3 ms·
> Different things works for different people. And if it works for them, who are we to say otherwise? The classic defense of astrology. Welcome to the world of
by lutusp 14y ago
> Different things works for different people. And if it works for them, who are we to say otherwise?
The classic defense of astrology. Welcome to the world of science, of objective, dispassionate research. Welcome to modern times, where people compare their ideas to reality.
You do remember reality, yes?
- kamaal 14y agoFrankly speaking if an astrologer were to tell me to buy a lottery ticket with a number he tells me. And I get to become a millionaire, I wouldn't give a damn how, why should or why shouldn't astrology work(And I'm sure neither would you, nor anybody for that matter). I have those millions and that counts.
- lutusp 14y ago> Frankly speaking if an astrologer were to tell me to buy a lottery ticket with a number he tells me. And I get to become a millionaire, I wouldn't give a damn how, why should or why shouldn't astrology work ... You need to learn how science works, and recognize the value of healthy skepticism in particular. There are criminal scams that work just the way you describe, and people are sometimes dumb enough not to see through them. Here's an example of a well-known scam that works again and again among the ignorant -- it's the "Miracle Man" scam: http://arachnoid.com/randomness/index.html#Miracle_Man http://arachnoid.com/randomness/index.html#Miracle_Man > I have those millions and that counts. You need to learn how to think -- hopefully before you get an e-mail from Nigeria.
- kamaal 14y agoI know all that you say. I come from a country(India) where scams like you mention are as common as a sneeze. I know more about them from practical encounters that happen around than you can know about by reading. But as I said for a guy suffering from chronic illness, who is told Hey nothing is wrong with you, and its all in your head, who would probably die otherwise- will rather take his chances with homeopathy or Ayurveda than sit at home and think about hundred reasons why science says otherwise. And wait for the disease to slowly kill him, while allopathy offers him no cure and only costly tests and hospital stay in return. Heck, these system of medicines are one thing. I've even met exorcists around here. I know people who go to these people and come out sane. You can sit down and write a hundred reasons why that shouldn't work. But a person from village side in India or any other poor guy, with hardly enough money to feed his family is not likely to visit a hospital like NIMHANS in Bangalore and spend months with tests and hospital with no cure in sight. He will go to what gives him the quickest and cheapest cure. Its difficult to explain to you because you have never been in a situation where anything and everything you will or can do can't get you out of it. Watching yourself in such misery and realizing the helplessness of your actions. That is when you start looking for miracles. Until you actually face that, anything that I say will attract a justification from you. I sincerely hope you never get caught in such a situation, because let me tell you its a humbling experience when you learn such things the hard way.
- Bakkot 14y agoThe thing to ask yourself in these situations: Which is more likely - coincidence, or that all of science is wrong? Because make no mistake, nothing less is required for exorcism or homeopathy or astrology to work. Hint: It's the first one. Or, to quote Minchin: 'You know what they call alternative medicine that's been proved to work? Medicine.'
- illuminate 14y agoI wouldn't brag about my poor ability to understand causal relationships.