4 ms·
I think about it analytically all the time. And I know it to be repeatable. Twelve years of steady improvement would be one helluva "coincidence". I spent many
by Mz 14y ago
I think about it analytically all the time. And I know it to be repeatable. Twelve years of steady improvement would be one helluva "coincidence".
I spent many years trying to learn to argue "correctly" in my martiage -- unemotionally, citing my sources, etc. I can do that. But it matters not how well I do it, I am still dismissed. You are dismissing me without knowing my story, and conveniently blaming me. I imagine you will never see my point, no matter how I present it.
I am working on trying to find the right presentation. But your approach is largely antithetical to mine and mine got me well. Finding a meeting ground is challenging, and most people make no attempt to meet me halfway.
Thank you for replying though.
- carbocation 14y agoDo you happen to have a summary of your story on the web somewhere? Not that you should feel obligated to share it, but if you have shared it before I would like to try to understand.
- Mz 14y agoThere isn't really a summary of my story anywhere but there is a website. I commented on that elsewhere earlier today: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4895256 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4895256 There isn't a summary because I get accused of having Munchausen Syndrome -- a sick need for attention -- rather than Cystic Fibrosis. It is quite dangerous to try to tell my story. It routinely results in public attacks, and moderators typically side with my attackers. You are welcome to email me if you wish to discuss it privately.
- lutusp 14y ago> There isn't a summary because I get accused of having Munchausen Syndrome ... And it has occurred to you that you may have Munchausen Syndrome, yes? > It is quite dangerous to try to tell my story. Not if you tell the truth. "Truth never damages a cause that is just" -- Gandhi > It routinely results in public attacks, and moderators typically side with my attackers. But with no justification or reason at all. Right? It's obvious that you're playing this out for all it is worth, without providing any real information, portraying yourself as the innocent victim of persecution, but in a way calculated to avoid providing any actual data, or anything that might lead to a resolution. I wonder if you realize how transparent you are, to an objective observer?
- Mz 14y agoPeople with Munchausen claim to be ill and manufacture fake symptoms when they are not. I was ill and am getting well, a claim most people will not accept as true. What "real information" do you want? I linked to my website. You are the one focusing on dismissing me, personally, and have apparently not bothered to even check the website. Here are the direct links if you need them again: http://www.healthgazelle.com http://www.healthgazelle.com http://www.healthgazelle.com/oldsite/archive.shtml http://www.healthgazelle.com/oldsite/archive.shtml
- lutusp 14y ago> People with Munchausen claim to be ill and manufacture fake symptoms when they are not. People with Munchausen fake medical difficulties. You're displaying all the classic symptoms. The distinction between suffering from an imaginary ailment, or slowly recovering from an imaginary ailment, makes no difference. > You are the one focusing on dismissing me, personally, and have apparently not bothered to even check the website. I read your comments there, and they're as uninformative as your comments here. Color me surprised. > What "real information" do you want? If you weren't a Munchausen sufferer, you would already know the answer to that question, and you would have already answered it -- either here or on the other forum at which you vent your dissatisfaction with reality.
- Mz 14y agoSo, basically, you think I have Munchausen therefore I have it and there is no need to actually engage me in discussion. Color me surprised.
- lutusp 14y ago> to actually engage me in discussion. What discussion is that? If you had any idea what a discussion consisted of, you would be well underway by now. And you would have avoided trying to connect CF with "germs", even among computer people, people you obviously chose in the forlorn hope of sympathy from ignoramuses.
- 14y ago
- lutusp 14y ago> I spent many years trying to learn to argue "correctly" in my martiage -- unemotionally, citing my sources, etc. I can do that. But it matters not how well I do it, I am still dismissed. You're not being dismissed because your accurate, concise description is being ignored, you're being dismissed because you haven't provided an accurate, concise description. When I want to argue a controversial point, I link to one of my many articles on diverse topics. Example: http://arachnoid.com/trouble_with_psychology http://arachnoid.com/trouble_with_psychology Where's yours? And do you think you have the right to claim unjust treatment if you haven't ever clearly explained your case? > Finding a meeting ground is challenging, and most people make no attempt to meet me halfway. No, and I can see why -- if someone tries to meet you halfway, you move the goal posts, then complain about how badly you've been treated.
