6 ms·
From the article: "Ramsey says it was a good deal, because his district is getting a brand-new $25 million school. 'You'd take that any day,' he says. 'Why wou
by tokenadult 14y ago
From the article:
"Ramsey says it was a good deal, because his district is getting a brand-new $25 million school. 'You'd take that any day,' he says. 'Why would you leave $25 million on the table? You would never leave $25 million on the table.'
"But that doesn't make the arrangement a good deal, says California State Treasurer Bill Lockyer. 'It's the school district equivalent of a payday loan or a balloon payment that you might obligate yourself for,' Lockyer says. 'So you don't pay for, maybe, 20 years — and suddenly you have a spike in interest rates that's extraordinary.'"
No, I would leave that on the table. I wouldn't agree to a sucker loan like that on my own behalf, nor would I agree to it as a public official on the taxpayer's behalf. The problem here is that the public official forgot that he has a fiduciary duty to the public. I wonder if he learned his civics and his understanding of the mathematics of loan interest in a California public high school.
AFTER EDIT: Oops, I almost forgot a rare example of a pithy quotation attributed to Mark Twain that is an actual genuine Mark Twain quotation. This is what he wrote about school boards more than a century ago:
"In the first place God made idiots. This was for practice. Then He made School Boards." -- Mark Twain, Following the Equator (1903) 2:295
AFTER SECOND EDIT: The claim that the school district did well to take out a loan on unfavorable terms to also obtain a loan with a federal subsidy doesn't take into account that all the taxpayers in the district are also on the hook for federal deficit spending, as most of them are federal taxpayers directly and all are part of the national economy.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sputknick 14y agoIf you look more completely at the deal it actual is a good deal for the school district. They will pay a total of $34 million over 20 years to obtain $25 million. So their effective total interest is only $9 million, which works out to about 2% per year... an excellent loan rate for anyone. What is hidden in that is that the other $23 million (34-9) in interest that is "free" to the school district is actually paid by all of us as taxpayers. If given the opportunity why not have taxpayers across the country finance your school district? I would fire any superintendent who DIDN'T take that deal. I'm not arguing that this is a morally correct thing to do, just that it makes good financial sense from the superintendent's perspective.
- stickfigure 14y agoThis is not what the article states. The article says they will pay a total of $34 million to receive a $25 million federally subsidized loan. Presumably the principal and interest on the $25 million must be repaid as well, so the actual cost of that $25 million is somewhere north of $60 million.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tzs 14y agoThe $25 million they obtained was a loan, want it? You have to include paying that back, and the interest on that loan, in you calculation.
- sputknick 14y agoFair enough. Let's assume they are getting $27,500,000 (adding the private loan with the federal loan) and let's assume they will repay $70,000,000 after 20 years. We still come up with an effective interest rate of 5%. Still not a bad deal.
- btilly 14y agoAccording to http://credittrends.moodys.com/ http://credittrends.moodys.com/ right now long term corporate bond rates are 4% or so. If the school district does not have bad credit, 5% probably is a bad deal in today's market.
- justincormack 14y agoRates have fallen a lot in the last few years so that's not quite a fair comparison. Wish the article would give detail not hype.
- rtkwe 14y agoExcept where did they plan to come up with that money? School budgets don't tend to grow that fast and building a new school adds additional costs. I'm not arguing that new schools shouldn't be built but taking on large debts without clear plans.
- csallen 14y ago>> "Ramsey says it was a good deal, because his district is getting a brand-new $25 million school. 'You'd take that any day,' he says. 'Why would you leave $25 million on the table? You would never leave $25 million on the table.'" It's maddeningly common for people to neglect that pesky "cost" part of a cost-benefit analysis.
- mathattack 14y agoAnd it's still another $25 million loan, even if on good terms.
- joelhaus 14y agoOn the contrary, the "cost" is quite clear[1][2]. It's the "benefit" part which requires a highly dynamic analysis. Bottom-line: A Loan makes sense for the borrower when the return on loan proceeds exceeds the cost of the loan. Since the reporting completely left this out[3], if anyone is aware of models used to measure return on such public investments, your insight would be extremely beneficial to those of us commenting on this article. [1] CABs are fixed rate. http://www.msrb.org/msrb1/glossary/view_def.asp?param=capitalappreciationbond http://www.msrb.org/msrb1/glossary/view_def.asp?param=capita... [2] See 16731.5 (a)(3). http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=gov&group=16001-17000&file=16730-16737 http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=gov... [3] The public is genuinely harmed by this type of reporting and it drives me nuts. How can anyone draw a rational conclusion to these difficult policy issues without a best effort cost-benefit analysis of the transaction?
- rorrr 14y agoWell, this idiot gets to put "built a brand-new $25 million school" on his resume. He's benefiting himself without any cost, while screwing the taxpayers.