7 ms·
Steve Ballmer fired Sinofsky, clearing the way for faster progress in mobile
- taskstrike 14y agoSinofsky was a great tech leader and shipper of products. The people who replaced him seems weak sauce. I'm not sure if firing someone creates faster progress in an area vs. just shipping more products.
- watmough 14y agoYes, this is a strange article. The reality is that MS were way behind the tablet curve, having plugged the same old tiny buttons, traditional Windows, use a stylus, furrow for years and years. Bolting Metro onto Windows 7 is likely to please very few, least of all corporate customers. If Sinofsky is as bad as painted, could he really have turned around the Longhorn mess, salvaged Vista, then reshaped the organization to do a fantastic job with Windows 7?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- twoodfin 14y agoMy wild speculation: Steve Ballmer is a sales guy at heart, and it's why he's been able to survive a decade of middling stock performance and strategic missteps: He must have close connections to Microsoft's largest enterprise customers, and were he to be fired, it would be an invitation for those customers to reevaluate their commitment to Microsoft's platforms. When he walks into a big customer's boardroom, he must be furious every time he sees some C-level using an iOS or Android device. He knows that if he can't sell "Windows everywhere" to these users, he's doomed to keep reading headlines about 5,000-user iPad-based IT projects and the "post-PC era". He didn't need to wait to see how the market would respond to Windows 8 and devices like the Surface. These users could tell him immediately, perhaps even before the product launched, and I would guess that their feedback was discouraging. If at the same time their IT departments were making noise about sticking with XP or 7, that would have been the last nail in Sinofsky's coffin.
- brudgers 14y ago"He must have close connections to Microsoft's largest enterprise customers" Ballmer has a close connection with Microsoft's largest shareholder, some fellow named "Gates." He has even closer ties to the second largest shareholder, himself.
- Stratoscope 14y ago> Steve Ballmer is a sales guy at heart Indeed! I still enjoy his classic Windows 1.0 sales video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tGvHNNOLnCk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tGvHNNOLnCk It's a total self-parody, and you can tell he had a ball doing it.
- brudgers 14y ago"Clearly Ballmer will assume a more direct role in Windows management, with Windows VPs Julie Larson-Green and Tami Reller now reporting directly to him." The sexism upon which this statement is partially premised aside... I have an entirely different take on this promotion. Microsoft has been run by a pair of consuls, Ballmer and Gates, for a long time. One focused primarily on the business side, the other upon the technology. At this point it is only prudent for them to look at leadership succession. Larson-Greene has real technical chops and has worked on compilers, Office, UX, and Windows. Teller went from receptionist to CFO at Great Plains, leading them through both an IPO and Microsoft's acquisition. It is clear that the future leaders will be from the post IPO generation of Softies. It may be clear now that the tradional pointed elbows approach to the throne is frowned upon.
- Permit 14y ago>The sexism upon which this statement is partially premised aside... What?
- brudgers 14y agoWhy does direct reporting indicate Ballmer is taking a more direct role in Windows management rather than indicating that both Larson-Greene and Reller have been given a degree of authority equivalent to that Sinofsky had? Sinofsky was reporting directly to Ballmer before his resignation. If he was fired, of course Ballmer fired him himself. Sinofsky was his direct report. People only report directly to the CEO because they are seen as capable of acting largely with autonomy. It's a sign of trust, not incompetence. The conclusion that Ballmer would micromanage Larson-Greene is absurd. He doesn't have the technical chops. The suggestion that he would do so with Reller, ignores her demonstrated professional competence. The most likely case is that Sinofsky is gone so that they could be promoted. This probably wasn't a crisis, but something brewing for a long time. The issues with Office under Windows 8 RT were due to structural issues with Sinofsky's management approach. It's the "Clearly" that makes it sexist.
