3 ms·
I'm absolutely certain that "modern medicine" doesn't have all the answers, and is woefully incomplete. I'm absolutely certain that there are things currently
by ColinWright 14y ago
I'm absolutely certain that "modern medicine" doesn't have all the answers, and is woefully incomplete. I'm absolutely certain that there are things currently considered as "alternative medicine" that will turn out to be valid when practised correctly, and on suitable patients with suitable conditions. I'm absolutely certain that there are people for whom the prescribed treatment from "modern medicine" was, in fact, wrong.
I'm also absolutely certain that the vast majority of "alternative medicine" is not, in fact, better than "modern medicine." Exceptions will exist, and true scientists would use them as stepping stones to better knowledge, better practice, and better medicine. The fact that your experience indicates otherwise is a clear indication that things not only could be better, but should be better. The true failure is not that modern medicine was wrong and that you appear to have been saved by "alternative medicine", but that your success is not taken seriously, and is basically ignored, by those in whom we ultimately place our trust to find and implement cures.
That doesn't stop it being true that there are people who seek "alternative treatments" when they would be better off going with "modern medicine", and all evidence suggests that they are the vast majority of cases.
- Mz 14y agoThere are really huge problems with the entire current system. That is why so many people seek alternatives. When I turned to "alternative treatments", doctors were calling me crazy and denying me treatment. Had they offered me real treatment, I would have gladly taken it. This is not a journey I desired to make. Not at all. But the problem with this being posted here is that the entire discussion will revolve around dismissing alternative medicine and not on what is wrong with the bigger picture that I and other people would consciously choose to take our chances on unproven methods rather than accept what little was offered us. I was in constant excruciating pain. If my own experiments had resulted in sudden death, I felt that was better than the slow torturous death modern medicine offers people like me. I know you are a mathematician. I imagine this piece hits a nerve for you. But bashing alternatives doesn't fix the real problem and will help close off avenues of escape from a larger system which is not working. That larger failure includes conflating "health care" and "medicine" when they are not the same thing but it is hardly limited to that issue. Thank you for replying.
- irahul 14y ago> Had they offered me real treatment, I don't know what you mean by real treatment, but a doctor will offer you what he knows is best based on his education, experience, past medical history and medical tests. If that's unreal to you, well, I don't know what can the doctor do about that. > what is wrong with the bigger picture that I and other people would consciously choose to take our chances on unproven methods rather than accept what little was offered us. I am sorry but I am missing the bigger picture. If the doctor could help, he will. If he won't, some other doctor would. It's a service industry after all. But when doctors say they can't help you, it's because they can't. What's the bigger picture here? Modern medicine has limitations, error rates and unknowns. People acknowledge and work on them. As another commenter pointed out, the "alternate medicine" that actually works is called "medicine". If eating some fruit is curing cancer, it will be researched and integrated in modern medicine. The pharma companies or any other researcher have no reason not to accept things that work, whether they are manufactured in a lab or found in jungles of India.
- Mz 14y agoMy doctor told me outright "people like you do not get well. Symptom management is the name of the game." When I improved anyway, he expressed no curiosity. He scheduled me fewer and fewer appointments and indicated other patients were more in need of his services than I was. It is routine that when patients with CF decline, their doctor makes zero effort to reverse the decline. Their decline is blamed on their genes. One doctor who did make real effort had a track record of helping people with CF improve. People used to travel very long distances to see him. Last I heard, he is now retired. But it is the norm in the medical community to tell people with CF, in essence, "Do not even bother to try. You are doomed anyway." even though all evidence supports the idea that this is not true.