15 ms·
Larry Page "providing free flu shots to all San Francisco bay area kids"
- iterationx 14y ago"if we do a really great job on new vaccines... we could lower [world population] by 10 or 15 percent" - Bill Gates
- DanBC 14y ago"First we've got population. Now, the world today has 6.8 billion people. That's headed up to about nine billion. Now, if we do a really great on new vaccines, health care, reproductive health services, we could lower that by, perhaps, 10 or 15 percent, but there we see an increase of about 1.3."
- illuminate 14y ago"..." You don't say! (He certainly didn't.)
- ck2 14y agoLet's see, maybe 900k kids, even if it was discounted in bulk to $10, that's $9 million. If half the kids take advantage of it and it's really $20 in bulk, same $9 million.
- GICodeWarrior 14y agocdc.gov has price lists for the vaccine. Apparently individual doses are around $1 each. You still need someone to administer it, but Target may be providing that. http://198.246.98.21/vaccines/programs/vfc/awardees/vaccine-management/price-list/index.html http://198.246.98.21/vaccines/programs/vfc/awardees/vaccine-... (cdc.gov isn't resolving at the moment)
- danielweber 14y agoYes, the challenge is not the physical products. It's the labor of getting it to people and administering it. (I still haven't gotten my free flu shot at CVS because there is always a long line there.)
- parsnips 14y agoFree healthcare, long lines? Say it ain't so.
- danielweber 14y agoIt's not "free because it's CVS." If I had no insurance, CVS would still charge me, because they have legitimate labor costs that need to be covered. I was just making a personal statement. Because it is free for me, there's no financial reason for me to avoid it. But waiting in a line is a hassle, and I have no reason to believe that everyone in line is there for a flu shot. Good on Page for offering it in multiple places like Target stores. I hope they stick around for a while so people can choose to go when the lines are short.
- lostlogin 14y agoAs a counter to that view, my daughter needed an eye operation 3 weeks ago, squint correction, 2 muscles on each eye. Saw the specialist, operation 8 days later. If I'd had a choice of date it would have been further away. New Zealand, tax payer funded (so not free as such), socialised cost. Successful operation. Edit: auto correct issues
- zoowar 14y agoWhile this is admirable, public health should be funded by the public through taxes and not the whims of the 1%.
- cleverjake 14y agoI dont think anyone is suggesting it should be paid through the 'whims of the 1%'
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ck2 14y agoThe problem is entire generations of people voting against themselves are going to have to die off before that happens in this country. Meanwhile at least hundreds of thousands of kids in SF bay area have a chance not to get the flu this year and spread it everywhere thanks to one man's generosity and thoughtfulness.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- cglace 14y agoHow do you figure the people are voting against themselves? Do you know what their preferences are or what they value?
- beagle3 14y agoMy parents used to think the same thing. But somehow, newer generations keep voting against their own interests. The realization that many people are not actually smart enough to figure their own interests came to me about 10 years ago, and the world made a lot more sense since then. (the late George Carlin reasoned thus: "Think how dumb the average person is; and now realize that half the population is even dumber than that". It's true, if you assume "dumbness" distribution is symmetric around the mean. Or, just replace "average" with median and it's true by definition.)
- dfxm12 14y agoOne can provide free flu shots, or one can pay for flu shots. Obviously, Larry did one or the other. Otherwise, it would be quite a publicity stunt to claim to be paying for something that was free. :)
- ck2 14y agoPoint taken, slight title edit. Will probably be changed by mod or automated reversion anyway.
- fuzzieozzie 14y agoIf this an experiment? Is it the 1% being magnanimous? Is this that he doesn't want his employees to get the flu? Nevertheless a nice gesture - though there may be more effective ways to spend the $$$ on the public good.
- stuaxo 14y agoThis is nice... though with a universal health system it doesn't need to be limited to one city.
- ck2 14y agoI suspect all Google employees already have good enough health care to get a free flu shot for their family without this, he's making sure all others do too? The flu makes society horribly unproductive (and cranky) so it's a public good.
