45 ms·
None of these three items are necessarily true of "having a descriptive title on a Web [sic] site". Why not? Having a properly worded title could be the differ
by petercooper 18y ago
None of these three items are necessarily true of "having a descriptive title on a Web [sic] site".
Why not? Having a properly worded title could be the difference between having 100 people find your project or 1000 people find it. Those people are then the difference between you getting consulting gigs for whatever you invented or not.
With your criteria you could argue that Ruby on Rails (the original topic a few posts up) could not possibly be "marketed" as the developers did not "gain financially" from people using it, but in an indirect way they certainly did - conferences, prestige (non-financial), consulting gigs, book deals, and so forth.
Take the word "financially" out of your criteria, however, to cover these open source cases and nearly all communications is marketing. After all, when I first met my now-wife, I stood to gain if she liked me, I wanted her to like me, and I certainly played up on my good points.
The thing I want to point out is that item 3 is very much at odds with basic norms of honest discourse
Honest discourse, perhaps, but most day to day discourse is not honest. On the whole, people will play up positive aspects of things they like and downplay negative aspects that work against them or things they have a high opinion of.
I think that's why so many people hate marketing: it creates a constant temptation to dishonesty, most marketers succumb to it at least a little, and that severely damages the quality of discourse in conversations that contain marketers.
I'd say that the majority of conversation has that quality. But most people don't hate conversation, even though it is typically riddled with manipulation and selective truths (usually in a quite non-malicious way.. few husbands are really going to tell the wife their butt does look big in those jeans..).
- kragen 18y agoI wrote: None of these three items are necessarily true of "having a descriptive title on a Web [sic] site". Peter Cooper responded: Why not? Having a properly worded title could... There is a difference between what could be the case and what is necessarily the case. It is certainly true that having a descriptive title on a web page could be marketing. My claim was that it was not necessarily marketing, and in fact need not satisfy any of those criteria. Peter Cooper wrote: With your criteria you could argue that Ruby on Rails (the original topic a few posts up) could not possibly be "marketed"... You could argue that if you were an idiot. But you would still be wrong. Peter Cooper wrote further: Take the word "financially" out ... and nearly all communications is marketing.... most day to day discourse is not honest...the majority of conversation has that quality. Actually, a substantial fraction of human communications are not, in fact, attempts to dishonestly manipulate someone else's opinions for the personal gain of the speaker. I understand that you may not be aware of this, but I assure you that it is true. By the way, I love Github.
- petercooper 18y ago-sigh- There I was thinking this was a reasonable discussion and it gets dragged down to a childish "yah boo well you're just wrong" level. Fine, you "win" :)