2 ms·
Yes, but not having to ask permission isn't the same as not having to include an attribution of the source and its author. The latter is required in virtually a
by lutusp 14y ago
Yes, but not having to ask permission isn't the same as not having to include an attribution of the source and its author. The latter is required in virtually all cases. Consider the issue of plagiarism -- is it plagiarism if the plagiarized work is in the public domain? I think you know the answer.
- Steuard 14y agoI'm a college professor and a research scientist: I'd better know the answer! But I've never heard that plagiarism is a legal issue. Are there actual laws on the books that criminalize plagiarism of public domain material? (I live in the US; is that answer different here than elsewhere?) But honestly, your objection here is very much a side issue. As I already said, the point of my example earlier was to wonder whether someone could hypothetically transcribe the Foundation stories from the audio recording and sell the resulting novels, complete with a cover reading "Isaac Asimov's /Foundation/" (and perhaps with "Edited by J. Smith" in small text somewhere).
- lutusp 14y ago> But I've never heard that plagiarism is a legal issue. Are there actual laws on the books that criminalize plagiarism of public domain material? It's more typically an issue of academics ethics. Plagiarism is a very serious charge in academia (and to some extent in politics), regardless of the source of the plagiarized material. As to its being a legal issue, I don't think so, but IANAL. My earlier point was about proper attribution. > As I already said, the point of my example earlier was to wonder whether someone could hypothetically transcribe the Foundation stories from the audio recording and sell the resulting novels, complete with a cover reading "Isaac Asimov's /Foundation/" (and perhaps with "Edited by J. Smith" in small text somewhere). I have to say I don't know how that would play out. I guess the example of Shakespeare's plays stands as an example of the freedom one may have in such a case. But that's not plagiarism -- defined as claiming another's work as your own.