- Mz 14y agoI have made good faith efforts for many years which ascribed to the rules you are trying to dictate, to no avail. No matter how well I argue the latest supposed reason for dismissing me, it makes no difference. There is another excuse behind that one. You are only the latest in a very long string of people to dismiss me, then justify that dismissal as somehow my fault. It isn't anything new to me, not at all. It's a very old story in fact. But thank you for replying.
- lutusp 14y ago> I have made good faith efforts for many years which ascribed to the rules you are trying to dictate, to no avail. Look, no offense, but you're obviously not going to win over intelligent readers with your diligent avoidance of anything substantive. You are quite obviously trying for sympathy but without providing anything concrete or testable. It's a symptom of Munchausen Syndrome. > You are only the latest in a very long string of people to dismiss me, then justify that dismissal as somehow my fault. It's not "somehow" your fault. It is your fault. You want sympathy but without earning it. This is why you have to keep changing forums -- people catch on too quickly. You're a textbook case of Munchausen Syndrome -- imaginary ailments, ailment you go to great lengths to (a) complain about but (b) conceal, a marked persecution complex, the usual accompanying histrionic syndrome ("It's dangerous to try to describe my condition"), and a general inability to picture yourself realistically. Get professional help.
- mikeash 14y agoYou realize that crazy coincidences happen all the time? A disease that's 99.999% fatal will routinely have survivors if the disease is common enough. A single data point doesn't mean a whole lot.
- Mz 14y agoAs I said elsewhere: I am not a single data point. Further, I did not merely live. The hole in my lung closed and I have gradually but steadily reversed my symptoms over the course of more than a decade. Would you like to actually discuss it? I am pretty tired of being dismissed by people who assume I am not thorough but themselves fail to be thorough enough to read all existing remarks in the discussion before jumping up with the same tired criticisms I have heard before and addressed previously in this very discussion.
- lutusp 14y ago> I am pretty tired of being dismissed ... By scientists in a science/technology forum that has no connection whatever to health or medicine? What did you expect?
- mikeash 14y agoMaybe people wouldn't be so ready to dismiss you if you didn't lead off with such awful arguments for your position. You give an emotional story about your own personal improvement, then complain when, what, we don't read your mind and realize there's more? If you're thorough, show it. It's completely unreasonable to start off so weakly and then complain when people call you on it.
- Mz 14y agoI am trying to figure out how to show it and have been for a long time. What you seem to not understand, and likely do not wish to understand, is that showing it is quite difficult when a) everyone attacks you and b) the mental models which worked are "unproven" and do not fit easily into the mental models other people require as evidence. People in this discussion are being very vehement about calling me crazy. There is no opening there for discussing how I view CF differently from current mental models. And to a large degree my credibility problem boils down to either you believe my story, that I have CF and got well and it is the basis for useful insights, or you do not. Most people do not. You can use whatever excuse du jour you want, but at the root of it, that is why I get dismissed: Because the entire world believes people with CF do not get well. Period. To claim otherwise automatically makes one "crazy". I continue to try to figure out how to more effectively engage people in discussion. But most people are unwilling to engage me in discussion. Even when they are being listed for transplant and in serious decline. If the speak to me at all, it is to reiterate that belief that their decline is inevitable, everyone knows that. People are dying to prove that belief true. I understand why they feel the need to defend it, but I have tried every avenue to try to find a means to talk to people. HN is less ugly about it than most places. This is actually as good as it gets, which, unfortunately, is not very helpful in my effort to find a means to present my case effectively. If I had come out with a phd length dissertation on what I did to get well, most likely no one would read it. I am sorry you don't get my point here. I hope you are never in the kind of position I am in currently. Presumably you don't get it because you haven't experienced anything like it.