3 ms·
from a practical perspective, the federal government should have the authority to say what kinds of vehicles should be able to drive on public roads paved by us
by mindcrime 14y ago
from a practical perspective, the federal government should have the authority to say what kinds of vehicles should be able to drive on public roads paved by us tax dollars. maybe you think you should be able to drive a car with no headlights, but the other people driving on the highways at 60mph could get hurt.
A couple of thoughts:
1. This sounds more like an argument for not building highways with tax money, than an argument for more government power, to me.
2. Liability for the consequences of ones actions should be sufficient to deal with this. If I do drive without headlights for a few miles, or - as far as that goes - 10,000 miles, and nobody is injured, it's totally bogus to claim that a crime has been committed. However, if I drive, without or without headlights, and crash into someone through my own negligence, I should be held liable for that outcome. If we adopted this as a basis for governance, we wouldn't need all these lame statutory "laws" in the first place.
3. Even if headlights are required, a driver might choose to turn them off, or they could be defective or inoperable for some reason. Focusing on the requirement that they simply be present is focusing on the wrong problem even from a practical standpoint.
4. Regardless of what the Constitution, or any other document says, I personally reject the notion that the State has any particular authority at all. Even if you accept Bastiat's extremely minimalist view of "Law as no more than the collective extension to our individual right to self defense" one can still imagine pathological cases where the whole thing reduces to "might makes right". That said, I think Bastiat's view is an ideal to strive towards, as use of force should be limited to situations that could be considered self-defense. Pre-emptive use of force (or threat of force) is invalid, in my world view.
Note: I don't expect everyone (or anyone in particular) to agree with me on this, I'm just explaining why I see this as an invalid role for government.
Anyway, my point doesn't revolve around me being right or wrong in what I believe on the issue... the point is that this conversation needs to be had in the first place, and that people should quit simply glossing over this stuff and just accepting everything the State sends down the pipe as being valid. "Question authority" should be everyone's mantra in my book, even if they decide that the answer to the question is "yes" on a particular occasion.
- jellicle 14y agoYou know, Somalia - a proper Libertarian paradise - has an open immigration policy. What are you waiting for?
- teffen 14y agoPlease shut the hell up about Somalia. We get it. The joke was stale the week it came out.
- alanctgardner2 14y ago> This sounds more like an argument for not building highways with tax money Really? You want exclusively private highways? Has any government ever, in the history of mankind, not created this sort of basic infrastructure? Especially in a country as large as the US, surely many areas would be terribly underserved as their government highways are a losing proposition. > Liability for the consequences of ones actions should be sufficient to deal with this. So, rather than discouraging people from acting recklessly, we should depend on them to anticipate every possible issue? Then, if they fail to imagine why driving without headlights might be bad, we should send them to jail for life? The goal of a law like this is to codify past mistakes, as a way to remind you not to repeat them. > Even if headlights are required, a driver might choose to turn them off It isn't just illegal to not have headlights. It's also illegal to not use them at appropriate times. This is why we need 'lame statutory laws', because some asshole will always think they've found a loophole. > I personally reject the notion that the State has any particular authority at all Do you vote? Do you pay taxes? Have you ever been fined, ticketed or incarcerated? Did you, or have your children gone to a public school? Have you ever received welfare, Medicaid, Medicare, or any other social assistance? Have you driven on a public road, received a student loan, purchased any product from a government-subsidised industry? The whole libertarian view is a vast over-simplification of the role of a government. The ability to, as you say, collectively defend yourself as a population of millions is non-trivial. What are you defended against, collectively, and who decides when to exert force in self-defense? > people should quit simply glossing over this stuff and just accepting everything the State sends down the pipe as being valid I suspect you could easily consume your entire life digesting and considering every decision the government makes. We call that 'politics'. In a representative democracy, such as the one you live in, we've decided that elected officials (not some big, bad, faceless State) should do this work for us, so we can do what we're good at, which isn't making complicated decisions about trade and subsidies and taxes and such.
- mindcrime 14y agoReally? You want exclusively private highways? Has any government ever, in the history of mankind, not created this sort of basic infrastructure? Especially in a country as large as the US, surely many areas would be terribly underserved as their government highways are a losing proposition. If full private highways and the risk of some areas being underserved are an inevitable consequence of not handing responsibility for building highways to an entity that uses force and aggression to get its way, then yes, that's fine. There's a key point about the worldview I advocate, that you are probably missing. You seem to be all wrapped up in analysis of outcomes as the primary motivator for things: how will the highways get built, etc. Now, while I believe that a world built entirely on voluntary collaboration and exchange in a free market will result - on average - in better outcomes anyway, that's not the goal. The goal is, simply, freedom. In my worldview, and the worldview of quite a few others, freedom is its own end. So, rather than discouraging people from acting recklessly, we should depend on them to anticipate every possible issue? Not at all. The goal is to avoid the initiation of force to accomplish political ends, no matter how noble they may seem. If some entity (whether it calls itself "government" or something else) wants to issue a guidline saying "always use your headlights" and if 99.9999999999% of people do so, because it's common sense anyway, that's fine. Somebody (or multiple somebodies) could issue whole books full of guidelines, most of which might look a lot like the statutory regulations we have today... the difference in what I propose is that we remove the sanction of "use of force" to require adherence to those guidelines, and rely on the effect of "strict liability for the consequences of ones actions" as the motivator for following them. It isn't just illegal to not have headlights. It's also illegal to not use them at appropriate times. This is why we need 'lame statutory laws', because some asshole will always think they've found a loophole. What you just said is almost completely irrelevant to the point I was making, and - if anything - just supports it. Requiring headlights to be installed is pointless because Joe Dumbass can simply choose not to run them, whether it's "illegal" or not. And, as before, if Joe Dumbass drives 100 miles without headlights for whatever reason and no one is injured, there is no reasonable basis to say a crime has been committed. The whole libertarian view is a vast over-simplification of the role of a government. One could just as easily make the claim that "the whole statist / collectivist view is a vast over-statement of the role of a government." In a representative democracy, such as the one you live in, we've decided that elected officials (not some big, bad, faceless State) should do this work for us, No, we didn't decide. I certainly didn't decide that I want this batch of "elected official" to represent me. Let's not pretend that "voting" makes everything OK or that democracy is anything other than a euphemism for mob rule and the tyranny of the majority. I suspect you could easily consume your entire life digesting and considering every decision the government makes. We call that 'politics'. ... so we can do what we're good at, which isn't making complicated decisions about trade and subsidies and taxes and such. Delegating certain decisions is fine, although decisions about a lot of the things you're talking about probably shouldn't be made by any centralized entity at all. Market forces are sufficient... It's a marker of incredible conceit for anyone to think that we can appoint some small group of people to manage something like a national economy, and actually expect them to be able to receive, process and act on, enough information (in a timely enough fashion) to actually make good decisions. It's actually quite an absurd notion.