3 ms·
First, a government-granted monopoly is only one kind of monopoly. Surely you have read enough economics since the 17th century to be aware of that? Even Adam S
by _delirium 14y ago
First, a government-granted monopoly is only one kind of monopoly. Surely you have read enough economics since the 17th century to be aware of that? Even Adam Smith discussed it as a possibility.
Secondly, there is not actually a growing presence of Objectivist philosophers, excluding those who are explicitly bought, like Roderick T. Long. If you want a demolition of her philosophical views from people who are politically sympathetic to libertarianism, see Robert Nozick's "On the Randian Argument", or Murray N. Rothbard's "The Sociology of the Ayn Rand Cult". Rothbard's satirical play, "Mozart was a Red!" [1], is also somewhat funny, though it is not very well-produced.
[1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9mGpMpaHGM4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9mGpMpaHGM4
- javert 14y agoRoderick Long is not an Objectivist. I don't know how you calculate Objectivist presence in academia, but I strongly suspect the numbers are growing, although I think that growth will probably plateau soon (but maybe I'm wrong). But, that doesn't really matter. Do you not think that all academic philosophers are bought? (OK, I know what you mean, though.) views from people who are politically sympathetic to libertarianism People who are sympathetic to libertarianism are (generally) anti-Objectivist, since they are basically a splinter group off of Objectivism, so that doesn't really mean anything. Anything by Rothbard can pretty much be dismissed out of hand, especially with a factually incorrect title like that. I think I've seen it before, but I'll double check. I think I've also see Nozick's "On the Randian Argument," and found that he hadn't actually grasped AR's methodology at all and had not made a legitimate critique, but I will double check that, too.