4 ms·

It’s hyperbolic and intended to generalize the sentiment I perceive from others. Dario Amodei said in January that he expected software engineers to be replace

It’s hyperbolic and intended to generalize the sentiment I perceive from others. Dario Amodei said in January that he expected software engineers to be replaced [0], so I suppose the quote should be extended to “can do anything… a software engineer can do” And I think we can all agree that SWE is on the more complex end of all white collar jobs. So, my thinking is that if SWE can hypothetically be replaced, so can many other jobs. Hence, the claim the models can “do anything” intending to capture the majority of white collar work. This, of course, is if you take their claim at face value - which I certainly do not. [0] https://www.entrepreneur.com/business-news/ai-ceo-says-software-engineers-could-be-replaced-in-months/502087 https://www.entrepreneur.com/business-news/ai-ceo-says-softw...

AndrewKemendo 3mo ago
So then nobody actually has ever said that and its explicitly hyperbole So then its misleading in the extreme to say “I’ve been told AI can do anything” It amplifies hype when people make claims like this by including hyperbolic statements as though they are reflective of the state of the discussion.
- weakfish 3mo ago
  Alright, sure, my bad. I thought it was clear that it was meant tongue in cheek, but I’ll accept it was unclear. That said, with respect what I clarified, I’m curious your thoughts.
Kiro 3mo ago
Code is the killer app for LLMs so software developers are the easiest to replace.
- weakfish 3mo ago
  Code isn’t what the majority of software engineering is.
  - Kiro 3mo ago
    Pointless nitpicking that completely missed my point. Software developers are not the hardest to replace, so your presumption that everything else should be easier is wrong.
    - weakfish 3mo ago
      Next time, try being polite, it’ll make me way more inclined to engage with you. If I missed your point it was unintentional. Instead of being rude, try gentle clarification. But now I’ve lost interest. Have a good day!
      - deleted 3mo ago
        [deleted]

AndrewKemendo 3mo ago

So then nobody actually has ever said that and its explicitly hyperbole So then its misleading in the extreme to say “I’ve been told AI can do anything” It amplifies hype when people make claims like this by including hyperbolic statements as though they are reflective of the state of the discussion.

weakfish 3mo ago
Alright, sure, my bad. I thought it was clear that it was meant tongue in cheek, but I’ll accept it was unclear. That said, with respect what I clarified, I’m curious your thoughts.

Kiro 3mo ago

Code is the killer app for LLMs so software developers are the easiest to replace.

weakfish 3mo ago
Code isn’t what the majority of software engineering is.
- Kiro 3mo ago
  Pointless nitpicking that completely missed my point. Software developers are not the hardest to replace, so your presumption that everything else should be easier is wrong.
  - weakfish 3mo ago
    Next time, try being polite, it’ll make me way more inclined to engage with you. If I missed your point it was unintentional. Instead of being rude, try gentle clarification. But now I’ve lost interest. Have a good day!
    - deleted 3mo ago
      [deleted]