7 ms·
Federal Agency wants black boxes in every new car by September 2014
- ctingom 14y agoWhat is the potential cost of this?
- lawn 14y agoWhat is the potential profit for whoever is contracted to make the boxes?
- jrockway 14y agoJust think how rich the manufacturers of seatbelt latches are getting in this era of mandatory seatbelt laws. It's clear proof that all laws exist only to make special interest groups ultra rich so they can screw us over in some future dystopia more easily.
- omarchowdhury 14y agoHey, if you want to increase your chances of not being around for that dystopia, don't use the seatbelts.
- andylei 14y agovery little. 96% of all new cars already have the boxes.
- maeon3 14y agoInsurances agencies are going to love this one, they might even want to fund this whole idea, if they can get the black box data, they might save billions on not fixing your car as much because you drove like a primate would, breaking all traffic laws and showing signs of intoxication or extreme carelessness. If it can be shown that the party who is technically guilty of causing an accident has a perfect black box record, while the one who didn't has a terrible black box record, does it change who is at fault?
- jasonlotito 14y agoInsurance companies already offer this to clients. The understanding is that it won't raise your rate, but it can lower your rate. That being said, if someone is "breaking all traffic laws and showing signs of intoxication or extreme carelessness," I'd hope they are paying more for insurance than I do. Sort of common sense.
- beagle3 14y ago> it won't raise your rate, but it can lower your rate. A distinction without difference.
- unreal37 14y agohttp://www.progressive.com/auto/snapshot.aspx http://www.progressive.com/auto/snapshot.aspx I saw this advertised the other day...
- X-Istence 14y agoThey say they don't check for speeding, yet they have full access to your OBD-II information, which definitely does include that. They could for instance easily add when you go over 85+ Mph which is the highest allowable speed in the US... They might not be able to check on the location you are in to compare it to local speed limits, but they can definitely know if you are driving faster than the max. I'm wondering how I can get one of these devices to play around with, without handing anything over but cash.
- bitwize 14y agoEverybody drives like a primate would, because barring robocars and Toonces the Driving Cat, every driver is a primate. I think you mean lower primate?
- stcredzero 14y agoDon't forget the dogs. http://www.clarionledger.com/viewart/20121205/NEWS02/121205030/Dogs-driving-cars-Trainer-in-New-Zealand-puts-canine-companions-behind-the-wheel-Video-?odyssey=tab%7Cmostpopular%7Ctext%7CFRONTPAGE http://www.clarionledger.com/viewart/20121205/NEWS02/1212050...
- digitalengineer 14y agoNext up is a peronal rifd card for ALL forms of public transport, eg the bus, metro, train... A card that can be loaded with dollars using your credit/debit card only. Think it won't happen? It already did in the Netherlands. They're trying to add Black boxes to cars here as well. Oh, did I mention the other privacy-nightmares? How about a mandated centralized database for health-related issues? Run by the insurance companies. We have licenceplate scanning CCTV camera's at all major roads as well as all borders.
- sami36 14y agoNot that I like the surveillance state anywhere, but I'm a lot less concerned about "advances" like these in societies where democracy is already established than countries were authoritarian regimes are still in charge. EDIT : Why is my comment being down-voted ?? what part of "Not that I like the surveillance state anywhere" don't you understand. It's a FACT, the consequences of Big brother are magnitudes of order more terrifying for societies that still don't have institutions to protect them.
- astangl 14y agoToday's democratic state can be tomorrow's authoritarian regime, and "advances" like these help grease the wheels.
- freshhawk 14y agoI can see your point but these "advances" are immediately sold to authoritarian regimes by those democracies. Most of the time before they are even used in the democratic country.
- arikrak 14y agoI agree. Often the benefits of these kind of things outweigh the risks of abuse. Law-abiding citizens rarely have what to fear from normal "surveillance".
- CamperBob2 14y ago
- stcredzero 14y agoInvolved people at the site of an accident often have no compunctions about lying. If such data can be securely provided in only 5 minute increments, I'd be all for it. We should be able to do this with a sequence of keys based on timestamps. Basically, each 5 minute parcel of data would be timestamped, then a symmetric algorithm with a master key used to derive a parcel key from the timestamp. The master key would never be revealed and only the parcel key given to the authorities. Authentication could be done through PKC and/or a hash chain. (As in bitcoin.)
