3 ms·
This is a wonderful response. It illustrates exactly how philosophers want to think of themselves. However when I compare with my actual interactions with phi
by btilly 14y ago
This is a wonderful response. It illustrates exactly how philosophers want to think of themselves.
However when I compare with my actual interactions with philosophers, I am forced to believe that reality falls far short of the ideal. Whenever I have seen philosophers speculate on a topic that I knew something about, for instance math and science, I found that I could tell the difference between philosophers who learned something about the subject, and people who knew the subject who learned something about philosophy. In general the only useful comments were from the latter. (The most significant exceptions are in logic, where there is no real boundary between the logicians you find in the philosophy department, and the ones in the math department.)
If that is my reaction on subjects I know well, I have to suspect the same is true about other subjects as well.
- davesims 14y agoThis is a huge reason for philosophy's ongoing journey into irrelevance. Both scientists and philosophers have become over-specialized and tend to presume competency in one gives competency in another. They are not only different subjects, but require very different modes of thought and background knowledge that often cause the experts in each sphere to talk completely past one another. Each demands that that all arguments submit to the peculiar rigor within their own discipline, causing ground-level miscommunication and exasperation.