3 ms·

Vibe-coded. Sorry. https://github.com/514-labs/dnsglobe/blob/c29802162636832e88b56bbb205e6c773c254e5b/src/dns.rs#L69 https://github.com/514-labs/dnsglobe/blob/

Vibe-coded. Sorry. https://github.com/514-labs/dnsglobe/blob/c29802162636832e88b56bbb205e6c773c254e5b/src/dns.rs#L69 https://github.com/514-labs/dnsglobe/blob/c29802162636832e88... You take the `other`, do a `to_string()` on it, which creates a String representation. Then you pass a reference to that String, and, in the case it doesn't contain `time out` or `timeout` or `refused`, the reference gets turned AGAIN into a String (i.e. new allocation), truncated to 48, and then returned. There is no check whether that the character at the 48th byte is a character boundary. Add to that the fact that this is a Rust project with the oldest commit created yesterday and it is using the 2021 edition. Be better.

Callicles 3mo ago
This was 100% vibe-coded with Claude Code and Fable. https://x.com/thatsFrScience/status/2073741209592295866 https://x.com/thatsFrScience/status/2073741209592295866 Thanks for the feedback, though, and for taking the time to look at the code. I can ship a round of cleanup.
orangeboats 3mo ago
It's gotten to the point that the moment I see "Rust" and "TUI" together, I immediately assume it's vibe coded. The combination just seems to be vibe coders' favorite, for some reason.
- zx8080 3mo ago
  > The combination just seems to be vibe coders' favorite, for some reason. It's the secret key to HN front page!
- blacklite 3mo ago
  That's not whose favorite it is; it's the favorite of who's doing the work. :)
- inigyou 3mo ago
  It must be because if you program in Rust, you don't have bugs ;)
rvz 3mo ago
Quite mixed on this one given that the author has experience with Rust before coding agents and this is just his toy project. There is going to be a time where these vibe coded projects have silent bugs, vulnerabilities or unnecessary performance issues and the AI coding agent just lies to the user that it has none. The AI agent will be the one to introduce new issues in the codebase regardless of "tests". The new issue is now the non-technical human vibe-coding is none the wiser. We have already seen this in Codex itself. Imagine this propagated in many other code-bases.
- rickydroll 3mo ago
  Having created and debugged human-written code with silent bugs, vulnerabilities, or unnecessary performance issues since my first day on the job, and pointing you to myriad companies with bugs and vulnerabilities that existed pre-AI, all I can say is "plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose."
seamossfet 3mo ago
Nothing wrong with vibecoding a toy project.
- teddyh 3mo ago
  There is if you present it to others without telling anyone it’s slop.
  - bcjdjsndon 3mo ago
    For some vague reason you can't really articulate, that's a bad thing?
Callicles 3mo ago
Addressed the feedback
egorfine 3mo ago
The very first thing written about this tool is the programming language it's written in. Like, when I'm querying a bunch of DNS servers, it is crucial for me to know which compilable language it was written in. Like, the most important thing.

Callicles 3mo ago

This was 100% vibe-coded with Claude Code and Fable. https://x.com/thatsFrScience/status/2073741209592295866 https://x.com/thatsFrScience/status/2073741209592295866 Thanks for the feedback, though, and for taking the time to look at the code. I can ship a round of cleanup.

orangeboats 3mo ago

It's gotten to the point that the moment I see "Rust" and "TUI" together, I immediately assume it's vibe coded. The combination just seems to be vibe coders' favorite, for some reason.

zx8080 3mo ago
> The combination just seems to be vibe coders' favorite, for some reason. It's the secret key to HN front page!
blacklite 3mo ago
That's not whose favorite it is; it's the favorite of who's doing the work. :)
inigyou 3mo ago
It must be because if you program in Rust, you don't have bugs ;)

rvz 3mo ago

Quite mixed on this one given that the author has experience with Rust before coding agents and this is just his toy project. There is going to be a time where these vibe coded projects have silent bugs, vulnerabilities or unnecessary performance issues and the AI coding agent just lies to the user that it has none. The AI agent will be the one to introduce new issues in the codebase regardless of "tests". The new issue is now the non-technical human vibe-coding is none the wiser. We have already seen this in Codex itself. Imagine this propagated in many other code-bases.

rickydroll 3mo ago
Having created and debugged human-written code with silent bugs, vulnerabilities, or unnecessary performance issues since my first day on the job, and pointing you to myriad companies with bugs and vulnerabilities that existed pre-AI, all I can say is "plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose."

seamossfet 3mo ago

Nothing wrong with vibecoding a toy project.

teddyh 3mo ago
There is if you present it to others without telling anyone it’s slop.
- bcjdjsndon 3mo ago
  For some vague reason you can't really articulate, that's a bad thing?

Callicles 3mo ago

Addressed the feedback

egorfine 3mo ago

The very first thing written about this tool is the programming language it's written in. Like, when I'm querying a bunch of DNS servers, it is crucial for me to know which compilable language it was written in. Like, the most important thing.