- kvb 14y ago
- steve8918 14y agoThe real culprit that needs to be fired is Steve Ballmer. He was great from the inception of MSFT until maybe the turn of the century, when their business strategy of making and maintaining a Windows monopoly worked beautifully and extremely profitably. However, he is living in a legacy environment where he believes he needs to protect the Windows/Office monopoly BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY, and he and the rest of Microsoft can't keep up with everyone else around them because of innovation. This mindset has completely stymied any sort of innovation at Microsoft because they are playing with one arm tied behind their backs in the midst of trying to compete against the likes of Google, Facebook, etc. In Steve Ballmer's eyes, everything must lead back to the sale of a license of Windows/Office, and that no longer works in their environment. If Microsoft engineers had free rein to make the best search engine, or the best phone, or the best tablet, without worries about how will it lead to maintaining their revenue streams of Windows and more importantly Office, then I think their offerings would be on an order of magnitude better and more creative.
- j_baker 14y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Six_phases_of_a_big_project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Six_phases_of_a_big_project The six phases of a project: 1. Enthusiasm 2. Disillusionment 3. Panic 4. Search for the guilty 5. Punishment of the innocent 6. Rewards for the uninvolved This is the way it seems to have played out (and the way project/startup failure almost always seems to play out).
- specialist 14y agoAwesome. Thank you. Very similar to the "process" I've witnessed and documented. From memory: 1) Assemble non-experts, non-stakeholders 2) Misidentify problem 3) Establish quorum 4) Do not communicate decisions 5) Everyone runs off in separate directions 6) Assign blame 7) Repeat. Given the challenges of organizational psychology (aka herding kittens), where trying harder won't change outcomes, I support the strategy of multiple competing teams, as detailed in the book Design Rules: The Power of Modularity. http://www.amazon.com/Design-Rules-Vol-Power-Modularity/dp/0262024667/ http://www.amazon.com/Design-Rules-Vol-Power-Modularity/dp/0...
- programminggeek 14y agoIt's worth noting that Ballmer has publicly laughed in the face of two of the biggest innovations in the last 5 years - the iPhone and the iPad. Now they're racing to catch up. It seems like Ballmer, Sinofsky, and Gates pushed out people building products along those lines - J. Allard and co. only to pick up their vision later with Metro UI and Windows 8. (J. Allard and his team were behind Xbox, Zune, and Courier which basically gave a roadmap to Metro UI, Windows Phone 7 and Windows 8. J Allard also wrote a famous memo about internet connected apps back in 1994.) Sinofsky and Ballmer also pushed out Ray Ozzie who was trying to make cloud computing a meaningful part of Microsoft's future. Now that all the big vision is gone, where is Microsoft going to go? Continue to be a fast follower of Apple and Google? Microsoft is a company without vision because it already achieved what it set out to - a computer on every desk. They won that battle. In the meantime, people's desks already have computers on them and are putting computers in their pockets, purses, and appliances. Microsoft was too busy with traditional computers to have a vision for mobile computing. Maybe Microsoft should change their company goal to a computer in every pocket. Or a Microsoft app on every home screen. Or every computer to be powered by Windows. Or maybe a computer on every surface. Without a big goal, Microsoft is going to be just another big tech company like IBM. It won't change the world again. It already did. Now it's just following everybody else.
- cooldeal 14y ago>It's worth noting that Ballmer has publicly laughed in the face of two of the biggest innovations in the last 5 years - the iPhone and the iPad. Now they're racing to catch up. Copy pasting from one of my previous comments. I'm tired of these kinds of statements. The golden rule is that companies' employee publicly have to put down their competitors' new strategies. Imagine if Balmer said the iPad is great it's going to kill us, or if Jobs said 7" tablets are good but we'll make only in two years, so wait for us to make it. Or even Andy Rubin saying that Android UI is laggy compared to iOS, fix coming in 18 months. All of them(except maybe Jobs) would be summarily fired or atleast will be forced to recant their statements immediately on threat of being fired. It's almost part of their job to publicly mock their competitors, or their shareholders will dump the stock. Privately they could be pissing in their pants about their competition, but you almost never hear about that except after maybe 5 years from unnamed sources. Care to think for a moment why? The more puzzling thing to me is, why do so many otherwise smart people actually think that these people publicly say what they really believe and really believe what they publicly say?
