3 ms·
>Behaviors that are baffling to outsiders are almost certainly adaptive within the context. Why do you believe this? It reminds me of people who think that jus
by javajosh 14y ago
>Behaviors that are baffling to outsiders are almost certainly adaptive within the context.
Why do you believe this? It reminds me of people who think that just because something exists, it must be useful. Some things really don't serve any purpose, like nipples on men, or belly buttons, or fingerprints.
I don't think its tribalism itself that's the problem. Heck, if the tribe is big enough we call it a nation. It seems to me that it's possible to have a "good tribe" - one that defends it's borders well, and imposes something like the rule of law within it's borders. Perhaps most importantly, inculcates a culture of non-destruction - where initiating violence is frowned upon by everyone. This tribe, I believe, could thrive and grow, and prosper.
As for the economics of the thing, I think that such a tribe could do very well. Heck, if you're right about capital flows (and you probably are) such a tribe could get (covert) American aid, etc. I imagine we'd even look the other way if they wanted to grow poppies. But still, this would be a small island, and I'm not sure if there are enough people to really man the battlements and make it work.
- chernevik 14y agoBecause it has extraordinary explanatory power in a very wide diversity of settings. It is certainly consistent with the sciences, and anthropological science in particular. BTW -- You (on average) ate through your belly button for months 2 through 9 of your existence. Just because you aren't using it _now_ doesn't mean it never served any purpose.
- daeken 14y agoFingerprints provide roughness and grip to your fingers. Without them, you'd have a difficult time doing simple things like holding a beer bottle with your finger tips.
- sp332 14y agoThey also improve sensitivity to vibration, which in turn increases the resolution of textures you can feel by brushing your fingers over them.
- cynicalkane 14y agoYou're proposing an entire tribe throw off the culture that they grew up in, social bonds that could mean the difference between life and death, and just... go all John Galt over in Afghanistan?
- w1ntermute 14y agoWell, a lot of those people are going to die before long if they don't do something to change the destructive aspects of their culture. So I'd say it's worth it (though highly infeasible).
- javajosh 14y agoWell, yes.
- xiaoma 14y ago>I don't think its tribalism itself that's the problem. Heck, if the tribe is big enough we call it a nation. And then we call tribalism, nationalism. And the results aren't pretty.