9 ms·
Killed by Homeopathy
- jere 14y ago>The next time somebody tells you that homeopathy is harmless you can tell them that it killed one of the greatest mathematical minds of the nineteenth century on whose algebraic logic both the soft- and the hardware of your computer function. Interesting, but as practiced homeopathy today is harmless (ignoring opportunity cost). It's basically the equivalent of drinking tap water.
- ColinWright 14y agoYes, but there are now more accounts being unearthed of people foregoing or declining conventional treatments because they have become convinced that homeopathy will cure them. Promoting homeopathy, if successful, can result in more deaths.
- yason 14y agoThat's stepping on the jurisdiction of those people over themselves. Everyone is entitled to believe in whatever they want to and live by that. They might die but it's their death, not other people's.
- pathy 14y agoExcept if parents refuse to allow proper treatment for their children because of religious or other beliefs, such as being in favour of "natural remedies" rather than lifesaving medicines.
- danso 14y agoExcerpt that if such people live in a modern society, society bears the cost of such malpractice. And so it behooves other members of that society to at least argue against ineffective practices.
- Joeri 14y agoThat reasoning would lead you to conclude seatbelts should be optional. Fundamentally, the reasoning goes like this: (a) you have an obligation to protect friends and family from their own bad decisions, and (b) there's no fundamental difference between a friend and a stranger, hence (c) some things should be enforced by law for the good of everyone.
- yason 14y agoNow that I think about it, basically they should be optional. One reason their use could be mandatory is that in a crash the occupants might fly out of the car and kill other people if they're not using seatbelts. But I'm not sure how relevant point that would be given that the people are allowed to drive a two-tonne killing machine with very little training in the first place. However, if we do not consider bystanders, I don't see a problem making use of seatbelts optional. It doesn't hurt to mandate that all cars must be equipped with seatbelts for the benefit of availability for everyone who wants to use seatbelts—which is most people. Seatbelts do save lives but, again, it's not a criminal offense to commit suicide and fail. So, to think, actually, I find it quite disturbing that they are not optional. I hadn't thought about it before. It's an inevitable slippery slope in that you can't really draw the line anywhere as long as you feel obliged to protect everyone. Could citizens be forced to eat a certain diet to make them not die of obesity, diabetes and cardiac/circulation problems too early? It's certainly ok to inform the citizens of healthier diets, so that everyone can make their own choices with the best information available. But I argue that in the end everyone is sovereign when it comes to their own life and body.
- illuminate 14y ago"Everyone is entitled to believe in whatever they want to and live by that." No one should be entitled to sell snake oil and quackery.
- Mz 14y agoPrescription drugs kill lots of people too. No one ever cites that as reason to skip seeing a doctor. Not to dismiss your valid concern, the problem is that when doctor's kill someone, the death gets blamed on a disease or on the patient not taking the medication correctly, etc. But when an alternative treatment is used and death occurs, it is used to smear all alternative treatments. The climate is already biased against meaningful discussion of such things.
- jlgreco 14y ago> "Not to dismiss your valid concern, the problem is that when an automotive mechanic fails to fix a car, the failure gets blamed on a malfunction or on the owner not driving their car correctly, etc, But when an automotive witch-doctor blesses your car and a failure occurs, it is used to smear all automotive-blessings. The climate is already biased against meaningful discussion of automotive witchdoctors." There is no evidence that blessing your car will prevent it from breaking down. Therefore when you car does break down after a blessing, that can be nothing but evidence that blessing a car does nothing. On the other hand there is an abundance of evidence stating that automotive mechanics can diagnose and treat faulty cars, so when an automotive mechanic fails to do that it of course means any number of things could have gone wrong. We only see your "bias" in situations where there was no evidence to support the treatment in the first place. It's not a bias, it is just common sense.
