This corruption doesn't have anything to do with the "Rails Way". The corruption was at a much lower level then things like nil foreign keys, long fields, etc.

This corruption doesn't have anything to do with the "Rails Way". The corruption was at a much lower level then things like nil foreign keys, long fields, etc. that Rails validates. It was the filesystem that was corrupted, and whether he did database validation in ActiveRecord, using database validations, or both would not have made a difference, as far as I can tell. Think about it for a second - if the corruption that caused this was things that could be validated using Ruby or in SQL declarations, it would to more than feasible to import that data into some format form which it could be recovered.