis of which is published and peer reviewed and available for your and others' scrutiny. If you do not wish to accept it because of your distrust of or dislike for the social sciences for whatever anecdotal reason, then that's fine, but it's not an argument that I can do much with. The standard you're using in this context is misplaced, the zeal unnecessarily antagonistic and a subset of arguments borderline fallacious.