3 ms·
All patents, and in fact all forms of intellectual property protection, by definition apply only to abstract ideas. Legal protection of non-abstract things alre
by baddox 14y ago
All patents, and in fact all forms of intellectual property protection, by definition apply only to abstract ideas. Legal protection of non-abstract things already exists: that's what normal property rights are.
All intellectual property laws forbid me from placing my physical property into certain arrangements. I am free to own ink and sell my products in my boxes, but if I apply that ink to the box in the form of an Apple logo I have violated trademark laws. I am free to own a hard drive and all the tiny magnetic particles therein, but if I cause those particles to take on an arrangement that represents a Beatles' MP3, then I have violated copyright laws. I am free to own a large building and a bunch of machines, but if I arrange these machines into a certain type of assembly line, I may have violated a patent on a manufacturing process.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>All patents, and in fact all forms of intellectual property protection, by definition apply only to abstract ideas. A cotton gin is not an abstract idea, it's a thing you can put in your barn and separate your cotton with. The patent applies to the thing. Even if a patent is inherently an abstraction, that doesn't mean it covers an abstraction. More to the point, if the thing the patent covers is an abstract idea then the patent is not supposed to be issued. This is why you see all these nonsense patents that say "XYZ on a computer" because a computer is an actual non-abstract piece of physical existence, so then the patent lawyers can say "look see, it's not a patent on an abstract idea, it's a patent on a computer that implements an abstract idea." Even though it's really a patent on any computer that implements the abstract idea, i.e. a patent on the idea itself within the domain of computer software.
- baddox 14y agoAny one cotton gin is a physical thing, yes. It should be illegal to take or damage another person's cotton gin, but that's just normal physical property rights. A patent on the cotton gin, however, has nothing to do with protecting your cotton gins from theft or vandalism. A patent prohibits you from shaping and arranging your metal into a shape that allows you to remove seeds from cotton, even if you're not even aware that someone else has patented this arrangement of metal.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoWhat does that have anything to do with abstract ideas not being patentable? You're just arguing that a patent is an abstract idea. But a patent and the thing it covers are two different things. The thing it covers is the thing that's prohibited from being an abstract idea.
- baddox 14y agoNo, I'm not just arguing that a patent is an abstract idea. I'm arguing that all patents cover abstract ideas. Patents don't cover any physical cotton gin, but rather the idea of a cotton gin, i.e. the arrangement of materials that separates the seed from the fibers.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoI guess I can kind of see what you're saying, but where is it supposed to lead? The courts are never going to come to the conclusion that Congress passed a patent statute intending to make nothing whatsoever patentable because all patents cover only abstract ideas and abstract ideas are unpatentable. I think part of the trouble may be that you're finding abstraction in patents and taking that to the conclusion that patents are nothing but abstraction. Take any given patent and you can find some degree of abstraction in it. The question is in some sense whether there is anything else there too, something concrete that nails down a particular invention as distinct from the underlying idea. Is the point that it's an amorphous and nearly unintelligible criteria? Because that's certainly a fair argument. Nobody seems to know exactly what "abstract idea" really means in this context and the courts have been little help. But the same goes for half the laws on the books, so what else is new.
- tossacct 14y agoIt seems like you think that baddox might be trying to make a "point" that is more complicated than what they have written in their posts. baddox>>>All patents, and in fact all forms of intellectual property protection, by definition apply only to abstract ideas. Looking at his posts, I'm not sure that baddox was "leading anywhere". Baddox may have just been making a simple statement of fact. AnthonyMouse>>>Take any given patent and you can find some degree of abstraction in it. The question is in some sense whether there is anything else there too... Correct! This is what is addressed in the lengthy amicus brief, which is summarized by the fine blog poster. Here is a quote that the blogger felt was representative of the amicus position: >>>Many computer-related patent claims just describe an abstract idea at a high level of generality and say to perform it on a computer or over the Internet. >>>... describe an abstract idea at a high level of generality... I suspect that the key here is the phrase "high level of generality", not "abstract idea". So a more accurate article title could be "Companies ask courts to reject patents that are described at a high level of generality". According to current patent law, patents must be useful - a vague, broad, or general idea is not useful or difficult to create. According to current patent law, patents must be new - which currently means "non obvious to an ordinary person in the inventor's field". Patent law has changed over time as a result of legislative action and Supreme Court action, and will presumably continue to do so. The reason why these companies signed and submitted this amicus brief is to influence the court into taking some action that will benefit them. Private citizens are permitted to submit amici as well. There are some links about copyright below. The summaries are very accessible, but are overly simplistic. The actual text of the legislation is also overly simplistic. The Legislature may pass a law that seems fairly readable, but this is deceptive because the Judiciary and the Executive are the interpreters and enforcers of these laws. When you notice that you vehemently do not agree with an interpretation or enforcement of a law, you must communicate this in some way to the government. Citizens generally communicate by voting, direct communication(such as amicus briefs or visible protests), and civil disobedience(nonviolent but illegal actions). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Title_35_of_the_United_States_Code#Section_103 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Title_35_of_the_United_States_C... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Clause http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Clause
- mtgx 14y agoAnd that's why the term intellectual "property" doesn't make sense. You can't own an abstract idea. Surely most of your idea was created out of prior knowledge that belongs to the "collective".
- nova 14y agoAnd that's exactly the reason why intellectual "property" is actually the opposite of real property. It's a restriction on the ways you can use your things, a limitation of your freedoms. Every patent granted, one more thing you can't do even if you rediscovered by yourself, one bit of liberty chipped away. Maybe one can be OK with this, but it's time to call things by their name or we'll never sort out this mess. So maybe after all there isn't so much difference between software and hardware patents. I think it's just that few people have a factory to get bitten by hardware patents, but everyone has a computer so it's much easier both to churn out soft patents and to feel the pain from them.