4 ms·
The weird thing for me is that I'm an atheist, almost sometimes a militant atheist, and yet by far the only people I met doing decent work in Afghanistan were:
by rdl 14y ago
The weird thing for me is that I'm an atheist, almost sometimes a militant atheist, and yet by far the only people I met doing decent work in Afghanistan were:
1) Afghan expats (generally moderately religious), like doctors from London who had moved back.
2) Christian missionaries, specifically those who had remained in Afghanistan from ~1979-2001 and beyond. To a limited extent, some (religious based) US charities as well.
Totally absent were USG organizations like DOD, USAID; the UN; various NGOs; ISAF; etc. The UN water pumps were helpful, but those I think mainly pre-dated the 2001 conflict, and in no way approach making up for the harm caused by the UNODC drug control policies.
SSF, Fab Lab, the guest house, Tim, etc. all did some worthwhile stuff, but were really an exception. In general, the only people doing anything helpful were locals and religious people.
This was slightly less true in Iraq; there were some limited positive works done by NGOs and by specific military commanders (using their under-$100k local budgets), and some worthwhile projects from CA.
- pstuart 14y agoPerhaps it's harder to slack off on doing the right thing when God is watching.