5 ms·
Alternative for Germany (Alternativ für Deutschland, AfD) is a party that wants to revoke citizenship of brown people and expel them from the country. There are
by inigyou 4mo ago
Alternative for Germany (Alternativ für Deutschland, AfD) is a party that wants to revoke citizenship of brown people and expel them from the country. There are very good reasons they should be banned. Their opposition to chat control is completely incidental.
- on_the_train 4mo ago[flagged]
- master-lincoln 4mo agothe party program doesn't state it, but some high figures were caught talking about it. E.g. Björn Höcke and Maximilian Krah. They did not mention "brown people" as gp states, but called out people foreign to the local culture.
- u8080 4mo agoWhat's so undemocratic if current inhabitants of some land do not want foreign culture influence in their society?
- master-lincoln 4mo agoWho said it's undemocratic? Throwing out citizens because of some birth attribute they can not influence could be seen as inhumane. Would you think it's ok to throw out everybody with a certain eye color?
- u8080 4mo agoYou said "foreign culture", now you are moving goalposts. Culture is not birth attribute.
- master-lincoln 4mo agook fair, I interpreted their language. But then it needs to be defined what is local culture and what is foreign. And people would need to get the same treatment independently of their background. That is not what the AfD argues.
- u8080 4mo ago>people would need to get the same treatment independently of their background This point of view is seems actually widely represented in German politics >That is not what the AfD argues. Ironically AfD leader is a lesbian married with immigrant Sri-lankian woman, so I doubt your claims.
- izend 4mo ago[flagged]
- inigyou 4mo agodid your AI train on the Potsdam meeting notes that leaked to journalists?
- izend 4mo ago[flagged]
- pebble 4mo agoI see nothing here rebuking the above claim. Maybe you would’ve had better luck coming up with something if you had bothered to write it yourself.
- fc417fc802 4mo agoThe claim was that they want to deport citizens. The above list does not contain any entries that correspond to citizens. So unless you believe the above list to be incomplete or somehow otherwise in error it is a sound refutation of the original claim. I'm inclined to vouch for the comment however I'm not clear if the self admitted AI copy and paste is in keeping with the current HN guidelines.
- vrganj 4mo agoMaybe don't trust AI so much. Obviously the fascists don't put their most odious ideas in writing, they plan them in secret instead. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/19/turmoil-in-germany-over-neo-nazi-mass-deportation-meeting-explained https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/jan/19/turmoil-in-ger...
- izend 4mo ago[flagged]
- 4mo ago
- earth-tattoo 4mo ago[flagged]
- ribosometronome 4mo agoYour quote is very different from the situation you describe. Revoking citizenship is different than no pathway to citizenship. A pathway to citizenship is not open doors.
- bpbp-mango 4mo agoa country can change its mind though
- earth-tattoo 4mo agoEspecially by voting in a party that says it will do it. That's democracy, right?
- ribosometronome 4mo agoWhy would you care about democracy? Plenty of countries don't have it. Why should America and Europe hold themselves up to such naive, idealistic standards with Middle Eastern countries around who aren't doing the same? That's essentially the point you made, while conflating pulling the rug out from under people's feet because they've committed the crime of being brown with never having made the offer in the first place.
- master-lincoln 4mo ago> Why would you care about democracy? Plenty of countries don't have it Because living in these countries usually comes with significant downsides for minorities. E.g. most middle east countries are limiting freedom for women compared to men.
- ribosometronome 4mo ago
- fc417fc802 4mo agoThis appears to be blatant misinformation. They want to expel various noncitizens and remove or restrict various pathways to citizenship. It's important not to misrepresent others even when you vehemently disagree with them.
- athrowaway3z 4mo agoThere are other (voices in other) parties that want to expel/restrict foreigners. There is a spectrum, and the AfD holds a rather large portion of the people tentatively agreeing with what you call misrepresentation. How many people of their party must make such statements while being welcome in the party, for it to not be misinformation/misrepresentation.
- modo_mario 4mo agoBelgium can revoke citizenship of dual nationals on certain ground. What off it?
- inigyou 4mo agoWhat are the certain grounds?
- account42 4mo agoDemocracy, as long as everyone votes for what you want, right?
- kvgr 4mo agoI mean, yeah. They push some things that would help - to sell its ideas to peole, but in the end if they got to power they would tripple down and do horrible things. If the german government and its parties actually listened to people, the AFD would have like 5% and would be non issue. Same with all extremist parties tht try to latch on some idea to get voted in.