- debacle 14y ago> Larson-Green is best known as a driving force behind the new Windows 8 UI and, prior to that, the Office ribbon bar. How can I dislike this woman so strongly when I've never met her?
- MichaelGG 14y agoYou might try watching the "Story of the Ribbon" presentation, or just read the articles on Jensen Harris's blog. The amount of research, data, and care that went into designing the Ribbon is astounding. I'm not sure what other approaches work, when you need to present thousands of commands to end users. I wasn't a fan of the Ribbon on first sight, but when reading how they came up with it, it's clear this wasn't just some arbitrary cosmetic adjustment. Contrast that to the Office 2013 design, with it's random all-caps on items in no apparent pattern. http://blogs.msdn.com/b/jensenh/archive/2008/03/12/the-story-of-the-ribbon.aspx http://blogs.msdn.com/b/jensenh/archive/2008/03/12/the-story...
- debacle 14y agoThis is one area where I side with Jobs. No amount of research can compete with smart designers.
- kvb 14y agoSurely the combination of research and smart designers is better than either in isolation, though, right? Do you have evidence that the designers of the ribbon were not "smart"? Are you aware of a better design for surfacing hundreds of features? Clearly, standard menu bars weren't working. The combination of the ribbon plus the quick access toolbar seems quite elegant to me...
- debacle 14y agoOutlook is probably one of the most complicated non-admin pieces of software that Windows users use, and I find it completely impossible to do real things in 2010 - in fact, it took me way longer than it should have to even figure out that I was running Outlook 2010. There are conventions to any interface. In Windows, Help -> About will tell you what version of a piece of software you're using most of the time, but for some reason Outlook feels that I need to go to File -> Help -> Additional Version and Copyright Information. Disregarding decades of convention because a handful of wankers with a whiteboard say so is a recipe for failure. I find LibreOffice far easier to use than newer versions of Microsoft Office precisely because their navigation isn't a convoluted wad of deuce. There is a reason that Visual Studio, Visio, and Project don't have the ribbon interface - it's not better for anyone who actually knows how to use a computer. The ribbon interface was designed for a mythical group of people that hadn't ever used Windows-style context menus in 2005. Maybe as an emergent, intuitive interface for people who've never sent an email, the ribbon is great, but it's different than any other piece of software out there, and I've never met anyone who actually prefers it.
- ww520 14y agoIs there a chance Gates would go back to Microsoft? Jobs did go back to Apple to revive it.
- evo_9 14y agoI keep wondering the exact same thing and yeah people alway say 'now way' but you have to wonder, as a founder, it's got to be hard to watch your former company struggling so hard at this point. I keep thinking back to the mid-90's when Gates sent out his famous internet tidal-wave email; that was how he reacted to a threat to MS's longterm survival - a huge pivot away from multimedia, cds/dvds (remember Encarta?) to focusing everything on the Internet. Ballmer in 2005 facing a similar tidal-wave does what? Laughs and mocks the iPhone then the iPad. Had he reacted as Gates had and pivoted the entire company then instead of 6+ years later with Window 8/Surface, who knows where they'd be right now.
- kvb 14y agoOr maybe he has a different perspective on what would constitute "struggling". The company did post its highest revenues ever this year, right?
- jlgreco 14y agoI think the idea is that for a company with as much resources as Microsoft, "doing really well" is not actually all that great. They should/could be an absolute juggernaut.
- brudgers 14y agoGates never left. He's the largest shareholder and chairman of the board.
- flyinRyan 14y agoAfter reading comments from Gates lately, I'd say he's as clueless as Ballmer is about how to break into the tablet/phone market.
- raganwald 14y agoThis hatchet job reads like Ballmer put it out to make it seem like he's a great manager and did a wonderful thing firing Sinofsky. I smell "The Submarine," the unseen hand of a PR company carefully managing public perception.
- waynecochran 14y agoThe article shows two women in two different pictures with no sub-titles. Are these just random stock photos or is one of them Sinofsky? If so, who is is the other?
- colkassad 14y ago"...Windows VPs Julie Larson-Green and Tami Reller..." Had to mouse-over to figure that out.