3 ms·
Math is such a big field that there tends to be much re-use of symbols, and the limited number of Greek letters doesn't help (no one likes multiple-Greek-letter
by lutusp 14y ago
Math is such a big field that there tends to be much re-use of symbols, and the limited number of Greek letters doesn't help (no one likes multiple-Greek-letter variable names).
To a mathematician reading the technical literature from his own field, there's no issue with math notation. Problems sometimes come up when a specialist in one field tries to read literature from a different specialty -- but that's true in computer programming too.
This may come as a surprise, but math notation is much more uniform than computer-science notation, including all the efforts to create generic program listings. Mathematicians are reluctant to invent new symbols, but it's sometimes necessary.
When I read computer program source code, I often wish the programmer had summarized the meaning of the code using math notation. I guess that puts me in a position precisely opposite that of the author.
- ahallerberg 14y agoFor me, it's because each symbol, letter or number is given a ton of weight in mathematical equations. You can't skip over and fill in the gaps later - like reading a book, for example - you have to understand each aspect before the whole makes sense.
- btilly 14y agoTo a mathematician reading the technical literature from his own field, there's no issue with math notation. Let me guess. You haven't learned much differential geometry? Constants vary by 2 pi depending on which definition you use. Functions might come before or after their arguments. And, of course, you leave everything that is "unambiguous" out of the notation. (Proving that it truly is unambiguous is sometimes nontrivial for the novice.) Guessing what notation a particular author is using has been known to be daunting, even for other differential geometers. In grad school I remember sitting down with homework sets and spending longer working out what the question said than I did in solving it once understood. That said, if you tried to actually write everything out explicitly, it would be impossible to read anything. Compact notation is a necessary evil - without it your brain simply can't think certain things. With it, it is hard for anyone else to figure out what you just said.
- saraid216 14y agoThere's something to be said for the notion of a glossary or legend... have these been considered at all? Or a notational standards body of some kind, perhaps?
- trhtrsh 14y agoHow many standards would you like? :-) http://mathoverflow.net/questions/33152/is-there-a-reference-containing-standard-mathematical-notations http://mathoverflow.net/questions/33152/is-there-a-reference...
- saraid216 14y agoEnough that (1) someone tells me about it in 5th grade and (2) people stop complaining. I mean, seriously. The top answer is, "Wikipedia".