- Mz 14y agoFunny you should say that. It reminds me that I want to write a piece titled "Your body is not a car". Unlike a car, a body can repair itself. If you get a minor cut, it closes on its own, without repair by a doctor. Not so with a car. Scratch the paint, the scratch is permanent -- unless you repair it. There are better means to support the body's own repair system than nuking it with toxic chemicals. Attempts to discuss that tend to get dismissed as quackery. I posit you are throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
- niyazpk 14y agoAny place where interested readers can learn more about your proposed alternatives? Your arguments here makes it feel like there is a prerequisite of knowing your (comment?) history to understand what you really mean.
- monochromatic 14y agoEschewing real medicine because of your belief that tap water will cure your illness is harmful. I guess that's what you meant by "opportunity cost" though.
- jere 14y agoYes, it is.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoIt can be a hell of an opportunity cost. For example this case: http://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/a/-/breaking/13310801/woman-sues-homeopath-over-sisters-cancer-death/ http://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/a/-/breaking/13310801/woman... http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/in_the_news/a1443763-Homeopath-being-sued-over-death-of-Australian-cancer-victim http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/in_the_news/a1443763-Homeopath-b... And this case: http://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/son-taken-away-by-mother-to-stop-cancer-treatment-found-safe-8389606.html http://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/son-taken-away-by-mother-t... and this case: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-12153074 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-12153074
- VMG 14y agoFull reference at http://whatstheharm.net/index.html http://whatstheharm.net/index.html
- rotskoff 14y agoSteve Jobs?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 14y ago> (ignoring opportunity cost) Opportunity cost when having cancer could mean dying from cancer while drinking sugar water. Yes placibo effect and all, but that's rather high cost if you ask me.
- mikeash 14y agoSaying that homeopathy is harmless if you ignore the opportunity cost is like saying that guns are harmless if you ignore all the damage the bullet does when it hits your body. Both are true statements that are also completely useless.
- asciimo 14y agoMore anecdotal evidence? I'm sorry, but I need to see clinical data before I'm willing to believe that homeopathy kills people.
- newobj 14y agoHomeopathy killed someone once. Allopathy killed someone once. I guess we're just screwed.
- halviti 14y agoTerrible article. My dad is a medical doctor. Because I spent a large amount of my life living in the same house as him does not make me a medical doctor. If I tried to treat someone who was suffering from pneumonia, and they died because of something stupid that I did, would modern medicine be responsible? You can hate on homeopathy all you want, but the conclusions being drawn here are utterly ridiculous, and anyone that finds themselves agreeing with this FUD suffers from a severe case of confirmation bias.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoAre you saying that homeopathy is effective when administered by someone who does know what they're doing? Because the alternative conclusion is that homeopathy is never effective, and the conclusion being drawn is true.
- halviti 14y agoNo, please read. There are no conclusions to be drawn here. Just because someone does something stupid does not mean anything. There is no evidence that this woman ever studied homeopathy, or that this whole wet towel thing is even a treatment used by homeopaths.
- danso 14y agoSo when does someone doing something stupid mean something?
- halviti 14y agoIt's very simple. You produce evidence or proof that two things are related. Living in the same house as a medical doctor does not make me a medical doctor, nor does it make modern medicine responsible for my actions.
- glesica 14y agoThe argument isn't that she was a homeopathic "doctor". The argument is that she was influenced by the ideas behind homeopathy, and because of that influence the "treatment" she administered made sense to her. Her logical reasoning had been clouded by her belief (essentially a religious belief) in homeopathy. This is akin to religious groups who refuse to allow medical treatment for their children, who subsequently die.
- stephencanon 14y ago"Mainstream" medicine has almost certainly killed vastly more people than will ever be killed by homeopathy. The difference, of course, is that it has also kept countless people alive (to say nothing of improving quality of life for others). Homeopathy has never kept anyone alive.
- silvestrov 14y ago"Mainstream" medicine has certainly saved vastly more people than will ever be saved by homeopathy.
- glesica 14y agoThere is also the problem of absolute versus relative numbers. Even discounting the number of people saved, mainstream medicine has possibly still killed more. But it has also been used on more people, hence the "mainstream" designation.