- X-Istence 14y agoThe data records only the last 30 seconds, and will only save said data if a crash of substantial force happens, at least in the cars that I am familiar with.
- stcredzero 14y agoA much more elegant scheme for protecting privacy.
- 16s 14y agoMy former job was systems programming on precisely this sort of project. We ran embedded ARM based Linux systems in cars, motorcycles and over the road trucks to gather research data from the vehicle CAN. The volume of data and variables collected was immense. Lateral acceleration (swerve), turn signals, seat-belts engaged, gear position, vehicle speed, individual wheel speed, engine rpm, GPS coordinates, steering wheel angel, etc, etc, etc. We were collecting petabytes of data for research. We had cameras on the vehicles as well so that we could correlate all of the collected data with what the driver was doing, where they were looking, etc. I doubt the cameras will exist in the mandated black-box systems, but who knows. I only say this because there are tons of research projects in this area right now and likely will be for many years to come.
- YokoZar 14y agoIf we had steering wheel angels we wouldn't need black boxes ;)
- beagle3 14y agoHow often did you sample most of those variables? I don't doubt the petabytes of data, but I'd be surprised if data that wasn't visual, all included, was more than a couple of terabytes (if even that .. a terabyte of textual data is a ridiculously large amount). Counting the gzipped data is the only meaningful thing here, btw - because a verbose XML document with repeating data "<absoluteLocation>17,34,25</absoluteLocation><absoluteLocation remark="notMoved">17,34,25</absoluteLocation>" is not more informative than "l=17,35,25", despite being 10 times longer. Video ... that's a completely different story.
- nja 14y agoThere's a good summary of what this means, what the implications are, and who has rights over what here: http://jalopnik.com/5966628/everything-you-need-to-know-about-the-black-boxes-coming-to-your-next-car http://jalopnik.com/5966628/everything-you-need-to-know-abou...
- unreal37 14y ago"Such devices, which are already in use in 96 percent of 2013 model year cars, record various types of data that can be accessed in multiple ways." Whoa. 96% of new cars already have black boxes? Did not know that... Wait til people get convicted of crimes based on the data in their black boxes. "OJ, your car shows it was used between 8pm and 10pm, and you were not home sleeping as you said you were..."
- jamesjporter 14y agoI don't plan on being a car owner any time in the near future, but out of pure curiosity I wonder how easy/legal it will be to remove these?
- signa11 14y agothis is waaay more scary than itu standardizing on deep-packet-inspection ;)
- mindcrime 14y agoI love how these stories - and most of the discussion around them - simply choose to ignore the larger issue of "does the federal government belong in the business of telling auto makers what equipment cars must have" or even more, "does the federal government have the authority to do this"? I would argue that the answer to both questions is unequivocally "NO" and that we should be raising absolute bloody hell with Congress over this. Despite what the SCOTUS and Congress have done to brutally butcher the 9th and 10th amendments, and despite their twisting and mangling of the "necessary and reasonable" clause and the "interstate commerce clause" it seems quite clear to me that this is an improper role of government in an open, free society. I say let's quit nit-picking over details and privacy concerns, etc., and let Congress know - in no uncertain terms - that we simply don't accept this whole game, period.
- brianchu 14y agoThe problem is that the "mangling" occurred long ago and have been largely accepted as "settled law." This "mangling" is not a particularly new phenomenon. The 9th and 10th Amendments long ago were widely considered by the courts to be fairly limited and, in the 10th Amendment's case, redundant. There are very few cases in which the 9th and 10th Amendment have been used to strike down federal laws. In the 1940s the Supreme Court ruled that basically the amendment stated a fact which would still be true even if the amendment did not exist. And the 9th Amendment is limited because the wording of the amendment makes it clear that it only limits expansion of enumerated powers; the Commerce Clause and Necessary and Proper Clause have long ago been interpreted as granting the government powers beyond the enumerated powers (powers to which the 9th Amendment does not apply). These interpretations are unlikely to change - they have many judicial precedents.
- mindcrime 14y agoThese interpretations are unlikely to change - they have many judicial precedents. Perhaps not, I'm not trying to prognosticate here. That said, I do believe it is the nature of governments to become more abusive, corrupt and tyrannical over time, and to eventually be overthrown by one means or another. I see the US government as being quite a long ways down that path, but I don't know where the end of the path lies.
- antihero 14y agoPerhaps they should be mandatory, but they should be signed by a user-owned key. In this way the data exists, but it becomes optional to share it.