4 ms·

What we need is a 1 child policy like in China.

by wesley 14y ago

pathy 14y ago
That does lead to other problems, like putting a strain on the welfare system of countries when there suddenly is a huge decrease in the number of people that support those who have retired. Look at Japan where there are fewer and fewer supporting more and more. It is kinda working for now but what will happen in 20 years? Who knows.
- kalms 14y ago
  My guess? We'll gradually shift back into larger households, with several generations living under one roof. Not that bad, when you come to think of it.
potatolicious 14y ago
http://www.brycealcock.com/random/TriviaStats/ChinaPopulation.html http://www.brycealcock.com/random/TriviaStats/ChinaPopulatio... Because it's demonstrably successful at curbing population growth rate? Because during periods of the most aggressive enforcement of the one-child policy, China had its highest growth rate in recent history, 2-2.5x that of the US? And now, during its period of least aggressive enforcement, but with a rapid pace of industrialization and wealth injection, the growth rate has fallen dramatically? http://www.indexmundi.com/g/g.aspx?v=24&c=ja&l=en http://www.indexmundi.com/g/g.aspx?v=24&c=ja&l=en Or perhaps we want to look at Japan, which without forced abortions, property confiscation, and brutal acts of repression have managed to achieve a negative growth rate? No matter which way you slice the data, the trend is clear: industrialization, wealth, and stability decrease growth rates, and do so far better than any number of guns and Bibles you can point at people.
- stcredzero 14y ago
  > Because during periods of the most aggressive enforcement of the one-child policy, China had its highest growth rate in recent history, 2-2.5x that of the US? The fact that China would think to enforce such a policy should give one pause.
citricsquid 14y ago
I don't think that policy is so great. People don't have children just because they can, we need to educate people about children and population growth. My aunt and uncle have an adopted daughter from China, she was abandoned as a result of the one child policy: the policy didn't stop her from being born, but it stopped her from having her biological family.

What we need is a 1 child policy like in China.

by wesley 14y ago

What we need is a 1 child policy like in China.

pathy 14y ago

That does lead to other problems, like putting a strain on the welfare system of countries when there suddenly is a huge decrease in the number of people that support those who have retired. Look at Japan where there are fewer and fewer supporting more and more. It is kinda working for now but what will happen in 20 years? Who knows.

kalms 14y ago
My guess? We'll gradually shift back into larger households, with several generations living under one roof. Not that bad, when you come to think of it.

potatolicious 14y ago

http://www.brycealcock.com/random/TriviaStats/ChinaPopulation.html http://www.brycealcock.com/random/TriviaStats/ChinaPopulatio... Because it's demonstrably successful at curbing population growth rate? Because during periods of the most aggressive enforcement of the one-child policy, China had its highest growth rate in recent history, 2-2.5x that of the US? And now, during its period of least aggressive enforcement, but with a rapid pace of industrialization and wealth injection, the growth rate has fallen dramatically? http://www.indexmundi.com/g/g.aspx?v=24&c=ja&l=en http://www.indexmundi.com/g/g.aspx?v=24&c=ja&l=en Or perhaps we want to look at Japan, which without forced abortions, property confiscation, and brutal acts of repression have managed to achieve a negative growth rate? No matter which way you slice the data, the trend is clear: industrialization, wealth, and stability decrease growth rates, and do so far better than any number of guns and Bibles you can point at people.

stcredzero 14y ago
> Because during periods of the most aggressive enforcement of the one-child policy, China had its highest growth rate in recent history, 2-2.5x that of the US? The fact that China would think to enforce such a policy should give one pause.

citricsquid 14y ago

I don't think that policy is so great. People don't have children just because they can, we need to educate people about children and population growth. My aunt and uncle have an adopted daughter from China, she was abandoned as a result of the one child policy: the policy didn't stop her from being born, but it stopped her from having her biological family.