- wissler 14y agoHomeopathy has never kept anyone alive. I'm sure there are cases where it did, e.g. by virtue of offering something benign in place of something in the mainstream that might have killed. People are comforted by the thought that modern medicine has completely transcended the barbarity of its own past, but doctors are humans and, on average, are subject to the same kinds of irrationality as everyone else is, and if you're unlucky enough to have to get up close to modern medicine and if you pay attention, you'll see the barbarism very clearly.
- rmc 14y agoI'm sure there are cases where it did, e.g. by virtue of offering something benign in place of something in the mainstream that might have killed. When homeopathy was invented about 150 years ago, it was actually safer than real medicine, but that's because real medicine was quite dangerous, and homeopathy wasn't actually any treatment, so the "doing nothing" approach (homeopathy) was safer than the current real medicine. However real medicine has gotten a lot better.
- delinka 14y ago"...he was in all probability killed by homeopathy." And that's where I stopped. People do stupid things. Sometimes, someone dies. Happens with cars every day, and we blame the idiot (criminal charges, lawsuits, media coverage...) Happens with guns and the law blames the idiot while the media blames the guns. This blog author's in the group with the media blaming whatever fits the current agenda.
- danso 14y agoWell yes, idiocy is the cause of such deaths, but to live life just as "well, idiocy strikes again" is to live life a little more fatalistic than most of us prefer. At the very least, if we can legitimately show that homeopathy is the result of idiocy, than it becomes easier to identify the idiots who may someday harm us if we leave our healthcare in their hands.
- VMG 14y agoCan't be true. Homeopathy says that the potency increases with dilution - since the blankets were very wet, they couldn't have had any effect.
- dlytle 14y agoHomeopathy is a gigantic scam that depends solely upon the placebo effect. But this specific case is a really stupid one to use as an indictment. It's like railing against the liquor industry because someone was beaten/stabbed to death with a liquor bottle. I think it's more appropriate to say that the improper application of homeopathy killed him - so, not unlike the improper application of any number of legitimate medical techniques. The difference here is that the proper application of medical techniques might have helped, whereas the proper application of homeopathic techniques would have done nothing.
- VMG 14y agoStill, the fundamental idea of "Like cures like" is what stuck with his wife and was eventually fatal. I'd chalk this death under "unscientific thought induced by homeopathic philosophy".
- dlytle 14y agoOh, I agree - one of the root causes was the belief in homeopathic philosophy. My main point is that this case is a lousy talking point when campaigning against homeopathy. It's not like there's a lack of real, tangible evidence against homeopathy - people should use that to argue against it instead. (Not like it's likely to do any good. Homeopathic believers are pretty hard to sway.)
- Mz 14y agoI am not a fan of homeopathy, but there is probably some underlying truth to that concept. I think it is more complicated than that, but the immune system works by identifying threats and going after them. It is a little bit like what happened in WWII in the U.S. when lots of Japanese Americans were rounded up and sent to camps because they were deemed a potential threat. I have found that strengthening the body first and then re-exposing myself is a way to get healthier. That was not a plan and most re-exposures for me were unintentional. But, having worked on strengthening my body, I have found that re-exposure triggers mop up of old problems along with new. I have not used homeopathy nor read up on it. I don't really know exactly what they do. But my impression is they are skipping that first part, that their mental model is missing something and thus results are rather hit or miss.
- bitcartel 14y agoThis is serious stuff for Brits. http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevensalzberg/2012/09/10/new-british-minister-of-health-believes-in-magic-potions/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevensalzberg/2012/09/10/new-br... "Well, this is one way to save money on health care. The new British Minister of Health, Jeremy Hunt, is a firm believer in homeopathy, which treats disease using magic water solutions that contain – well, only water." http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn22241-hail-jeremy-hunt-the-new-minister-for-magic.html http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn22241-hail-jeremy-hunt... "Hail Jeremy Hunt, the new minister for magic." "The fortunes of the UK's National Health Service (NHS) are about to be transformed with the help of the magical waters of homeopathic medicine... the UK's new health minister, Jeremy Hunt – who replaced Andrew Lansley yesterday in a government reshuffle – thinks that homeopathy works, and should be provided at public expense by the NHS." "John Krebs, professor of zoology at the University of Oxford, said: "There is overwhelming evidence that homeopathic medicine is not effective. It would be a real blow for those who want medicine to be science-based if the secretary of state were to promote homeopathy because of his personal beliefs."
