3 ms·
I don't mean this in a deragotary way - you obviously don't need to understand at a deeper level than you do; few people do ... Do you like to assume much? I
by btilly 14y ago
I don't mean this in a deragotary way - you obviously don't need to understand at a deeper level than you do; few people do ...
Do you like to assume much?
I have a masters in mathematics. I likely understand a lot more than you give me credit for.
I do not "discard" the limit process. I'm saying that the d/dx notation, which we get from the old infinitesmal approach, has insights buried in it that most students miss. I certainly missed it for a long time.
Limits won for good reason - they were the first consistent approach to defining the derivative that mathematicians understood, and were a key step on the way to resolving the inconsistencies in previous definitions that Fourier series had revealed.
But limits are not actually "essential". I am personally aware of multiple completely rigorous formalizations of Calculus. The second most famous of which is Robinson's non-standard analysis, which has absolutely nothing looking like a limit in sight.