5 ms·
> My views and experiences are dismissed wholesale before I even open my mouth. Try describing your experience scientifically, rather than emotionally (as you
by lutusp 14y ago
> My views and experiences are dismissed wholesale before I even open my mouth.
Try describing your experience scientifically, rather than emotionally (as you are doing). See how that works. You might learn something you don't already know, as might your listeners.
The chances are very high that your story is one of coincidence rather then repeatable effect, but until you actually think about it analytically, you will never know.
- ColinWright 14y agoI'm pretty sure you're talking to someone who has tried pretty much every possible avenue to get people to listen to her, failed, and is now rather bitter about how she is treated over the whole episode. Mz can speak for herself, but I suspect your advice is well-meant, but badly misplaced.
- lutusp 14y ago> I suspect your advice is well-meant, but badly misplaced. The advice to post a scientific description instead of an emotional one is never misplaced.
- carbocation 14y agoHis advice is great. She might not take it, but lutusp's audience is the entire internet.
- Mz 14y agoI think about it analytically all the time. And I know it to be repeatable. Twelve years of steady improvement would be one helluva "coincidence". I spent many years trying to learn to argue "correctly" in my martiage -- unemotionally, citing my sources, etc. I can do that. But it matters not how well I do it, I am still dismissed. You are dismissing me without knowing my story, and conveniently blaming me. I imagine you will never see my point, no matter how I present it. I am working on trying to find the right presentation. But your approach is largely antithetical to mine and mine got me well. Finding a meeting ground is challenging, and most people make no attempt to meet me halfway. Thank you for replying though.
- carbocation 14y agoDo you happen to have a summary of your story on the web somewhere? Not that you should feel obligated to share it, but if you have shared it before I would like to try to understand.
- Mz 14y agoThere isn't really a summary of my story anywhere but there is a website. I commented on that elsewhere earlier today: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4895256 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4895256 There isn't a summary because I get accused of having Munchausen Syndrome -- a sick need for attention -- rather than Cystic Fibrosis. It is quite dangerous to try to tell my story. It routinely results in public attacks, and moderators typically side with my attackers. You are welcome to email me if you wish to discuss it privately.
- lutusp 14y ago> There isn't a summary because I get accused of having Munchausen Syndrome ... And it has occurred to you that you may have Munchausen Syndrome, yes? > It is quite dangerous to try to tell my story. Not if you tell the truth. "Truth never damages a cause that is just" -- Gandhi > It routinely results in public attacks, and moderators typically side with my attackers. But with no justification or reason at all. Right? It's obvious that you're playing this out for all it is worth, without providing any real information, portraying yourself as the innocent victim of persecution, but in a way calculated to avoid providing any actual data, or anything that might lead to a resolution. I wonder if you realize how transparent you are, to an objective observer?
- Mz 14y agoPeople with Munchausen claim to be ill and manufacture fake symptoms when they are not. I was ill and am getting well, a claim most people will not accept as true. What "real information" do you want? I linked to my website. You are the one focusing on dismissing me, personally, and have apparently not bothered to even check the website. Here are the direct links if you need them again: http://www.healthgazelle.com http://www.healthgazelle.com http://www.healthgazelle.com/oldsite/archive.shtml http://www.healthgazelle.com/oldsite/archive.shtml
- juniper5 14y ago> Try describing your experience scientifically, rather than emotionally (as you are doing). See how that works. It works terribly, which is probably why she tends to be skittish on that front. If/when you do get a straight answer, she's going to tell you she cured CF with sea salt (yes, that's the big mystery).