3 ms·
Quite so. They are not proposing a blacklist of all people without degrees in their subject matter.. they are presenting general guidelines to skepticism to a
by jlgreco 14y ago
Quite so. They are not proposing a blacklist of all people without degrees in their subject matter.. they are presenting general guidelines to skepticism to a group of people (TEDx organizers) who seem to have forgotten their skeptics cap at home a few times too often.
There should be nothing controversial about telling people to be on their toes when somebody without a relevant degree tries to tell you something fantastic.
- sliverstorm 14y agoYou may not have noticed, but HN is fairly negative about college degrees, so many people probably see the bit about degrees as a personal attack on their beliefs.
- reinhardt 14y agoThis. Not just their beliefs but their lack of said degrees.
- DanBC 14y agoBut on HN people tend to show their working, rather than using an irrelevant degree as a badge of authority. There's a difference between saying "I think this is the case; here's why I think it; it needs a bit of iteration" and "I have a degree (in X); here's the truth about Y; some people disagree but they are wrong; I tried to publish this on Z but they are controlled by shills of the big industry and they squashed my free speech rights".