3 ms·
> It could be solved by making it a criminal offense to materially mislead the public while holding office The problem would be how you define that in law and
by _heimdall 3mo ago
> It could be solved by making it a criminal offense to materially mislead the public while holding office
The problem would be how you define that in law and enforce it in the real world.
Its already hard enough to legally distinguish between a lie, misrepresentation, and someone telling what is wrong but they honestly believe to be true given what they know at the time. How do you define that?
And for politicians who are regularly working with state secrets, politically sensitive information, confidential/classified documents, etc how could you ever actually catch them in a lie?
- rbanffy 3mo ago> Its already hard enough to legally distinguish between a lie, misrepresentation, and someone telling what is wrong but they honestly believe to be true You can’t and you shouldn’t. People in power need to be careful with the information they give the people they serve. If it’s wrong at the time it was communicated, too bad. The person should have been more careful.
- _heimdall 3mo agoI'm not sure how that could work. If we can't distinguish between those how would you write enforceable laws or regulations? Its all well and good to have a blanket statement that politicians shouldn't lie. It entirely different to codify such an aspiration.