- CodeCube 14y agoIt would be nice if he's just being magnanimous, but I actually hope it's an experiment ... will there be a notable difference in flu rates in the area as a result of this? will there be any other statistical blips that can be correlated to fewer infections? I'm hoping they're tracking the heck out of this effort :P
- ck2 14y agoI vaguely remember Google had a flu tracker last year. Ah here it is http://www.google.org/flutrends/ http://www.google.org/flutrends/ You are right, it will be interesting to see if this makes a difference statistically. Unfortunately their tracker doesn't go down to metro areas, only state. Oh wait, there are a few cities, here is SF http://www.google.org/flutrends/us/#1014221 http://www.google.org/flutrends/us/#1014221
- danielweber 14y agoIt probably won't even show up. There have been some unintentional experiments with the flu vaccine, such as the year production got botched or that the people in charge of predicting which strains to include guessed wrong. There were no noticeable increases in sickness or morbidity in those years. Don't take this too far; the data is very noisy and maybe it was there and we just didn't see it. Flu vaccines do seem to work in labs and in small community experiments.
- Apocryphon 14y agoUnfortunately, all I can think about is how the conspiracy theorists will respond. "Billionaire providing free VACCINES? Google?!? SAN FRANCISCO?!?!"
- armenarmen 14y agoSame exact thought haha
- tcgv 14y agoIf I recall correctly this has already been covered in an episode of The Simpsons. Free vacines are just a means for the government (now Google) to control our minds, Ned Flanders had it all figured out!
- dEnigma 14y ago"Simpsons did it!" -General Disarray
- livestyle 14y agoIf you think flu shots are good then this is good but if you know the truth about flu shots it's quite scary.
- bruceboughton 14y agoThat they make you addicted to AdWords?
- cloudwalking 14y agoIf you think vaccines are bad you need to get a better education.
- maratd 14y agoActually, you should educate yourself. The overwhelming majority of vaccines are solid and probably one of the most important discoveries mankind has ever made. The flu "vaccine" however, is at best 50% effective and is frequently 0% effective. Notice how you have to vaccinate every year for it? But not for anything else? Yeah, it's because it's constantly mutating and it's a moving target. We still haven't figured out how to nail that target. What's worse, you need to go to a doctor to get vaccinated ... guess where the majority of infections occur? The place where many people congregate. Especially sick people. I'm all for vaccinations, but not if they have to be done on an annual basis and are best-case-scenario 50% effective.
- bruceboughton 14y agoYou have to go to the Internet to download anti-virus. Guess where the majority of infections occur? The place where PCs congregate. Especially sick PCs. Anti-virus is bad.
- maratd 14y agoMy OS comes with anti-virus built-in. Don't download useless shit from the Internet.
- dhlabs 14y agotime for tim cook to step up
- drzaiusapelord 14y agoFree $9 lattes to everyone with a Macbook Pro and in the $250,000 or more tax bracket! No, just kidding, they'll horde it for lawsuits.
- calebhc 14y agoI was getting my hopes up... :p
- bcx 14y agoI think this makes a ton of business sense. 1) Children are near the top disease spreaders 2) Less sick children means less sick employees 3) Less sick children means less employees spending time with their sick kids 4) Everyone wins!
- creativityland 14y agoand add employees required to give their children flu shots.
- zem 14y agohe's doing it personally. out of his own money. out of a desire to do his bit not to have flu spread around. why would you even be speculating on whether this makes "business sense"?
- derleth 14y ago> why would you even be speculating on whether this makes "business sense"? Why not? Also, it might make it more likely to happen next year if it makes good business sense this year.
- tuukkah 14y ago3) Less sick children means less employees spending time with their sick kids 4) Everyone wins! Everyone except those kids who care less about having a flu sometimes than having a chance of their working parents spending time with them. =/
- bti 14y agoLarry Page is destroying families.
