7 ms·
"the adventure found at a nimble 250-person startup like Dropbox becomes more tempting" What is the definition of a startup these days, anyway?
by untog 14y ago
"the adventure found at a nimble 250-person startup like Dropbox becomes more tempting"
What is the definition of a startup these days, anyway?
- debacle 14y agoAre you saying that a start-up can't have more than a certain number of employees?
- alokhar 14y agoWell, I'm sure there is a point when a startup has started up.
- untog 14y agoIt's a genuine question. To my mind, a startup has a small number of employees and not very much money. This is hardly the first time I've heard of a company with >100 employees described as a startup, so I'm interested to know what people's definitions are.
- achompas 14y agoPeople were tossing it around to describe a 400-person Twitter team in 2010 or 2011 (can't remember which).
- rm999 14y agoAs long as we are on HN, might as well as cite PG on what a startup is: http://paulgraham.com/growth.html http://paulgraham.com/growth.html >A startup is a company designed to grow fast. Being newly founded does not in itself make a company a startup. Nor is it necessary for a startup to work on technology, or take venture funding, or have some sort of "exit." The only essential thing is growth. Everything else we associate with startups follows from growth.
- debacle 14y agoBeing a start-up really has nothing to do with number of employees.
- freyr 14y agoI once interviewed with a company that maintained a staff of <25 people throughout its entire 8 year existence. It struck me as odd when they described themselves as a startup. According to Paul Graham, "a startup is a company designed to grow fast." By this definition, they didn't fit the bill. Dropbox might, depending on whether or not they're still in a rapid growth phase.
- shard 14y agoIt seems like you're taking the term "fast" to refer to the number of employees. I think it refers more to revenue, or maybe user acquisition for those "we'll figure out how to make money later" companies.
- nostrademons 14y agoWell, it can get confusing when "a company designed to grow fast" doesn't, and yet still has enough revenue coming in to not die. I worked at a company that considered themselves a startup when I first interned there in 2004 (they'd been founded around 2002 and had just gotten their first 7-figure contract). When I left in 2007, it was apparent they were really a small business, they started calling themselves a small business around 2009, and they finally went out of business in 2011. I think headcount topped out at around a dozen in 2006 - it'd been around 7 at my first internship, and I think it was down to just founders when they went under.
- protomyth 14y agoAt 250 people, you would think you're a business and no longer a startup. Once you pass Dunbar's number you probably are no longer a startup.
- theorique 14y agoThat's a reasonable upper bound. Once the company is big enough to the point where you don't remember everyone's name, it's past the startup point.
- m0th87 14y agoDunbar's number makes little sense for directly determining/classifying organizational sizes. Most of peoples' relationships lie outside of the organization they work for. You'd probably have little to no relationship with people in your organization way before you reach Dunbar's number.
- saraid216 14y agoThe advantage of calling out Dunbar's number is that it explains why there's an upper bound of some kind. But yes. 150 is far too high a number. I'd say it should be closer to 50. It makes me sad to link to this, since the PARC blog no longer hosts his images, but it's more than nothing: http://www.lifewithalacrity.com/2005/10/dunbar_group_co.html http://www.lifewithalacrity.com/2005/10/dunbar_group_co.html
- tripzilch 14y agoI see your point, but there's more numbers when it comes to companies, there's a break at 7 or 8, and another one somewhere around 20. I might have fudged the numbers a littlebit, but they're both breaking points when a company needs to change its organisational structure: Starting with a flat, informal startup, at 7 or 8 is where people may feel their voice is not informally heard at (for instance) meetings, that needs to be addressed by a (slightly) more formal type of meeting. Somewhere around 20 there's a second break which is when you need to start thinking about an extra level of management (just one at first, of course). There's probably a few more that I don't know of and I would not be at all surprised if Dunbar's number is one of them.
- bickfordb 14y agoA company in a hyper growth mode?
- spaghetti 14y agoPerhaps companies that have existed for less than n years?
- wensing 14y agoI would argue that Dropbox isn't a startup anymore. Once you've found a business model and start scaling your personnel (i.e. Steve Blank's "Company Building" stage), a startup is no longer a startup, IMO.
- raverbashing 14y agoExactly that Besides, Dropbox has already received some substantial investments, and have a healthy revenue
- AYBABTME 14y agoAnd soon enough offices abroad.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ErikAugust 14y agoNimble 250. I worked at places with 25 people that weren't close to anything I'd consider "nimble".