- pi18n 14y agoHow is it possible for these nutbars to get influential positions overseeing the very field they are nutty in? There are a bunch of US examples as well, so I'm assuming it's a global phenomenon. It doesn't make any sense, and honestly there should be a process to prevent people who believe in magic from informing policy.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- lutusp 14y ago> there should be a process to prevent people who believe in magic from informing policy. That would require the abandonment of religion. Good luck with that plan.
- riffraff 14y agoyou are assuming people get put into a position overseeing X because they are competent in X, which is, most likely, a factor with minimal influence in the complex equation that determines who does what. I mean, by definition someone who's specialization is "being a politician" can't have it as "being an expert of medicine & healthcare".
- naner 14y agoI was pretty floored when I saw homeopathy cold remedies on the same shelf as actual cold medicine at a US Walgreens. I'm sure people who aren't very careful end up purchasing the homeopathic item by accident. This bizarre experience made me wonder about the companies that formulate and produce this stuff. Do they actually go through the trouble of diluting things to ridiculous level or do they just skip the tedious part and sell inert capsules? You have to believe most people that work for these companies are con men and not actually true believers.
- lukeschlather 14y agoFrom a scientific perspective there may be a decent case for putting placebo cold medication next to the real stuff. If the real stuff has 50% efficacy but has side effects x, y, and z, there's something to be said for selling someone a 30% effective placebo with no real side effects. It makes us queasy, since you're effectively selling nothing, but at the same time nothing is not always nothing.
- polyfractal 14y agoAnd, at the end of the day, the patient is just suffering from a cold. Medicine or no, they will get better in a week. Placebo can help alleviate discomfort and pain to some degree, because that is something the mind has some sway over. So in cases of simple illness...placebo is a somewhat valid medicine. Now, when people start taking homeopathy for cancer or whatever, that's a different story. EDIT: To be clear, I think it's kinda ridiculous they are allowed to sell it too. But I suppose it isn't too different from "nutritional supplements" that have ambiguous value.
- corin_ 14y agoI don't have time to look up any decent sources right now, and it's very possible that there are far more studies that disagree with this, but I'm sure there has been at least some research showing that placebos can affect more than just the most obvious things that the mind controls, e.g. pain. Obviously any placebo relies on tricking the mind, but the mind can have a subconscious effect on how your body does anything, including fighting cancer.
- debreuil 14y agoExcept pneumonia is from bacteria - you don't get it, or get worse from it based on temperature or wetness. It is important to be sure you are actually on the side of science before laughing at those who aren't.
- sesqu 14y agoWell, body temperature has been linked to immune system performance. So wet towels can arguably worsen a pneumonia.
- GiraffeNecktie 14y agoExcept that wrapping someone in wet bedsheets has nothing whatsoever to do with homeopathy. Homeopathy might be a crock but this article is ridiculous.
