5 ms·

Littered with AI writing tells.

lgas 3mo ago
This doesn't need to be posted on every post. Everyone that cares is well aware. It's like saying "this was written in english" on every post.
- hack1312 3mo ago
  Why should I bother reading something that the “author” couldn’t even be bothered to write themselves?
  - lgas 3mo ago
    I'm not saying you should, I'm saying you shouldn't clutter up every thread with this type of useless comment. It just detracts from the people that do want to engage with it.
  - pseudony 3mo ago
    Similarly, why should I be bothered reading this kind of comment in each and every discussion thread? What does it contribute? I can read and discern this for myself, I can then stop reading or decide I don’t care. Seriously, at some point all you “ai writing sleuths” should just get your own discussion thread together. It’s been months of this , we get it already. (Not directly just at you, but anyone who feels the need to drop these comments in every thread)
    - tgv 3mo ago
      > why should I be bothered reading this kind of comment in each and every discussion thread? To help other people who don't care about it so they can skip it. A subject tag would be nicer. > It’s been months of this , we get it already. And I am tired of the constant barrage of AI proselytizing.
  - josefrichter 3mo ago
    he's sharing an idea, not "text". text is just a medium.
josefrichter 3mo ago
is that wrong though? you write all your code with AI already, but you still need to supervise and steer it. same with blog posts - as long as you steer it towards converying your point, it doesn't matter the text itself was written by AI rather than typed by you, does it?
- derdi 3mo ago
  It doesn't matter if a human or a machine wrote it, it's just unpleasant to read. I don't know what the OP's motivation for their post was, but I think it's reasonable to point out that something is harder to read than it should be.
rcarmo 3mo ago
Actually, not really. The vocabulary is sophisticated, but there isn’t a single “the honest value” or A bunch of itemized bold fluff.
TacticalCoder 3mo ago
> No framework. No state machine. The agent’s state is just ... Indeed. The new language, llmish, has definitely been used. Still a good TFA IMO. P.S: this particular construct "No X. No Y. ... just ..." is half my LinkedIn feed.
deterministic 3mo ago
Who cares? I most certainly doesn't. As long as the article is well written.

lgas 3mo ago

This doesn't need to be posted on every post. Everyone that cares is well aware. It's like saying "this was written in english" on every post.

hack1312 3mo ago
Why should I bother reading something that the “author” couldn’t even be bothered to write themselves?
- lgas 3mo ago
  I'm not saying you should, I'm saying you shouldn't clutter up every thread with this type of useless comment. It just detracts from the people that do want to engage with it.
- pseudony 3mo ago
  Similarly, why should I be bothered reading this kind of comment in each and every discussion thread? What does it contribute? I can read and discern this for myself, I can then stop reading or decide I don’t care. Seriously, at some point all you “ai writing sleuths” should just get your own discussion thread together. It’s been months of this , we get it already. (Not directly just at you, but anyone who feels the need to drop these comments in every thread)
  - tgv 3mo ago
    > why should I be bothered reading this kind of comment in each and every discussion thread? To help other people who don't care about it so they can skip it. A subject tag would be nicer. > It’s been months of this , we get it already. And I am tired of the constant barrage of AI proselytizing.
- josefrichter 3mo ago
  he's sharing an idea, not "text". text is just a medium.

josefrichter 3mo ago

is that wrong though? you write all your code with AI already, but you still need to supervise and steer it. same with blog posts - as long as you steer it towards converying your point, it doesn't matter the text itself was written by AI rather than typed by you, does it?

derdi 3mo ago
It doesn't matter if a human or a machine wrote it, it's just unpleasant to read. I don't know what the OP's motivation for their post was, but I think it's reasonable to point out that something is harder to read than it should be.

rcarmo 3mo ago

Actually, not really. The vocabulary is sophisticated, but there isn’t a single “the honest value” or A bunch of itemized bold fluff.

TacticalCoder 3mo ago

> No framework. No state machine. The agent’s state is just ... Indeed. The new language, llmish, has definitely been used. Still a good TFA IMO. P.S: this particular construct "No X. No Y. ... just ..." is half my LinkedIn feed.

deterministic 3mo ago

Who cares? I most certainly doesn't. As long as the article is well written.