- elteto 14y agoThat is one of the most idiotic things I have ever read. I hope you are being sarcastic.
- prostoalex 14y ago
- aarondf 14y agoI'm kind of amazed that a story like this can _still_ elicit negative responses here. Maybe the gov't should provide this, maybe not. Either way: it doesn't right now, but Larry Page just did. I think that is pretty cool. Bravo.
- mikeash 14y agoIt's pretty crazy. This is a mildly interesting story about an act of charity by a person who got wealthy in tech, that's it.
- vectorbunny 14y agoI applaud the practical impact of this act, however I do not view it as charity. Acts of charity are anonymous. Charitable donations made in a highly public manner are publicity.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- darrenkopp 14y agoNo, charity is not defined by whether the donor is anonymous or not.
- pkulak 14y agoWhat a terrible world it would be if society rewarded giving so much that wealthy people and corporations climbed over each other to give as much as possible, just for the publicity. There'd be no more charity!
- mikeash 14y ago"Acts of charity are anonymous." That's not how other people use the word. You should pick a different word if you're going to have your own private definition.
- vectorbunny 14y ago
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bensw 14y agoI'm glad Larry has finally answered definitively how to end parentheticals with smilies.
- gsibble 14y agoFree for children? Shame that Apple's factory workers don't live in San Francisco. ZING!
- mvleming 14y agoI think this is a nice gesture by a public figure. I don't think this is something to take seriously as an approach to a long-term goal, but instead as something to be inspired by. Thanks Larry Page. :)
- nsxwolf 14y agoNote to self: If I ever become rich and decide to donate something to a bunch of kids... don't let HN find out...
- jarcoal 14y agoI feel like the Slashdot and /r/technology crowd have infected this place. So much negativity it's shocking.
- unalone 14y agoNegativity's to be expected when any controversial issue's brought up, and this is certainly a controversial issue on a number of fronts. The people-spending-lots-of-money front, the how-should-we-make-people-less-sick front, the are-corporations-taking-over-our-lives front... all sorts of things that're bound to raise hackles. The nature of all three sites you brought up, this one and Reddit and Slashdot, make the problem a bit worse by throwing voting and ranking into the mix. When people feel their opinion is being publicly valued, they become more defensive about their opinions and thoughts. The tyranny of the majority means that any thread will display the most popular opinion first, and therefore there's a valuation occurring in every conversation here that can be bothersome when you're in the minority. That's not entirely the cause – sites with threaded discussions also have frequent arguments over controversy. But there are methods of encouraging positivity in online discussions, they're just not ones built into HN, and the system that is built-in favors more contentious back-and-forths.
- derleth 14y ago> the how-should-we-make-people-less-sick front This isn't controversial on that front unless you're a scammer or a moron. Seriously. We need to stop pretending like the anti-vaxxers actually have an argument. We're not CNN. We can financially afford to state the facts of the matter without injecting false balance.
- unalone 14y ago
- thechangster 14y agoLarry Page, major germaphobe, disinfects entire Bay Area.
- dude3 14y agoProps and this is a great thing. But it shouldn't erase all the morally bad things Google is actively doing. It's like a Dictator giving candy to the kids for the cameras while still actively oppressing people behind the scenes. There does happen to be a huge FTC case (that will be probably dropped) and a possible DOJ case against Google right now.
- knowaveragejoe 14y agoLadies and gentlemen, start your conspiracy engines.
- kyllo 14y agoAre the kids required to present proof of Google+ activity first?
- joey_muller 14y agoHaha. Exactly what I was thinking. I am sure there's a "Vaccinated by Larry Group on Google+" group coming soon.
- stevewilhelm 14y agoGlad to see him following the Gates' lead.
- hermannj314 14y agoBuy a kid a $10 flu shot, vaccinate him for a year. Teach a kid to buy his own $10 flu shot, vaccinate him for a lifetime.
- tomkarlo 14y agoYay, child labor.