- mshafrir 14y agoNot completely proven & scaled business model?
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI suspect a "startup" is any company that is serving a market that has yet to prove it is viable. Many folks use that term to describe any privately held company that is growing into something much larger.
- shawn-butler 14y agoAlso for me, a startup has a disruptive nature or mission for an existing market that seperates it from the normal competitive pressure created by new small businesses, franchises, etc. I never understood who or what Dropbox was ever disrupting to earn such high valuations but that's ok. Sometimes just have to admit when you can't see the forest for the trees.
- nostrademons 14y agoOr a market that is known to be viable with a product that is not yet known to be viable. I think most people would consider Tesla a startup, but cars have been around for a century.
- pretoriusB 14y agoYes, but in their case it's "electric cars" which is a different market.
- noiv 14y agoThis market also exists for a century.
- pretoriusB 14y agoYou confuse "exists" with "matters to more than a thousand people".
- skeletonjelly 14y agoIt's funny that that term is abused, similar to how this site hates the abuse of the word "hacker" by the media.
- lancashire 14y agoI've always liked Steve Blank's definition: "A startup is a temporary organization designed to search for a repeatable and scalable business model." I would say Dropbox has found a repeatable and scalable business model.
- Angostura 14y agoVery nice
- michaelochurch 14y agoBillion/million rule is the cutoff for "real startup". It stops being a startup when, if acquired or IPO'd for $1 billion, a full-time entry-level engineer makes less than $1 million after taxes. For straight equity, that puts the cutoff around 0.2%. For options, it depends on the strike. By 250, new employees are getting much less than that.
- pz 14y agothis is a poor definition for what a startup is
- soofaloofa 14y agoIf you can hire Guido you are not a startup.
- ramayac 14y agoB.G. (Before Guido) it's a startup, A.G. (After Guido) it's not a startup anymore.
- Goopplesoft 14y agoCan that be the mark of a programmer too? /j
- dgreensp 14y agoPG's well-known definition is "a company designed for growth". http://www.paulgraham.com/growth.html http://www.paulgraham.com/growth.html
- herval 14y agoMeaning Apple is a startup?
- Sam_Odio 14y agoNo. A growing company is not necessarily a company designed for growth. Startups are rarely profitable since a company designed for growth reinvests its revenue back into the company to create future growth (think a "ramen profitable" startup vs a "lifestyle business"). Large profits mean the company has run out of investment opportunities.
- pretoriusB 14y agoSo a startup is mostly a pyramid scam on investor/IPO money, not interested in a specific end product (since they pivot) or building a profitable company (judging by what you say). I'd rather have a lifestyle business, which at least until the nineties we used to call just company/business. You know, like Apple, IBM, Oracle, Microsoft, Adobe et all, despite not being startups are _just_ businesses.
- herval 14y agoSo in other words, your actual definition of startup is "a company that doesn't make any profit"? Apple is designed for growth since their inception (when they were still a startup, by anyone's definition of startup) and that haven't changed much ever since (except, perhaps, on the Scully phase... and probably now, under Cook): they kept iterating fast on new products, predating their own margins with internal competition and all those other small things companies designed for growth do...
- dpitkin 14y agoTechnically I believe any company that is less than 2 years old is a startup, they have a limited operating history. VC funded startups that are supposed to grow hyper fast but lots of statistics we see also count every new small business.
- famousactress 14y agoOn my more cynical days my observed definition from context clues would be: "A company that isn't profitable, but isn't as unhappy about it as I would be yet." [edit: Worth clarifying that I doubt Dropbox probably ever qualified under my definition... but that's fine. Who wants to be a startup? I'd rather start a company.]
- foxylad 14y agoMaybe I'm a lot more cynical than I thought, but I think this is the best definition of a startup in this thread. I'm continually amazed by stories on HN where people invest significant portions of their lives and/or wealth with no idea of how they can generate revenue. Now I AM going to get cynical by saying it's in the VCs' interest for this to happen, because they can swoop in and grab the few that do turn out to be profitable. The HN dream is a bit like Hollywood - most of the hopefuls who chase the HN dream are going to end up eating ramen through three or four pivots, before they realise quite how bad the odds are against them. Sorry for such a black thought at the start of the week!