5 ms·
USPTO Preliminarily Invalidates Apple's 'Steve Jobs Patent' on the iPhone
- DigitalJack 14y agoIf you want to see the prosecution history and documentation of a patent, you can go to the PAIR portal of the uspto[1]. After going through a Captcha, you can then search for a patent# or application #, and then click on the "image wrapper" tab. It's very enlightening to see patents go through rejections and resubmittals, and what the explanations are for rejection or why a rejection should be reconsidered. [1] http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/pair http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/pair
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kyrra 14y agoIf you look the patent up on Google Patents, you can download all the "Public PAIR data". It's 56MB for this patent. Inside of the zip there is a file located at: 12101832-image_file_wrapper/12101832-image_file_wrapper.tsv It's a tab-delimited version of the table on the USPTO site for "image file wrapper". It also has all the PDFs in that directory. http://www.google.com/patents/US7479949 http://www.google.com/patents/US7479949
- monochromatic 14y agoVery cool! I did not realize Google Patents had this capability.
- revelation 14y agodetecting one or more finger contacts with the touch screen display, applying one or more heuristics to the one or more finger contacts to determine a command for the device, and processing the command. So literally the function of every touchscreen device ever? Touchscreens have been around since 1970; this was filed for in 2006.
- brian_cloutier 14y agoOnce again, reading snippets from a patent does nothing. You might as well read a copyrighted story and exclaim in horror "Well this is rich, he's trying to claim 'Once upon a time' for himself!" A patent does not claim every single thing that is listed. An infringing device must contain every single thing listed in the claims. Claim 7 is my favorite: "The computing device of claim 1, wherein, in one heuristic of the one or more heuristics, a contact comprising a simultaneous two-thumb twisting gesture corresponds to a 90.degree. screen rotation command."
- revelation 14y agoSorry, I know, and I invite all the downvotes I can :) Its just the pure stupidity of it all that takes ahold of me when reading this stuff.
- gjm11 14y ago> An infringing device must contain every single thing listed in the claims. An infringing device must contain every single thing listed in at least one of the claims. If you infringe on any single claim, then you infringe. Usually what happens is that claim 1 is really broad, and then there's a sort of tree of claims with claim 1 at the root and more specific claims further down the tree. The early claims may well get invalidated when an infringement case goes to court, but the patent-holder hopes that the later more specific ones will survive and still be broad enough to cover what their rivals are doing. (For the avoidance of doubt, I agree with the general point brian_cloutier is making.)
- wmf 14y agoThe meat of claim 1 is: "instructions for detecting one or more finger contacts with the touch screen display; instructions for applying one or more heuristics to the one or more finger contacts to determine a command for the device; and instructions for processing the command; wherein the one or more heuristics comprise: a vertical screen scrolling heuristic for determining that the one or more finger contacts correspond to a one-dimensional vertical screen scrolling command rather than a two-dimensional screen translation command based on an angle of initial movement of a finger contact with respect to the touch screen display; a two-dimensional screen translation heuristic for determining that the one or more finger contacts correspond to the two-dimensional screen translation command rather than the one-dimensional vertical screen scrolling command based on the angle of initial movement of the finger contact with respect to the touch screen display; and a next item heuristic for determining that the one or more finger contacts correspond to a command to transition from displaying a respective item in a set of items to displaying a next item in the set of items." (Notice the ands.) So this is claiming the ability to distinguish three different specific gestures. (Besides Graffiti, I don't remember old touch devices using gestures at all, although I'm sure there were some.)
- xntrk 14y agoMaybe the USPTO finally decided to look for prior art?
- DannyBee 14y agoNo, i believe this was due to a second re-exam request (they denied the first)
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI find this an interesting side effect of patent-a-geddon. The government looks stupid, and politicians are only human and don't like to be associated with 'stupid' so they react. The result has been a tremendous amount of "light" being shown on the patent process, the people who run the process, the goals of the process, the effects of the process, and perhaps most importantly the stuff that makes it through that process. There is a lot of stuff that could use some "light" therapy. The danger is that Congress is a blunt instrument at best and a complete disaster at worst. So one has to hope that enough tension is created such that the good people are empowered to fix things, but not so much that the bogus people can use it to do more harm than good.
- arbuge 14y agoGiven the vast sums of money that patent trolls are blood-sucking out of legitimate software and web companies these days (see another post currently also on the front page of HN), I'm personally quite looking forward to a massive swing of the pendulum in the other direction.
- josteink 14y agoMay Apple get a big one up the rear. Asshole patent-trolls keeping the software-business back.
- monochromatic 14y agoI don't think you know what "patent troll" means.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 14y agoWow, scrolling down from that article was a hilarious reminder how much more cogent HN comments tend to be than any other comments on the interwebs. "Grrr! USPTO is mean to Apple! How dare they! I'm mad!" Etc.
- duaneb 14y ago> Wow, scrolling down from that article was a hilarious reminder how much more cogent HN comments tend to be than any other comments on the interwebs. "Grrr! USPTO is mean to Apple! How dare they! I'm mad!" Etc. Really? It seems like the entire internet is anti-patents, even apple fans.
- miahi 14y agoI don't think HN or the Internet is anti-patents, but anti-stupid patents and anti-patent trolls.
- monochromatic 14y agoHN comments about patents also tend to be laughably simplistic... just at the other end of the spectrum.
- larrys 14y agoI'm wondering if nefarious advance knowledge of this office action was a cause for the drop in Apple's stock as shown here: http://finance.yahoo.com/q/bc?s=AAPL+Basic+Chart&t=1m http://finance.yahoo.com/q/bc?s=AAPL+Basic+Chart&t=1m
- linuxhansl 14y agoFinally this is (seeming) insanity is brought to the spotlight. Here's to hoping that between invalidating trivial patents like these and initiatives like Twitters "Innovator’s Patent Agreement" (which requires all inventors to agree before a patent can be used offensively), the current situation will finally come to an end.
- monochromatic 14y agoWhy is this patent trivial?
- lukifer 14y agoThe problem with Twitter's patent agreement (and others like it) is that it is not legally binding. However good their intentions now (and I believe they are genuine), sooner or later the company will come under new management, or have their assets sold for scrap, at which point all those "defensive" patents get weaponized and used for extortion.