2 ms·
What's a book, though? I suppose people would at least count a traditional e-book. Does long-form fanfic count? How about a book-length website? What about one
by brainwad 3mo ago
What's a book, though? I suppose people would at least count a traditional e-book. Does long-form fanfic count? How about a book-length website? What about one that was originally published as a book and then republished online?
- harperlee 3mo agoI'm sure the general population being asked whether they read books have a very clear idea of what a book is.
- brainwad 3mo agoIs that understanding also cross-culturally consistent? That's a typical failure mode in comparative surveys between different countries - the meaning of the question depends on the translation used in each language. I imagine here the implied frequency might also vary between languages; maybe English speakers don't say they "read" unless they read once a week, while Spanish speakers are laxer?
- rapind 3mo agoI think it's obvious enough without getting into the weeds like this unless their sample size is unreasonably small. E-book yes obviously counts. For the rest, like fanfic? Probably, but does it matter here? Is this actually going to move the needle?
- pessimizer 3mo agoBe cool if they would research that, instead of asking rhetorical questions and assuming that none of it matters and everything is "obvious." I think it's just people being snooty. Bestsellers are trash, and by definition a plurality of readers are reading them. I don't think someone who reads Gladwell has any greater cognitive power than somebody who reads twitter.
- aeturnum 3mo agoAll your examples could be printed and read as books - whatever form they are consumed in. What differences are you seeking to highlight with these examples?
- brainwad 3mo agoPeople don't usually count reading an online piece of writing as equivalent to reading a book, even if the exact same content could also be in book form. Hence if you ask speakers of a language with a lot of available online reading material (English), you may systematically underestimate how much they read long-form content.