3 ms·
> "Not to dismiss your valid concern, the problem is that when an automotive mechanic fails to fix a car, the failure gets blamed on a malfunction or on the own
by jlgreco 14y ago
> "Not to dismiss your valid concern, the problem is that when an automotive mechanic fails to fix a car, the failure gets blamed on a malfunction or on the owner not driving their car correctly, etc, But when an automotive witch-doctor blesses your car and a failure occurs, it is used to smear all automotive-blessings. The climate is already biased against meaningful discussion of automotive witchdoctors."
There is no evidence that blessing your car will prevent it from breaking down. Therefore when you car does break down after a blessing, that can be nothing but evidence that blessing a car does nothing.
On the other hand there is an abundance of evidence stating that automotive mechanics can diagnose and treat faulty cars, so when an automotive mechanic fails to do that it of course means any number of things could have gone wrong.
We only see your "bias" in situations where there was no evidence to support the treatment in the first place. It's not a bias, it is just common sense.
- Mz 14y agoFunny you should say that. It reminds me that I want to write a piece titled "Your body is not a car". Unlike a car, a body can repair itself. If you get a minor cut, it closes on its own, without repair by a doctor. Not so with a car. Scratch the paint, the scratch is permanent -- unless you repair it. There are better means to support the body's own repair system than nuking it with toxic chemicals. Attempts to discuss that tend to get dismissed as quackery. I posit you are throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
- niyazpk 14y agoAny place where interested readers can learn more about your proposed alternatives? Your arguments here makes it feel like there is a prerequisite of knowing your (comment?) history to understand what you really mean.
- Mz 14y agoI kind of answered that elsewhere in this discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4895581 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4895581
- juniper5 14y agoShe allegedly has (had?) CF, which she magically cured by eating a lot of sea salt. She generally talks vague circles around that point and avoids giving straight answers (preferring instead to go on about how nobody believes her, etc), but if you dig far enough to the heart of her pet issue - that's it. The throwaway is braced for downvotes... but if that's not the truth, Mz, feel free to actually post a clear & concise defense saying otherwise.
- lutusp 14y agoMy advice is not to feed this troll. She will dodge and weave, then blame people for not understanding her. She also doesn't know what she's talking about -- she insists there are no progressive genetic conditions without environmental factors. Dozens of such conditions falsify her position.
- jlgreco 14y agoYou can fix your own body without visiting a doctor, and you can fix your own car without visiting a mechanic. Sometimes a doctor or a mechanic will fuck up, and sometimes those cases intersect with the cases where you could have fixed the problem yourself. This is not an argument against either doctors nor mechanics. You probably get dismissed as a quack when you suggest that all doctors do is "nuke your body with toxic chemicals". I would say that 90% of the times I have ever been to a doctor the doctor has either told me "walk it off" (read: let your body fix itself), or "here are some stitches, now walk it off". (And I am the sort of person that heavily leans towards ignoring the problem and avoiding doctor visits...)
- Mz 14y agoThe point is the body will try to repair itself if it can. A car will not. For very deadly conditions like I have, nuking the body is the standard practice. They do the same thing with cancer. That is a statement of fact. It shouldn't be used as a flimsy excuse to call me a quack.
- jlgreco 14y agoI don't see how the mechanism of the car being fixed is terribly important. Either you fix it, a mechanic fixes it, or it stays broken. Either your body fixes your body, a doctor fixes your body, or it stays broken. Arguments against doctors and mechanics, even if they were legitimate (and they are not) are not arguments in favour of magic. I don't pretend to know anything about your situation, but in the cases of cancer we nuke the body because the evidence shows that doing that is better than a placebo. Chemotherapy is not an argument against modern medicine. It is actually a great argument for it. Even if it were an argument against modern medicine, that would not make it an argument in favour of alternative 'medicine'. You can slander doctors all day, but "doctors suck" does not logically imply "alternative medicine isn't bullshit"
- Mz 14y agoWell, but it is significant. Can we back up a minute here? On the small scale, is it true that your body will generally repair a small scratch with zero "treatment" but your car will not? Can we agree on that point, before talking about doctors or mechanics?