4 ms·
"This memo starts out with a highly dubious argument about the meaning of the copyright clause." What's dubious about it? Isn't that the standard constitutiona
by Alex3917 14y ago
"This memo starts out with a highly dubious argument about the meaning of the copyright clause."
What's dubious about it? Isn't that the standard constitutional interpretation? I've always heard that it's supposed to work like a balance with incentives for creators on one side and public domain access on the other side, with the goal being to maximize invention and innovation.
- tptacek 14y agoLook through 'tzs comments for the one about the meaning of the word "science" at the time the constitution was ratified, and the clear intents of the framers. I believe Khanna's opening point about the purpose of copyright is actually incorrect.
- Alex3917 14y agoThe thing that tzs was responding to is different than the khanna memo, which is here: http://www.theamericanconservative.com/an-anti-ip-turn-for-the-gop/ http://www.theamericanconservative.com/an-anti-ip-turn-for-t... tzs is probably correct, but he was actually responding to this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4862752 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4862752 (His comment is here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4862752 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4862752) So long story short, even if tzs is correct I don't think that means that khanna is wrong, as his interpretation of the constitution doesn't depending on the 'sciences' part in any way. In fact, the way he is using 'sciences' seems to be consistent with the way tzs defines it.
- tptacek 14y agoThe point 'tzs was making is that the purpose the framers had in ratifying the copyright clause was essentially the same purpose to which it is applied today. Khanna's point is that it has been warped towards a purpose other than the framers had in mind, which again does not in fact appear to be correct.
- Alex3917 14y ago"Khanna's point is that it has been warped towards a purpose other than the framers had in mind, which again does not in fact appear to be correct." I guess I still don't see how you're getting that. Khanna's criticism of the current copyright law is that it is being used to enrich creators rather than to maximize innovation. TZS's comment is about what can be copyrighted or patented, which Khanna never takes issue with. What specifically do you think he is wrong about with regards to his interpretation of the constitution?
- tptacek 14y agoYou might be right, I'll think of a more carefully reasoned response to this later today.
- lisper 14y ago> I believe Khanna's opening point about the purpose of copyright is actually incorrect. Yes, you said that already. What you haven't said is why you believe this, except to cite an obscure (and not at all on point) comment on HN. I've done a little bit of searching, and it is easy to find extensive well-reasoned arguments that Khanna is spot on. e.g.: http://open-spaces.com/article-v2n1-loren.php http://open-spaces.com/article-v2n1-loren.php I can't find a single coherent defense of the opposing position.
- tptacek 14y agoThis is a good essay, thanks for digging it up. I'm not sure it convinces me that Khanna isn't off base in the introduction to his memo, but that introduction isn't really the core of my argument and I wouldn't want to get derailed.
- lisper 14y agoSo what is the core of your argument? That the memo was not politically wise? That is manifestly true. But it says nothing about whether or not it was right on the merits, or even whether or not it was "shockingly sensible." As far as I can tell, it was all three of those things. If you don't agree, I'd really like to know why.
- tptacek 14y agoObviously repeating myself: that the reforms the memo advocated for managed simultaneously to be unrealistic and not particularly meaningful.
- joshred 14y agoIf they're not meaningful, wouldn't they be more realistic?
- tptacek 14y agoNo! (Well, besides ratcheting terms back). That's the thing I'm trying to point out. If, like me and I think a lot of people, you think that the 2 big problems with our current copyright regime are (1) ordinary people are under constant threat of being bankrupted by studios for availing themselves of the most convenient access to a TV show or movie, and (2) that it's dangerous to start a consumer Internet company that deals in media, then these reforms meaningfully solve none of those problems. But at the same time they manage to be inflammatory to the content industry: exemptions for remixing rights-encumbered songs, punitive measures for mistaken takedowns, and slightly but not meaningfully increased costs of litigating infringement.
- tzs 14y agoHere's a study prepared for Congress in the late '50s when they were considering a revision of copyright law that provides a good look at the historical development of our understanding of the scope of the copyright power in the US: http://www.copyright.gov/history/studies/study3.pdf http://www.copyright.gov/history/studies/study3.pdf