4 ms·
I'm frankly, not converted by this uninspiring call to arms. If you'd like to convert me, offer more than just a "we're doing it wrong, this is the direction we
by falcolas 14y ago
I'm frankly, not converted by this uninspiring call to arms. If you'd like to convert me, offer more than just a "we're doing it wrong, this is the direction we should go".
Instead, offer me a graphical solution to the same problem you posed against the 'nix shell. It doesn't even have to work; a series of photoshopped images would be welcome.
Show me something better, because that 'nix philosophy works very well, whereas its replacements don't (seriously, can anyone think of a way to come up with that list of files without resorting to a shell or programming your own solution?)
- jdbernard 14y agoExactly what I think. I am content with a text interface because honestly I do not think there will be a more intuitive way to exchange ideas than language, a skill we have been honing for thousands of years. OP, build that better, graphical interface. When you blow by me because you are so much more productive, don't worry, I'll take notice. Until then you can take my text editor when you can pry it from my cold, dead hands.
- clebio 14y agoAgreed. He should provide a graphical solution to every example given. It's distressing that none are given, not even then ignore-exception piece. That's the brilliance of Bret Victor's essays: he posits the idea, bringing you along in the 'yeah, that's been bugging me, too' fashion, and then proceeds to guide you through working solutions that build on themselves over the course of the piece. If you've been properly dog-fooding, show us the crumbs and the empty bowl to prove it. Graphical wrappers to plain text are not only 'orders of magnitude harder [to implement]', but that much harder to debug as well. If your GUI client to a remote server beach-balls waiting for a command to complete, is your code wrong, or your connection latent, or your desktop app crashing? An SSH connection to the CLI server can cut through a lot of that pretty quick.
- est 14y ago> Instead, offer me a graphical solution to the same problem 1. open a folder 2. Click the "File Type" column 3. Drag to select all txt files 4. Hold Ctrl, click to deselect the ignore_me.txt
- falcolas 14y agoThat does not fulfill the original requirement set forth by the author: > Here's a simple task: print a list of all the files with a txt extension in the current directory except for ignore_me.txt. Your solution, and one of the the sibling comment solutions, will select all of those files, not print a list of them. Pedantic, perhaps, but the solution outlined by the OP is not mirrored by your solution. This isn't automation, this isn't anything but simple file manipulation, that most graphical operating systems are incapable of; it's also a simple display of how graphical UIs fall short of the shell.
- 69_years_and 14y agoI'm going to guess you are making a joke, esp. the ctrl click to deselect. I did not even read the rest of the article, once I got to the word visual, I did a quick scan for an example, none found, came here to see what others thought. Second read, maybe u are not making a joke? While not mentioned, how would u automate that?
- hollerith 14y agoSince the times when automation is not necessary greatly outnumber the times when it is, "how would u automate that?" is not exactly a knock-out blow to the pro-GUI position. In other words, even for people like me who when asked, "how would u automate that?" would reply, "I'd write a shell script or some Emacs Lisp," it is IMHO often better to do it in a GUI when automation is not necessary. (No joking.)