- tokenadult 14y agoThe previous submission of Larry Page's Google+ post http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4874293 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4874293 led me to his post, where I commented, and where I was APPALLED to see how many people were making blatantly unscientific statements about vaccines, with one even saying, "Just google it" (without providing any links) to introduce flat-wrong statements. A follow-up comment of mine was, "+Larry Page I'm wondering if your head hurts as much as mine does when people say 'Just Google it' to recommend websites full of incorrect information not based on science or rational thought. More work still needs to be done in developing the public's research skills so that most people can distinguish reliable sources from unreliable sources that happen to turn up in an online search. " Ouch. I guess the co-founder of Google is seeing an example in the comments to his Google+ post of how ignorant people stay ignorant even when they use the world's best search engine. I wonder what the search quality team at Google can do about issues like this.
- yuhong 14y agoSometimes it is as simple as confusing different kinds, such as H1N1 vs normal flu vaccines.
- mcmatterson 14y agoThe nobility / motivation for this act aside, I can't believe this is still even a thing. Honestly, I find it incredible that there's even debate about this. Nobody thinks twice about things like transportation infrastructure or monetary policy being publicly administered, but the second health care is involved, all sense seems to go out the window. How someone can think that health is less of an inalienable right than access to roads or free markets is beyond me.
- baddox 14y ago> Nobody thinks twice about things like transportation infrastructure or monetary policy being publicly administered You're right. I only think once about it, and I think it's a bad idea.
- hermannj314 14y agoImagine if everyone were required to sign up for a food/water plan to make sure they and their children would be covered for all of their food related needs. Employers would be required to pay a percentage of food plans premiums for all full-time employees. And if you don't buy a food plan you will be fined $700 annually by the Federal government. The benefit is that you could never be denied basic access to food/water for the rest of your life. Of course, the government would decide what sort of food each food plan offers and how much grocers can charge for food. I mean, food is just as much an inalienable right as health, right? So all sense would go out the window if you don't agree with this?
- mahyarm 14y agoThe main difference in this case, you can get other people sick with your contagious illness.
- hermannj314 14y agoI'm not against vaccinations, I agree. A vaccinated public is something everyone benefits from. I was responding to healthcare in general, sorry for the confusion.
- nicholassmith 14y agoWell done to Larry Page, doesn't matter if its a PR (which I doubt) situation, he's directly improving the quality of life for a large group. Kudos to him. Flu seems trivial but often ends up distinctly not in kids.
- k-mcgrady 14y agoThe amount of negativity and even in anger in the HN comments here is amazing. A successful entrepreneur uses some of his money to provide children with vaccines - how can people respond badly to that?
- afterburner 14y agoFlu shots aren't free in the US? I suppose I should have guessed.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kyro 14y agoThis is ridiculous. Why doesn't he spend more of his time and money building Google's customer service? Has everyone suddenly forgotten the Google Apps story from yesterday? They presumably stopped giving out free accounts to maximize profits, and yet this imbecile is going around burning his cash on preventing the spread of influenza and other diseases. Your self-driving vehicles are the future, Larry. Why would you invest in helping more people survive when we'll actually end up leading less of them because of all the driver/cab jobs you'll be eliminating?
- photorized 14y agoAs someone said here, best charity is anonymous. Meanwhile, Brin is in the news for scooping up properties and renting them out "to the needy". I remember the press Page and Brin were getting 5 or 6 years ago for helping out a filmmaker... to the tune of 200 or 250k. Many people I know do more, and more often, without any kind of public praise. This kind of publicity should really cost more. And if you truly care about helping people, make an anonymous donation, instead of milking it for all its worth.
- bfac112 14y agoFlu shots don't cost anything. Hey Larry, try not being a cheapskate next time.
- microkernel 14y agoInteresting Meta-Analysis of the Cochrane Collaboration: http://summaries.cochrane.org/CD004879/vaccines-for-preventing-influenza-in-healthy-children http://summaries.cochrane.org/CD004879/vaccines-for-preventi...