- eof 14y agoI don't support tax-funded homeopathy by any stretch (and think it is almost certainly bollocks in and of itself); however, the story about the bed sheets is not homeopathy. Perhaps you could still claim homeopathy did the killing because the wife in the story 'misapplied' the "like cure like" conjecture; as wet bedsheets are not a diluted-herb-magic-water-solution. I have spent more than zero energy talking with people about spending energy being anti-homeopathy. I think homeopathy is fine, and not harmful. Every single person I know personally that believes in homeopathy also uses traditional western medicine (with far more vigour and enthusiam than myself); though I suppose if people are rejecting antibiotics and instead sprinkling magic water on themselves then it's a problem, but I would still have a hard time seeing Homeopathy itself as harmful. It's just a game. My personal relationship to true homeopathy (diluted magic water substances) is something like this: - Seems really unlikely to me anything is happening. - I could sooo easily be wrong about this, I recognize revolutions in our understanding of the universe happen frequently, and the future winners are always dismissed/laughed at while the old guard remain in power positions - The people who believe in homeopathy are also generally much, much more emotive / socially intelligent / free with love / full of what appears to be healthy energy. This leaves me extremely skeptical; but in the end open minded enough that I don't see any benefit to spending energy demonizing the ultimately non-harmful act of diluting flowers in water and thinking its magic. Anything anti-science is ultimately harmful if it is taught as science; and no one should have to subsidize other's childish fancies; but so long as we aren't teaching homeopathy in medical schools, or using tax money to subsidize its use; I really don't see anything wrong with its existing. And I do see this article to essentially be propaganda; whose only primary purpose is to demonize homeopathy, and I think this betrays some sort of chip on the shoulder of the author. Maybe I am projecting because I have seen this chip so often elsewhere; I just don't understand it. I mean, who the f really cares--and, if you really aren't humble enough to recognize that your understanding of the world is not so perfect as to absolutely eliminate the possibility of some unrecognized mechanism of 'imprinting information onto matter' through this likely quackery--then you should take a quick read of the Structure of Scientific Revolutions.
- tlrobinson 14y ago"I think homeopathy is fine, and not harmful." Extremely diluted water isn't harmful. Replacing real medicine with homeopathic treatments is.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- robbrown451 14y agoPutting a wet blanket on someone who had gotten sick from a downpour is not homeopathy. Unless the wet blanket is, statistically speaking, less than a molecule in size.
- kmavm 14y agoI enjoy a good homeopathy-bash as much as the next guy, but Boole died of an infectious disease. The rain storm he walked through, and the wet blankets he was wrapped in, had nothing to do with the bacterium that killed him. The "cold sensations cause pneumonia" folklore this article relies on is as much magical thinking as the homeopathy it invites us to smugly chortle at.
- prakster 14y agoNot afraid to say it: I have directly benefited from homeopathy. Specifically: Treated my heartburn with "Carbo Veg 30" and now it's gone. Don't care what anybody says or might think about the placebo effect - or any other argument, for that matter.
- illuminate 14y agoDo you actually understand what homeopathy is? Pills with active dry ingredients are not homeopathic, no matter what the label says. http://skeptico.blogs.com/skeptico/2005/06/if_it_has_any_i.html http://skeptico.blogs.com/skeptico/2005/06/if_it_has_any_i.h...
- prakster 14y agoNo I don't, but that was not my point.
- illuminate 14y agoIt detracts significantly from your point. If the item contains active ingredients that take care of a particular condition, it's not homeopathic (no matter what the label states.)
- drchristo 14y agoHOMEOPATHY WORKS AND IS THE MOST ADVANCED SCIENCE OF HEALING Bignamini M, Saruggia M, Sansonetti G. Homeopathic Treatment of Anal Fissures using Nitricum acidum Berlin Journal on Research in Homoeopathy, 1, 4/5, 286-287, December 1991. Patients using Nitricum acidum 9C once daily in a double blind placebo controlled trial found subjective relief with the medicine over the placebo .Kleijnen et al 'Clinical trials of homeopathy' Br Med J. 1991; 302: 316-23 Kleijnen reviewed by meta-analysis controlled trials in humans for evidence of efficacy. Of 105 trials with interpretable results there was a positive trend regardless of trial quality or the variety of Homeopathy used; 81 indicated positive results, 24 showed no positive effects. Publication bias and low methodological quality inhibit definite conclusions yet the evidence is positive. Over 50% of these reports were not published in English.
- illuminate 14y ago"Publication bias and low methodological quality inhibit definite conclusions yet the evidence is positive." The selection bias inherent to meta-analyses also leads to difficulty using any of them to "prove" the existence of homeopathy. The principles are not science. If you cherry pick studies, you might eventually find some with a positive response.