8 ms·
Yes, but there are now more accounts being unearthed of people foregoing or declining conventional treatments because they have become convinced that homeopathy
by ColinWright 14y ago
Yes, but there are now more accounts being unearthed of people foregoing or declining conventional treatments because they have become convinced that homeopathy will cure them. Promoting homeopathy, if successful, can result in more deaths.
- yason 14y agoThat's stepping on the jurisdiction of those people over themselves. Everyone is entitled to believe in whatever they want to and live by that. They might die but it's their death, not other people's.
- pathy 14y agoExcept if parents refuse to allow proper treatment for their children because of religious or other beliefs, such as being in favour of "natural remedies" rather than lifesaving medicines.
- danso 14y agoExcerpt that if such people live in a modern society, society bears the cost of such malpractice. And so it behooves other members of that society to at least argue against ineffective practices.
- Joeri 14y agoThat reasoning would lead you to conclude seatbelts should be optional. Fundamentally, the reasoning goes like this: (a) you have an obligation to protect friends and family from their own bad decisions, and (b) there's no fundamental difference between a friend and a stranger, hence (c) some things should be enforced by law for the good of everyone.
- yason 14y agoNow that I think about it, basically they should be optional. One reason their use could be mandatory is that in a crash the occupants might fly out of the car and kill other people if they're not using seatbelts. But I'm not sure how relevant point that would be given that the people are allowed to drive a two-tonne killing machine with very little training in the first place. However, if we do not consider bystanders, I don't see a problem making use of seatbelts optional. It doesn't hurt to mandate that all cars must be equipped with seatbelts for the benefit of availability for everyone who wants to use seatbelts—which is most people. Seatbelts do save lives but, again, it's not a criminal offense to commit suicide and fail. So, to think, actually, I find it quite disturbing that they are not optional. I hadn't thought about it before. It's an inevitable slippery slope in that you can't really draw the line anywhere as long as you feel obliged to protect everyone. Could citizens be forced to eat a certain diet to make them not die of obesity, diabetes and cardiac/circulation problems too early? It's certainly ok to inform the citizens of healthier diets, so that everyone can make their own choices with the best information available. But I argue that in the end everyone is sovereign when it comes to their own life and body.
- illuminate 14y ago"Everyone is entitled to believe in whatever they want to and live by that." No one should be entitled to sell snake oil and quackery.
- Mz 14y agoPrescription drugs kill lots of people too. No one ever cites that as reason to skip seeing a doctor. Not to dismiss your valid concern, the problem is that when doctor's kill someone, the death gets blamed on a disease or on the patient not taking the medication correctly, etc. But when an alternative treatment is used and death occurs, it is used to smear all alternative treatments. The climate is already biased against meaningful discussion of such things.
- jlgreco 14y ago> "Not to dismiss your valid concern, the problem is that when an automotive mechanic fails to fix a car, the failure gets blamed on a malfunction or on the owner not driving their car correctly, etc, But when an automotive witch-doctor blesses your car and a failure occurs, it is used to smear all automotive-blessings. The climate is already biased against meaningful discussion of automotive witchdoctors." There is no evidence that blessing your car will prevent it from breaking down. Therefore when you car does break down after a blessing, that can be nothing but evidence that blessing a car does nothing. On the other hand there is an abundance of evidence stating that automotive mechanics can diagnose and treat faulty cars, so when an automotive mechanic fails to do that it of course means any number of things could have gone wrong. We only see your "bias" in situations where there was no evidence to support the treatment in the first place. It's not a bias, it is just common sense.
- Mz 14y agoFunny you should say that. It reminds me that I want to write a piece titled "Your body is not a car". Unlike a car, a body can repair itself. If you get a minor cut, it closes on its own, without repair by a doctor. Not so with a car. Scratch the paint, the scratch is permanent -- unless you repair it. There are better means to support the body's own repair system than nuking it with toxic chemicals. Attempts to discuss that tend to get dismissed as quackery. I posit you are throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
- niyazpk 14y agoAny place where interested readers can learn more about your proposed alternatives? Your arguments here makes it feel like there is a prerequisite of knowing your (comment?) history to understand what you really mean.