5 ms·
I love how these stories - and most of the discussion around them - simply choose to ignore the larger issue of "does the federal government belong in the busin
by mindcrime 14y ago
I love how these stories - and most of the discussion around them - simply choose to ignore the larger issue of "does the federal government belong in the business of telling auto makers what equipment cars must have" or even more, "does the federal government have the authority to do this"?
I would argue that the answer to both questions is unequivocally "NO" and that we should be raising absolute bloody hell with Congress over this. Despite what the SCOTUS and Congress have done to brutally butcher the 9th and 10th amendments, and despite their twisting and mangling of the "necessary and reasonable" clause and the "interstate commerce clause" it seems quite clear to me that this is an improper role of government in an open, free society.
I say let's quit nit-picking over details and privacy concerns, etc., and let Congress know - in no uncertain terms - that we simply don't accept this whole game, period.
- brianchu 14y agoThe problem is that the "mangling" occurred long ago and have been largely accepted as "settled law." This "mangling" is not a particularly new phenomenon. The 9th and 10th Amendments long ago were widely considered by the courts to be fairly limited and, in the 10th Amendment's case, redundant. There are very few cases in which the 9th and 10th Amendment have been used to strike down federal laws. In the 1940s the Supreme Court ruled that basically the amendment stated a fact which would still be true even if the amendment did not exist. And the 9th Amendment is limited because the wording of the amendment makes it clear that it only limits expansion of enumerated powers; the Commerce Clause and Necessary and Proper Clause have long ago been interpreted as granting the government powers beyond the enumerated powers (powers to which the 9th Amendment does not apply). These interpretations are unlikely to change - they have many judicial precedents.
- mindcrime 14y agoThese interpretations are unlikely to change - they have many judicial precedents. Perhaps not, I'm not trying to prognosticate here. That said, I do believe it is the nature of governments to become more abusive, corrupt and tyrannical over time, and to eventually be overthrown by one means or another. I see the US government as being quite a long ways down that path, but I don't know where the end of the path lies.
- andylei 14y ago> "does the federal government belong in the business of telling auto makers what equipment cars must have" > it seems quite clear to me that this is an improper role of government in an open, free society i'll bite. from a practical perspective, the federal government should have the authority to say what kinds of vehicles should be able to drive on public roads paved by us tax dollars. maybe you think you should be able to drive a car with no headlights, but the other people driving on the highways at 60mph could get hurt. it seems pretty clear that federal government should be in the business of telling car makers that street legal cars have to have headlights. from a theoretical perspective, the commerce clause, taken at face value, seems to give board powers to the federal government to regulate any commerce that happens across state lines. cars are certainly sold across state lines. i don't understand why you think its so clear that the federal government doesn't have this authority.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ericingram 14y agoAs I understand it, the word "regulate" had a different meaning at the time the commerce clause was written. It generally meant "to make regular", as in, prevent states from taxing imports from one state higher than another. Now it essentially means "control".
- mkr-hn 14y agoIt's convenient that your historical definition lines up perfectly with the ideology of limited government. Do you have a source for it?
- runaway 14y agoI can't find any actual citations of the word regulate used to mean "to make regular". The only references I found are in articles trying to explain the Commerce Clause. The word regulate comes from the Latin regulare "to control by rule, direct". I don't see any evidence that the meaning has changed much over time.
- 14y ago